A Blade from Scratch.. A Peak into a Process (TEST blade added)

Joined
Jan 10, 2010
Messages
1,818
If you are ever wondering where the fine grain structure in a Japanese nihonto sword forged from tamagahane comes from.. or how the chaotic patterning in wrought iron originates, here is a glimpse. This little project was inspired by the fact that I'm accumulating all sorts of home made steel bits either from the shear steel I've made, my little orishigane furnace, bits of bloomery iron sent to me from a friend (Mark Green from the Fogg Forums), a paper published by Tatsuo Inoue
(http://www.shibuiswords.com/tatsuoinoue.htm) and by a tutorial on Jesus Hernandez's website: http://www.jhbladesmith.com/en/tutorials/the-making-of/lasagna-tanto.html

The goal here is to forge a tanto with heart breaking fine grain structure and incandescent hamon... another blade for the Arkansas show if it works out.

Here is a diagram from Tatsuo's paper that shows basically what I'm doing:

Untitled-1.jpg


My starting bits are pieces of orishigane that I made by melting wrought iron nails in a carburizing clay furnace that I made. This furnace makes golf ball size blooms of .95ish high carbon steel that is of fairly high quality right out of the furnace:

aristotle_furnace-300x225.jpg


bloom-300x225.jpg


The other bits are the shear steel I made Ric Furrer's workshop, home made bloomery iron smelted directly from ore (sent to me by a friend), pieces and plates of W2 and 1084 powder. Here is a picture that shows a lot of this:

SAR0126.jpg


In this case, everything I'm starting with is high carbon which would not be the case in a traditional situation. The steel powder is to fill gaps between the pieces.. which I don't believe was traditionally done either.

Here is stacked billet showing all the pieces with steel powder and flux. This is wrapped in wet paper towels to hold it all together.

SAR0119.jpg


Welding needs to take place in a white hot environment. A lot of these traditional materials weld very easily.. but it needs to be hot.

SAR0120.jpg


Here is the first welded billet. Everything firmed up quite nicely after the first go under the press.

SAR0127.jpg


Traditionally, as seen in the diagram... the smiths would have just cut and folded and continued. But I'm working in a propane forge that just doesn't have the heat intensity... so I prefer to take it slow and just grind surfaces clean.

Here is where you start to see where you get the type of grain structure seen in wrought iron..all the gaps that never end up welding and filled with flux and whatnot.

SAR0128.jpg


But I will be using the angle grind to clean some of those gaps out and back fill with steel powder in the next step. So next will be cutting that billet, filling the gaps, and stacking with plates of 1/8" W2. And then just continue to cut and stack to achieve further refinement of all the slaggy bloom components and weld failures caused by the gaps in the billet.

That's it for now! Hope this is of some interest......
 
Last edited:
So the billet shown in the last picture above was cut into three pieces for stacking and welding. When preparing the pieces for welding, I noticed that some of the material was sparking as low carbon. Bloomery iron is very heterogenous in terms carbon content.. which is yet another reason that the stuff needs to be folded and welded repeatedly... to distribute the carbon more evenly. When I checked the pieces it seems that most of it was high carbon.. but sometimes it's just a matter of hitting the piece on the grinder on the wrong spot. Anyway... to make sure the final billet is high enough in carbon for a performance blade I will continue to add pieces of W2 in the next couple of welds. Japanese smiths often would add small pieces of cast iron (VERY high in carbon) to get more carbon into the blade.

Low carbon:

IMG_1136.jpg


High carbon:

IMG_1137.jpg


Here you can see the next stack prepared for welding. You can see where I've added plates of W2 as well as small pieces for gap filling. And again.. steel powder is sprinkled into gaps as well.

SAR0131.jpg


That was welded and this time the billet was cut lengthwise into 4 pieces and stacked again with more W2. After this weld it will start behaving more like a typical billet as the sponginess and slag of the bloomery iron is refined out.

IMG_1139.jpg


So basically after this weld, I will stop adding layers of W2 and start treating it as a typical damascus billet to increase layer count. More later!
 
I'll be watching this with intense interest. This is a really fascinating part of the process and one I've been wondering about. I've toyed with the idea of cutting up my W2 and forge welding it just to see if it produces grain structure. (for aesthetics primarily in Japanese style blades.)
 
