3-D Printing a Knife? Is it the beginning of the end of custom knives?

It's not much of an advancement if you ask me. What can a 3-D printer do that a 3-D CNC milling machine can't? CNC is already used extensively in the knife world, in both custom and production manufacture, so how would a 3-D printer be different? The real allure of a 3-D printer is it allows a consumer to utilize a more user-friendly, less precise version of CNC in their own home. If the day comes where a 3-D printer has the same capabilities of a $10,000 CNC machine while remaining affordable, I imagine the CNC would be even more affordable, though I don't think either will happen.
 
I believe that plastic variants will be developed in the future, to be hard enough to create a good knife.
Imagine something like the cold steel plastic line, but good.
The raw material in contact with air, after heating, shaping, and cooling, could be very well designed to be cheap as material, and using a cheap plastic 3d printing, not a metal one.
As a dedicated mall ninja and armchair commando,I would buy and print all kind of tactical black weapons in a plastic hard enoughto be sharpened and retain an edge. Light, undetectable by metal scanners, black color, a tacticool dorkops wet dream.

And we don't now what orher alloys ferric and non ferric the furure has in store.
 
This will just open the door to more innovative and high tech knives of the future. The canvas is still there, it's just adding an ink-jet printer to your paintbrushes. Imagine a sizable folding knife with a four inch blade and a nice thick grip, and it only weighs one ounce. This could be achieved by putting miniature, geometric hollows all through the knife. I think eventually a knife blade will be able to be made from graphine, carbon nanotubes, and buckyballs. These knives will keep a razor edge through years of use.
 
This will just open the door to more innovative and high tech knives of the future. The canvas is still there, it's just adding an ink-jet printer to your paintbrushes. Imagine a sizable folding knife with a four inch blade and a nice thick grip, and it only weighs one ounce. This could be achieved by putting miniature, geometric hollows all through the knife. I think eventually a knife blade will be able to be made from graphine, carbon nanotubes, and buckyballs. These knives will keep a razor edge through years of use.

this :)
 
If this kind of production approach becomes commonplace, the more the merrier as far as I'm concerned. There are more custom knife makers now that ever before based on what I see. That is not going to change. Too many people who are aging who want to do something interesting, rewarding, and challenging after they move out of the regular workforce. The abundance of knife makers does keep the price down and that's good for the consumer.
 
I'm surprised nobody has mentioned this yet, but you still have to HT it. And I'm sorry, but you're not getting any forging from it either. Which means you can't get a damascus steel blade with a custom pattern that's been forged to fit the shape of the knife. Nor can you get multiple materials, such as bolsters or engravings, or integrals, etc. It's not like the technology exists, or is even close, to just print out a full custom knife.
 
I'm surprised nobody has mentioned this yet, but you still have to HT it. And I'm sorry, but you're not getting any forging from it either. Which means you can't get a damascus steel blade with a custom pattern that's been forged to fit the shape of the knife. Nor can you get multiple materials, such as bolsters or engravings, or integrals, etc. It's not like the technology exists, or is even close, to just print out a full custom knife.

This^ +1

As I said, at best you would get a kit knife. Actually at best you're getting a blade blank. This is a far, far cry from a finished knife.
Also, these machines are not going to be in the tens of thousands, they cost in the 100's of thousands.
They are not printers. They are not going to be as easy to operate as you think. Do you know cad/cam?
They're slow. Much slower than you'd think. That may not seem to be an issue, but in manufacturing it's very important. If I can make 10 of an item on a cnc mill in the time it takes to make 1 3d printed item why would i bother with the printer at all?
 
I think the word "custom" will be redefined. Namely, any Joe will be able to design and create a knife exactly to their specs and at a fraction of a cost.

I predict that the 3D printers 5-10 years from now will be capable of finer tolerances than any human being. Keep in mind that a gun is already possible to print, and a knife is a lot less complex.

I also predict that non-metallic materials of the future will be far superior to the stuff we see today, in terms of edge holding.
 
I'm surprised nobody has mentioned this yet, but you still have to HT it. And I'm sorry, but you're not getting any forging from it either. Which means you can't get a damascus steel blade with a custom pattern that's been forged to fit the shape of the knife. Nor can you get multiple materials, such as bolsters or engravings, or integrals, etc. It's not like the technology exists, or is even close, to just print out a full custom knife.

Thank you, I was wandering how long it be till someone brought this up.
 
I think the word "custom" will be redefined. Namely, any Joe will be able to design and create a knife exactly to their specs and at a fraction of a cost.

I predict that the 3D printers 5-10 years from now will be capable of finer tolerances than any human being. Keep in mind that a gun is already possible to print, and a knife is a lot less complex.

I also predict that non-metallic materials of the future will be far superior to the stuff we see today, in terms of edge holding.

Methinks you haven't seen some of the custom knives that are out there. Because sure, a basic plain jane knife is very simple. Does that mean a knife can't be complex, particularly a CUSTOM knife, which is sorta, ya know, the topic here?

