I hate dial-up, but still have to suffer with it when I'm on the road as most hotels don't have broadband yet. I had DSL for several years and had a rock solid 600k down/128k up connection and it rocked. Then I got an offer from my cable company where they actually paid me $30.00 per month for the first few months to try their service ($20.00 per month introductory rate with a $50.00 coupon towards total cable bill), so I had both cable and DSL available. I did a long comparison of benchmarking both at various times of the day and the cable connection absolutely rocked at 1.5mb down and 128k up. My ping times in Counter Strike and Unreal Tournament both went down appreciably, so I cancelled the DSL.
Just a few months ago I got a letter from my cable company telling me that as a result of network upgrades, I was going to see a speed improvement, and that there would be no increase in cost to me. Now I'm getting 3mb down and 256k up!!! For some strange reason, about the same time as the speed increase hit, the charges for my cable modem service seem to have disappeared from my cable bill. I keep meaning to call them and ask about that part, but somehow haven't gotten to making that call yet.
John