119 Sheath Survey

TAH

TAH

Joined
Jul 3, 2001
Messages
6,138
All things considered (appearance, function, belt loop placement, material, etc.), if all of these sheaths were available today, which would you choose for your 119 and why?

A
s-l1600.jpg


B
s-l1600.jpg


C
s-l1600.jpg


D
s-l1600.jpg


E
s-l1600.jpg
 
If "B" was the one with the swivel, that would be the one for me. I like the knife lower and I prefer a dangler. Ever sit down in a chair, truck, atv, etc... and have the knife refuse to get out of the way? Me too...

Kudos again to Makael for his GAW a few weeks back. I got the perfect (IMHO) 119 sheath.

The only thing I did that's not in the photo is I threaded a piece of paracord with a knot on it through the hole in the tip of the sheath that I could lash around my leg so it didn't go flailing about too bad.


If my Makael plug and photo detract from your post, let me know and I'll edit my post to remove them.
 
Not at all, Pokt. That's a great looking sheath and similar to Buck's swivel sheath in Photo B. I'll put you down for B. Thanks!
 
Put me down for A, the flap both protects and holds the knife securely; also there is enough opening in the belt loop to allow for adjustment when wearing. C is my least favorite (assuming the fit on the 119 is similar to the fit on my 118 with that type sheath) - it is too tight on the spine and edge of the blade. OH
 
I'm going to agree with Pokt on "B". It's hard to beat the swivel sheath on a knife this size. "A" would be my second choice.

And yes, I'm keeping score. :D

A = 1
B = 2
C = 1
D = 0
E = 0
 
It would be awesome to have a 119 with a left handed flap sheath and a matching 1911 with matching holster.
That would be awesome, especially if the 1911 was stainless with phenolic grips with little buck 119's in them.
 
I like A. Because there is room for embossing one's name or initials on the flap to easily personalize the item or make it a gift.

(And it reminds me of the 119 that was stolen from my home long ago which had my initials on the flap and my name on the blade.)
 
Over the years I have had many different sheaths for the 119. If I were king, I'd likely go with option A. The full flap variety keeps the knife safe and sound. The A version was also the most expensive for Buck to fabricate. To me, the A variety is a veritable classic!
 
I like them all, and each one has it's own benefit, but "E" is the best when considering all aspects. The plastic liner is probably my most favorite innovation.
 
Apparently, my copy and paste likes lower case. :confused:

a = 5
b = 2
c = 1
d = 0
e = 1
 
I like the style of B myself, but I honestly prefer style D...

For hunting and a knife I use you can't beat the Cordura IMHO. I probably don't take the best care of my sheaths and I ruined a leather one from sitting in cold wet duck blinds. I know, I'm the black sheep on this one :D
 
I like 'C' the best. I have some of the others but C is stiffer and has thicker leather. I don't care about a swivel. DM
 
MT_Pokt said:
If "B" was the one with the swivel, that would be the one for me. I like the knife lower and I prefer a dangler. Ever sit down in a chair, truck, atv, etc... and have the knife refuse to get out of the way? Me too...

Kudos again to Makael for his GAW a few weeks back. I got the perfect (IMHO) 119 sheath.

The only thing I did that's not in the photo is I threaded a piece of paracord with a knot on it through the hole in the tip of the sheath that I could lash around my leg so it didn't go flailing about too bad.


If my Makael plug and photo detract from your post, let me know and I'll edit my post to remove them.
Click to expand...

Thanks. I like that sheath quite a bit. I'm glad your enjoying it.
 
"A". The full flap protects the entire handle from the elements (rain, dirt, woods brush, etc). A top flap does not get in the way like the side flaps do in the other designs when deploying the blade. I own a few gun holsters with a similar design and they are excellent for woods carry.
 
I prefer the style C, personally.

I like the handle being free to put a hand on, which I tend to find myself doing.

And I also like the look of the stitching.

best

mqqn
 
I would absolutely love A. In fact, I'd be happy to pay extra for it if re-introduced. I love full flap sheaths, especially in my environment.
 
put me down for A, Tom. I can put the knife away so much safer bouncing in the fishing boat with the pouch style sheath.
 
Thanks for the replies and comments so far. Very interesting.

a = 8
b = 2
c = 3
d = 1
e = 1
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top