Good luck making any of these on a 3D printer...

GemoftheOrient-KingTut-FireIce.jpg

EdmundDavidsonGuild08artKnife.jpg


In fact, just browse through the Custom knives forums. There are some pretty epic threads you should look at. Here's a few of my favorites:
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php/893907-quot-The-Port-Royal-quot-36-caliber
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/s...Wheeler-s-Steel-*-Stuck-in-the-metal-with-you
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/s...uot-San-Fran-quot-quot-Jambiya-quot-amp-More?

Etc. Yeah. Customs aren't going away.
 
Methinks you haven't seen some of the custom knives that are out there. Because sure, a basic plain jane knife is very simple. Does that mean a knife can't be complex, particularly a CUSTOM knife, which is sorta, ya know, the topic here?

.

People have underestimated technology for thousands of years. I believe that if you can dream it, it will be possible some day. And then there is the stuff we don't even dream about yet..
 
People have underestimated technology for thousands of years. I believe that if you can dream it, it will be possible some day. And then there is the stuff we don't even dream about yet..

Exactly. You can make a stainless steel knife 100% on a 3-d printer right now. YES RIGHT NOW the technology is here. But now its going to be 100% stainless steel including the handle. Is it going to be a WOW knife, probably not. But it could compare to several of the customs out there. Someday they could compare to the finest custom knives. But of course there will never be a 100% 3-d knife with a burl handle or bunch of MOP inlays.

There's 3-d printers being developed for the Navy right now to make food with multiple ingredients (flour, oil, proteins, etc). A few years ago the only place you would have heard anything like this was on Star Trek. If this can happen then someday there will be handles that can be made on the knife too in one shot. Remember ink jet printers 20 years ago? I remember back then my dad's office had a $1000+ inkjet and the resolution was a whopping 600dpi! Now you can get a decent inkjet for a tenth of that price. 3-d printers will be no different.

Only thing I can't figure is the HT, but someday that might be figured out too.
 
People have underestimated technology for thousands of years. I believe that if you can dream it, it will be possible some day. And then there is the stuff we don't even dream about yet..

I'm sure the technology will be there. Some day. Maybe we'll have Star Trek replicators that will build things molecule by molecule. Heck, by then, we won't likely even be using knives in the traditional sense, and they'll have been replaced by lightsabers or monofilament blades, or something of that ilk.

Even then, though, custom knives will still be a thing, if only because it's fun to bang on hot steel, and because, at the end of the day, we think it's cool to have something that was made by a skilled set of hands following historical methods. And what makes a knife valuable isn't just how it looks, etc. It's that it takes a distinct level of skill to generate something. For instance, we can render amazing images with a computer, but somehow, people still buy paintings. The value added is, in my opinion, primarily from the added skill and human aesthetic sense. Until we're making sentient machines, and even then, it's going to be a long time before machines will be capable of artistic vision. Being handmade, or forged, etc, is still a selling point, even though a serviceable, even beautiful blade, can be made from stock removal or CNC work. Maybe we could 3D print an elaborately engraved handle or something. But the value wouldn't be the same as a Warenski, because it's unskilled, and skill adds value. And, at the end of the day, there's a human craftsperson behind the machine. A 3D printer may one day be a viable tool for the craftsman to bring his vision to life, just as the modern 2x72 variable speed belt-grinder has become an essential tool in most knifemakers workshops, when 100 years ago, people didn't even imagine such a tool.

Does the fact that we have a belt grinder make you think that custom knives are no longer a thing?

Until we create machines that are capable of artistic vision AS well as the utterly complex nature of a knife and getting the heat treat down, (and we'll probably create Terminators that will destroy our civilization before that happens), there will always be custom knives, and other pieces of artwork, made by skilled craftspeople. And if the tech is there, people will marvel even more that a custom knife can be made WITHOUT the tech, and will value it all the more.
 
What's the difference between heat treated steel and annealed steel?

I'm just saying, why couldn't the steel be printed in its hardened state? It can be manufactured in a hardened state can't it?
 
I was thinking today about the 3-d printer we use at work and discussing how they can now be used to make stainless steel and titanium objects. Its now possible to print a stainless knife and a handle on a printer. I would imagine it would be a few years away before any "real" steels make it to the 3-d printer.

Is the art of custom knives going to be in jeopardy in a few years?

Well, quite frankly Yes... once perfected...

I mean.. think about it... you can sit down at your computer and TOTALLY customize your OWN knife YOUR OWN way....

Every detail is able to be put on it by you... and only you... from the first click to the last.... that knife was made by you...

Though we might not see this for 15 years .... or more... one day we will...
 
Viable 3D printing will be not be the beginning of the end. It will be more like the beginning. Period. When that day comes, just about anyone will be able to design and produce their own knife. Talk about custom! How much more custom can it be?
 
Back
Top