Your impressions of Bud Nealy knives

AKY

Joined
Oct 29, 1998
Messages
114
I just traded for a Nealy Aikuchi. Thanks Chris! Can't wait to receive it.

Those of you who have Nealy knives, please tell me how you like them. All I know is what I've read in magazines. The usual stuff like fit and finish, edge retension, etc.

Thanks,
Tony
 
The MCS is neat. Just stay away from the neoprene handled ones. The handles were all coming off on the ones I've seen w/that type of handle material.
 
I am of two mind regarding several of Nealy's designs. On the one hand, I think the combination of different bevel grinds on the same blade is smart in some ways and sub-optimal in others. On a couple of his designs he has a fairly thin edged hollow grind over most of the blade which transitions to a thick-edged flat grind near the tip. I like that for a tactical blade as you have a good cutting edge for the most part, and a strong tip. The transition between the grinds does interfere with smooth continuous cutting. That is not a big issue for a blade that was designed for defensive use first. All my blades though have to be good utility knives first, and I will make them work for defense.

The other odd thing about Nealy's designs is that they seem rather optimized for thrusting, vis-a-vis the strong tips I've already mentioned, but are very low on handle curves, finger cutouts, or guards that would stop the hand from sliding up on the blade.

I like his designs, particularly the Kinzhal and the Belledau, but find them a little confusing.

Harv
 
imp - the Aikuchi model I'm getting has green micarta with M2 blade. At least that's what the handle looks like in the picture. I don't think I will ever buy another neoprene handled knife. Although, the Gerbers I've owned were very comfortable.

Steve - Your comments are well taken. I see what you mean about Nealy's designs being more for self-defense. I bought this knife mainly out of curiosity, and it was a price I could live with. His designs have always intrigued me. The Aikuchi appears to have the hollow grind along the length of the blade, transitioning to a stout flat grind at the tip for strength. I should receive it Monday or so.

Take care, and thanks!

Tony
 
Back
Top