Stuart... Cut up your W2 and weld it to some 1050 and go for a really high layer count. A real easy way to get a blade with hada (grain). Check out the hamon thread on the Fogg forum and check out Walter Sorrel's blade done that way. I'm getting ready to order some 1050 in some kind of shim stock so I can start doing low contrast 'grainy' blades.

I will post more pictures tonight. Got a lot of forging done on this billet. I may end up having enough for a nice size tanto.
 
Stuart... Cut up your W2 and weld it to some 1050 and go for a really high layer count. A real easy way to get a blade with hada (grain). Check out the hamon thread on the Fogg forum and check out Walter Sorrel's blade done that way. I'm getting ready to order some 1050 in some kind of shim stock so I can start doing low contrast 'grainy' blades.

Cool... great idea.


BTW, I've wondered about that folding and rewelding that is traditional and wondered if it's the clay wash and straw they roll it in that helps in the weld and why the can get it to weld... is it that it's just screaming hot?
 
Looking good Scott!
As soon as the weather breaks, I'll be blooming up a storm.
You need some of that nice re-smelted magnetite bloom steel. That should make some great koto looking swords.
Best of luck on this endeavor.
Mark
 
Stuart the clay is just flux and the straw helps scrape off the scale. The thing about traditional iron and steel is that it is simply easier to weld. Due to the smelting process there is natural 'flux' impregnated in the bloom that really aids in scrubbing out the scale. But it does need to be welded at higher temperatures.. practically sparking hot.

The next time I do this I'm finally going to get around to making a hot cutter for my press. I will do it the traditional way just to speed up time. Because it's pretty easy to fix weld failures with this stuff..as you will see whenever I get time to put up the next set of pictures!
 
Here is where this is now. Today I will fold one more time and then forge out a blade.

On this last weld I wanted to go ahead and draw it out into a more conventional bar. This is the time you really start to see any weld failures or trapped flux pockets. Trapped flux will show as dark spots in the billet and then start to bulge out. There were two spots that did this so I took a thin cutting wheel to those spots (while still red hot) and cut down in to allow trapped flux out and new flux in.

Here you can see the scars where I did this. On the next fold I will keep those spots on the outside of the billet so that they forge out flat.

IMG_1141.jpg


And here is the drawn out billet... .I will grind it flat and hopefully reveal a couple of layers for the next weld.

The billet is about 1/2" thick and 13" long.. so I should get a decent blade from it as long as everything is hunky dory inside.

IMG_1142.jpg
 
Mark... I just saw you where you posted. I'm hoping to take everything I've learned since my last failed smelt and put together a good one this spring. We should still continue to exchange blooms though... the diversity of sources will make for more interesting grain I would think.
 
Cool Bro,
If you want some brown ore to play with, just let me know. I have about 3000lbs setting in the driveway now. Great stuff. It makes wonderful pure iron.
 
Whew by beard is burnt! I was about to start drawing out the billet pictured in the last post to prepare for forging when the middle started bulging out on both sides! Another pocket. So I immediately cut it in two since it was dead center, fluxed each piece and welded em down. This time I took one piece out and ground it clean while the other was soaking at welding heat and then I just fluxed em and welded. The weld took..and I THINK I have a nice 12" bar at 1/2" thick for welding. I will see how things go tomorrow when I start forging it and go from there.

But here is the bar:

IMG_1148.jpg


And here is the edge ground and etched... looks good at this point. And lots of fine layers:

IMG_1150.jpg
 
Here is a test blade I forged and heat treated this morning to get an idea of how it would quench and what the pattern is like before I start forging the larger blade. This is about 2.5" long and 3/16" or so thick. I expected to see some inclusions and flaws since this is the very end of the billet.. and there are a few minor ones. It hardened pretty nicely and skates a file. I will do some more playing around with that though.

I'm inclined to do one more cut and stack to further refine the pattern and hopefully catch any other flaws.

IMG_1153.jpg
 
Here is a test blade I forged and heat treated this morning to get an idea of how it would quench and what the pattern is like before I start forging the larger blade. This is about 2.5" long and 3/16" or so thick. I expected to see some inclusions and flaws since this is the very end of the billet.. and there are a few minor ones. It hardened pretty nicely and skates a file. I will do some more playing around with that though.

I'm inclined to do one more cut and stack to further refine the pattern and hopefully catch any other flaws.

IMG_1153.jpg
 
Back
Top