You Say To-Mah-To, I Say. . . . . . . .

waynorth

Knifemaker / Craftsman / Service Provider
Joined
Nov 19, 2005
Messages
32,753
What is it with this knife? Pocket knives shouldn't be nearly 4" long, and feel so good in your pocket!
I carried a big Congress knife in my Bib Jeans, but I had help holding it up (the Bib!).
I don't wear Bibs any more, so I don't think of a Congress as a choice of EDC.
But then there's that shiny Red plastic with the unlikely name of "Tomato Acrylic"!
Now knives are bone and steel, wood and some other metals. Manly natural stuff, like fire and burning meat! Ruff, ruff!
But, well . . .you couldn't lose this knife in a Blizzard - so I guess that puts it in the "Yeller" (never lose it) school of knives; venerable - - - - and - - - it does kinda remind me of fire - - - -and burning meat!!! Ruff ruff ruff!
But, the old knives are the best, right?? With all due respect to the talented custom makers around here, the Wilfredians, and Waupacans; the Okies and . . well, you know who you are! Those Customs are in an Uber-class of knife.
But there are all those nice old antiques around! Some even inspire the Uber-Makers!
For a reasonably priced carry for a Bluish-collared guy like me, I've enjoyed a humble Robeson Barlow, a Case greenbone 6347 - old stuff from the World War eras, when men were men, and knives were proudly hafted!
(more Ruffs!)
Well men are still men (mostly), but knives sometimes don't measure up. Sometimes they are even made by people we'll never know.
But this is a new knife! It's got a modern look to it. It ain't old.
But then, it's got some home-spun goodness too! Made by people I know! Proudly in America!
It sits easy in my right front pocket. It snaps proudly, but doesn't rip my dried out old-man thumbnail. Just right!
And that pointy Wharncliffe blade goes right in and opens that dunning notice from the IRS like nobody's business! It's sturdy enough to peel and core a Granny Smith, or whittle a Cedar stick down to a satisfying pile of shavings. But is has genteel sunk joints, and smoothly rounded ends, so it doesn't wear my pockets out, and in this economy, that's good!
I like all the Etches! Go ahead and argue that one, but they remind me of the old Cattaraugus and Holley etc. catalogs! Michigan Pen, King of the Woods, Real Harness Knife etc. were etched or stamped on some of those old, proudly made knives. A bit of advertising hooey, but it was Cool hooey!
I shouldn't like this knife, but I do. I like everything about it. It all fits nicely, came nicely honed, and I am going to enjoy watching the Etching fade into the patina, and I am going to use this knife for a long time!
I think it's as good as the old Robeys, Cases and Catts! It's a good 'un fer sure!
Tomato 1.jpg
Tomato 2.jpg
Tomato 3.jpg
 
Last edited:
I like everything about it. It all fits nicely, came nicely honed, and I am going to enjoy watching the Etching fade into the patina, and I am going to use this knife for a long time!
I think it's as good as the old Robeys, Cases and Catts! It's a good 'un fer sure!

That's a heck of an endorsement coming from you Charlie.

I like this model, especially the versions like yours with the subtler swedging. I think I need to get one of the raisin jigged bone knives, it looks as if it'd make a dandy whittler.

- Christian
 
Nice, Charlie. Yours has particularly nice, even swirls in the acrylic (it's almost worse than stag for buying sight unseen) and I dig the round bolsters.
I wish the smaller blade was a pen to go with the Wharncliffe, but it's still a great little pocket tickler. :thumbup:
 
It's got a single backspring, Christian - nice and slim, but the handle is good sized, providing a good grip!
This baby would have passed muster in 1920! Probably woulda sold for at least a Dollar or so!!:)
 
It's got a single backspring, Christian - nice and slim, but the handle is good sized, providing a good grip!
This baby would have passed muster in 1920! Probably woulda sold for at least a Dollar or so!!:)

In that case I'll take a baker's dozen. Accounting for inflation, in 1920 $1 has the same buying power as $11.60 today.

Better make that a gross. :D

- Christian
 
Charlie, I love it when you drink Wild Turkey with Redbull chasers and review knives...
 
That really is a nice new pattern for them. Nice intro Charlie. That one just looks as pocket friendly as they come.

What is it's closed length? (when you have a chance).
 
For you, Gus, I have put everything on hold (except for the Wild Turkey) to measure the knife, just as quickly as I can!
It is 3 and 13/16" long; a hefty length for a lighter knife!

Corey, why say in ten words what you can say in several hundred!! (I always say! . . . .and say!. . . . .and say!!):D
 
I was just ogling/fondling this knife out on my sunny deck. (76 U.S.degrees in this Coastal Rain Forest).
Old waterfall celluloid has got nothing on this Toe-may-toe stuff!!! Ruff, ruff!!
 
It is 3 and 13/16" long; a hefty length for a lighter knife!

I think GEC hit a home run with this one. Sure would like it to be 3 1/2" or so but that's just me.

Does it have half stops? How's the action? I'm debating my next GEC ATM. Thanks for the pics... that's a great looking slippy.
 
That's a heck of an endorsement coming from you Charlie.

I like this model, especially the versions like yours with the subtler swedging. I think I need to get one of the raisin jigged bone knives, it looks as if it'd make a dandy whittler.

- Christian

It does.

 
Last edited:
Keith it has half stops! I LOVE half stops!! Perfect amount of smooth snap in all positions.
It walks and talks with the best!!!

Nice to see one with some miles on it Jack. I take it you are enjoying using it!?
 
Nice write-up, Charlie. The #62s are my favorite GEC pattern to date. The whittler version--a true split-backspring job with a nice tapered spacer--is pretty sweet, too (though no halfstop on the master, which is as it should be for a whittler).

GEC62CourthouseWhittler05.jpg
 
What a lovely bunch of coconuts, Rick!! Makes my Tomato feel kinda lonely!:rolleyes:

Seriously, you have the bases covered. The #62 indeed makes a nice whittler! Great collection!!
I couldn't possibly choose a favorite! They are all super!!
 
Oh those are really sweet. Just the right number of blades (for me) and so comfortable in the hand. I don't know about you guys but you can get those blades screaming sharp. Here is mine. oh by the way not my picture--as probably everyone knows.

tomato.jpg
 
Back
Top