WW I Mk II on ebay

Joined
Mar 9, 1999
Messages
1,440
Did anyone notice the very nice Mk II kukri that sold for $463 on eBay? It is a beauty and looks untouched or the blade was professionally repolished leaving the numbers crisp and intact.

This is the highest price I have ever seen for this model and it doesn't have the rare frog. Pretty amazing plus the guy has to pay shipping from England.
 
this one?


i-1.JPG
 
Pen, that's a pretty nice kothimora, but this was your basic WW I Mk II. Wonder what the details are on the picture you showed though?
 
N2S - I think you've got it right.

The one I was looking at closed at $550.

Item # 2519229551

Detail:
i-4.JPG
 
Why I torture myself thus when broke, I can't say.

Any informative comments appreciated. Maybe I can learn enough to try buying an old one sometime.

i-1.JPG

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=2170557190&category=4074
current $75.00

blade is stamped "Military Supply Syndicate" Said to be WWII. Significance of stamp?

i-3.JPG

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=2170610821&category=475
current $36.00

NICE MILITARY KUKRI WWI WWII?? THIS 17IN. KUKRI IS IN GOOD SHAPE BONE HANDLE Will bone get to be this color and have the blade and scabbard be in reasonably good condition if the knife is as old as claimed? Or does the seller have bone and horn mixed up?

i-1.JPG

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=2170780458&category=20271
current $24.00

Said to modern nepali-made. Note eye of dove cho. "Real" tool, or tourist stuff? Looks like a Chainpuri in the FAQ. Were I not broke, I'd be tempted to take a chance on it. I like this variant.

i-3.JPG

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=2171064169&category=13966
Current $60.00

Said to be WWI . Is this a MK II or M43? It has steel rivets, not brass. Does lack of ridges on handle indicate M43? WWII era instead?

[edited to fix a couple of pix]
 
John Powell wrote:
Did anyone notice the very nice Mk II kukri that sold for $463 on eBay? It is a beauty and looks untouched or the blade was professionally repolished leaving the numbers crisp and intact.This is the highest price I have ever seen for this model and it doesn't have the rare frog. Pretty amazing plus the guy has to pay shipping from England.
Military kukris always fetch premium prices on eBay. This is why I only have 1 of them out of the 65 or so hanging around here. I think their value is determined by their association with combat, not by their merit as kukris. Especially since they are usually almost factory made, and therefore lack the personal craftsmanship of village kukris of the same vintage. For almost five hundred bucks you could get a lovely kothimora with a dui chirra blade and lots of native silver, or this bare bones arsenal made jobby where the numbers stamped on the blade are the only distinguishing features.
Obviously, I'm trying to start a discussion about what constitutes a "collectible" kukri by touting my favorites over the military models. Any rejoinders from fans of the military models?
Berk
 
I'm trying to start a discussion about what constitutes a "collectible" kukri by touting my favorites over the military models. Any rejoinders from fans of the military models?

Everyone collects to their own objective. To some a military knife like this represents a real piece of history. Unlike most khukuries this one can be directly linked to a particular unit (sometimes to a specific individual) and placed on battlefied at a specific point in time. There are prettier ones out there, but, this one is a real veteran; and, it can take it's rightful place among the badges, flags, uniforms, and other military paraphernalia of a long forgotten conflict.

n2s
 
Berk,
I have found that the collectors of military kukris are a bit more "fanatical/enthused" than the collector of all types. The reason the prices are so high is because of their value to 3 types of collectors: military, edged weapons, kukri nuts. As you know I collect all types, but have found the value of many of my military pieces have surpassed some of the finest kothimoras. Of course everyone wants ivory. One of the highest end pieces combines both: an ivory gripped M43. Second only in rarity to the metal gripped M43.

Firkin:
1. post 1947 standard early issue Indian military in use by the Gurkha
(Gorkha) Regiments that opted not to stay with the English Army.
2. post WW II standard Indian military issue for Gurkha units and
some police.
3. New "eye of the dove" with chainpuri grip. Probably well made
except for the karda and chakmak.
4. the seller is a good guy, but this is a WW II MkII. I don't know
what his reserve is, but it certainly isn't $60.
 
Many thanks, John. At least I filtered out the tourist pieces.

I'm not a collector, by any stretch of the imagination, but I'm kinda with Berk here. I find the traditional, individually made khuks more interesting in general. The variations seem nearly endless, and thanks to folks like J.P. and others, the regional affiliation can be found. They all seem to feel different, and could have been made for a specific task, or person. They can be uniquely decorated. It's like a tiny bit of a varied culture.

I'd rather a few of those than an assembly of nearly identical military pieces made in a factory. The military pieces with a genuine interesting provenance I probably couldn't afford anyway. A military khuk old enough to have been individually made for the user instead of cranked out to specs, would be as interesting to me as the traditional styles.

Some does seem to have a real fixation with the military aspect though, from the number of essentially non-military issue khuks offered as "fighting knives", daggers, etc, or bearing phony military provenance.

Why an essentially mass-produced khuk made to unvarying military specs is thought to be inherently more interesting than a unique, individually hand made piece is beyond me. Especially since the Ghorka's may very well have been making the history with a khuk from the village instead of the issue model.
 
Have the best of both worlds: find a kukri made in Nepal and then the owner joined either the British Military regiments, or the Nepalese Army. These are great traditional knives transformed into military mufti. The Gurkhas were allowed to carry their own knives into the field as long as they had the proper issue item for parade. I have 7 of this type from the mid 1800s thru WW II.

You can also look for Nepalese made military pieces from 1900 or earlier. They still had certain requirements, but have all the charm of a traditional kukri.

I think the FAQ may have some Nepalese made military pieces shown. If not. I'll be glad to send Berk some pix to post. Just ask.
 
Here is a pix of four pieces for the forum gang. I will send some of pre-1900 if there is any interest. Also threw in some Gurkhali to confuse the issue.

1. Nepal Army 1930-1940

2. Nepal Army 1940-1950

3. British Regiment (poss 6th GR)
Nepali made 1940-1945

4. Nepal Army 1920-1940

2 and 4 have 'pana butta' (riveted grips) and have great ek chirra blades
All have metal butt plates with peened over tangs and various keepers
2 is horn and is the only 'chiruwa' (scale) set of grips
All furniture is metal except 2 which is 'chandi' (silver). This kukri is very 'bishesh' (special)
Well made and it looks as if they all saw a lot of action and utility work
The 'kardas' and 'chakmaks' are all of various types and have probably been lost and replaced at least once
1 has no space for k &c or 'kalti' (pouch). I think this 'dap' (scabbard) was rebuilt after initial service
 
Back
Top