Would these knives be good to practice sharpening on?

I think the steel on those is probably just TOO bad to get good experience. Buy a beater knife, that is,.. one that you can still use, but don't care about keeping in great shape. You can find something in 440C, AUS8, or ATS34 pretty cheap.
 
I wouldn't spend that for practice. don't you have some cheepos lying around ?

I love the pic of the spider-man carry; yea thats how I carry mine. :eek: :rolleyes:
 
High carbon is about the easiest to learn on, try a mora, or Opinel, and as Hammurabi says, Old Hickory at a yard sale, or thrift shop.
 
Pick up something in 440C or AUS8.. super easy to sharpen, but still a functional knife. You can actually get something you might like and use!
 
Honestly, I've found quite a few el-cheapo knives that seem to not be able to take ANY edge. For example, I can sharpen a BUTTER knife better than this $1 cheapo knife I bought at Wal-Mart. It simply won't sharpen.
 
The bad thing about practicing on really cheap knives is that you may never know for sure if your technique is good. Very cheap knives are made (usually) with junk steel. It may never be able to take a decent edge, even if you're doing it right. That makes for a lot of frustration.

You'd be much better off spending that same $25 on one, or maybe two, older used knives from reputable makers (Case, Buck, Ka-bar) whose quality is well established. They've always used decent steel (excellent, in many cases), and their blades respond amazingly well to good sharpening technique. It'll leave no doubt when you get to the point where you're doing it right. You'll be rewarded with a knife that you'll be proud to carry and use and show to your friends. Those eBay 'mall ninja specials' will always look (and probably perform) like cheap knives, regardless of whether they've been sharpened or not. And they're not exactly the practical type of knife you want to carry everywhere and show 'em off, unless you're really into scaring people.
 
Good to the recycle shop and find a kitchen knife with a darkly stained blade. It will be made of good carbon steel and should be perfect for sharpening practice. Don't get one with a bright silver looking blade. Be sure the blade is dark, perhaps with a blueish tinge to it. You might just luck out and have yourself one damn fine knife when you're finished!

Stitchawl
 
Back
Top