The Micarta has a more textured feel and as a manmade material it is uneffected by hot or cold (it won't swell or contract) and it actually gets grippier when wet. I agree that the wood inlays look nicer and are in some cases less expensive than the Micarta and to be fair the stabilzed wood is very durable and holds up well under use and if it gets scratched it can be refinished. I've never heard of anyone having any trouble with the wood and if you do have any trouble CRK will make it right. Personally I think of the Micarta as the ultimate utilitarian inlay. With the available serrations I think it makes it a very versitle knife. I guess it comes down to personal choice, I like it because it looks "tougher". That may sound immature but that's what I think. It just think it really looks cool.