1095 imparting a metallic taste to food?

So the general consensus is that no one's noticed it with 1095... and in general, it shouldn't be an issue with properly cared for carbon steel.

I'm good with that.

Follow up question:

Given the textured nature of the coating (new in my case), anyone have any cleanliness issues with it for food prep?

Oo, FedEx Santa just dropped off my new BK14... gotta go!

Erik
 
So the general consensus is that no one's noticed it with 1095... and in general, it shouldn't be an issue with properly cared for carbon steel.

I'm good with that.

Follow up question:

Given the textured nature of the coating (new in my case), anyone have any cleanliness issues with it for food prep?

Oo, FedEx Santa just dropped off my new BK14... gotta go!

Erik

1095CV. We have added Chromium and Vanadium. You'll notice our blades don't corrode very fast, or deep. Yeah, its that extra Chrome. :D

New coating is the same as the old coating, just "crinkled". The rest of the shit I cut with it, sticks to it, so, I would imagine so. I mean, you wash something in hot soapy water, and it will come clean.

I've cut chicken, beef, pork, veggies, and noodles with the new coating, and never noticed it sticking to it, say, indefinitely, but as far as "wets" are concerned, the stick to the coating, so, when cutting taters or onions, beware, you might have to flip the blade to get them off.

I prefer uncoated blades myself. Cause they kick ass like Jet Li's foot.

Uncoated blades simply laff at coated blades, for not having the balls to walk around nekkid. I think the word chickenshit was thrown around some too. But, I'm getting old, the hearing, not as good as it used to be.

Moose
 
I have noticed a metal taste when I have eaten apple slices directly off the blade. This was with a fresh forced patina, and I think it was the smell of the blade as much as any real taste. I'll have to do some expermenting and see?

+1
I don't have a becker (yet) but using an opinel in carbon steel, yes it does give a metal taste when I eat apple directly from the blade. . . :)
 
okay, time for some contention :)

if you cut apples, lettuce, or certain other things with *any* iron knive (esp carbon), you WILL get contact oxidation, though lemon juice can deal with that

so, there is a correlation. i was just waiting for someone to say something :D

some stupidly sensitive people might notice that. most won't.

i think one of the reason why MOST won't, is they don't routinely LICK various kinda of metals and/or have a good sense of smell correlated with years of "being aware"... uhm, like me :D yaaaaah, uh, i like things. i smell it. i taste things... i can SMELL several flavors of water in the air. "i know snow"...

if you get someone that is stupidly sensitive, they might notice. me? rarely in food because of knives. though the FOOD might notice.

i can slice paper thin apples with a ceramic or glass knive, and they *do not oxidize* unless my work surface had impurities.

do the same thing with *any* steel based knife? you get *brown* apples (or lettuce...)...

clearly, there is a reaction, and based on color alone, i shall call it rust. this, i can generally *taste*

now, in meat? there, is the advantage, as meat is RICH in iron *anyway*. you are not going to taste nothing.

if you mix a red meat knife (of which i include almost anything but veggies and fish), you might notice. however, as a LOT of food is ideally cook on, or in iron cookware, ..., not so much! go figure, eh? bbq grills? steel, iron. cast iron? duh. other? well, depends. mostly? no?

red meat by itself oxidizes ANYWAY, so "iron helper"? no effect.

thank you for tuning into science today and my opinion...

also, my sense of smell is FREAKY. i know you ate that :)
 
My 14 does not give a metal taste to my food. However, it is one of the only knives I have that does have a strong metallic odor.
 
Back
Top