About to test the forever warranty.

DGladden

Gold Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2010
Messages
587
*Update on page 3*


Going through some old tool boxes recently and ran across my late father's Buck 110. This was a birthday gift from his sister some time in the late 70's of early 80's. He carried it every day through several various jobs. He gave it to me in 1998 when I turned 15. Times were hard and we could barely afford food, much less birthday gifts, so he gave me the old beat up 110. It had a broken tip, worn blade and dings all over from being used as a hammer! I carried and used it off and on for a while, but eventually tossed it in a box and essentially forgot about it.

I've owned and carried many different knives over the last 25 years or so. Most of them have been more modern designs with the occasional traditional mixed in here and there. I don't know if it's me getting older or just bored with modern trends, but lately I've been drawn to more traditional knives. For about the last year I almost always have a slipjoint in my pocket. However, for work I need something a little more robust so I still carry my modern overbuilt tank of a knife. That sent me on the hunt for a more appropriate work knife in a traditional pattern. After a little bit of searching I remembered that I had the old beat up 110 in the garage somewhere.

After digging it out and cleaning it up, I've got it boxed up and ready to ship off to Buck in the morning. We'll see what the wizards there can do to breathe life back into the old workhorse. I'll update this thread as it goes.
20241225_192154.jpg20241225_192204.jpg20241225_192210.jpg
 
Last edited:
Going through some old tool boxes recently and ran across my late father's Buck 110. This was a birthday gift from his sister some time in the late 70's of early 80's. He carried it every day through several various jobs. He gave it to me in 1998 when I turned 15. Times were hard and we could barely afford food, much less birthday gifts, so he gave me the old beat up 110. It had a broken tip, worn blade and dings all over from being used as a hammer! I carried and used it off and on for a while, but eventually tossed it in a box and essentially forgot about it.

I've owned and carried many different knives over the last 25 years or so. Most of them have been more modern designs with the occasional traditional mixed in here and there. I don't know if it's me getting older or just bored with modern trends, but lately I've been drawn to more traditional knives. For about the last year I almost always have a slipjoint in my pocket. However, for work I need something a little more robust so I still carry my modern overbuilt tank of a knife. That sent me on the hunt for a more appropriate work knife in a traditional pattern. After a little bit of searching I remembered that I had the old beat up 110 in the garage somewhere.

After digging it out and cleaning it up, I've got it boxed up and ready to ship off to Buck in the morning. We'll see what the wizards there can do to breathe life back into the old workhorse. I'll update this thread as it goes.
View attachment 2743469View attachment 2743470View attachment 2743471
Incredible story on that old 110. Please keep us posted!
 
I sent them one that was a model out of production last summer. The blade had failed from a manufacturing deffect. The turkeys told me they couldnt get blades for it anymore so they simply regroundnwhat was left and charged me.


Reminds me of the time about a decade ago. Everyone got fed up of Buck selling knives made in CHINA at an inflated price. When they decided they needed to recover their image from that they started printing extra bible verses on everything they sold. I wrote and asked them to start printing their bible verses in Mandarin stating they should worry about the underpaid chinese workers as much as they worry about their profits. Their response was not overly thrilled with my assessment.
 
That shouldn't be covered under warranty because of obvious abuse. But they can change the blade and give it their SPA treatment for a nominal cost.
Oh, I'm not asking them to replace the entire knife. I'm simply looking to get the blade replaced to bring it back to it's original functionality. But I am curious to see how it turns out after their spa treatment. I've never used Bucks warranty before.
 
I sent in a 110 that also appeared to be used as a hammer. It had deeper dings and pits than the ones I see on your knife.

It came back looking almost brand new with the exception of a pit or two that was too deep to completely remove.

I think you are going to be very happy with the results.
 
There are probably a lot of memories that come with that knife. Personally, I think I'd clean it up, retire it as-is, and buy a new 110 for a daily user. But, that's me. It's your knife, and you get to decide what you want do with it.
 
There are probably a lot of memories that come with that knife. Personally, I think I'd clean it up, retire it as-is, and buy a new 110 for a daily user. But, that's me. It's your knife, and you get to decide what you want do with it.

Honestly, there isn't really any sentimental value to it. My father and I didn't have the greatest relationship. He was a great example of a bad example! Getting the knife back to functional shape would be better than sitting in the garage and continuing to rot away.
 
Honestly, there isn't really any sentimental value to it. My father and I didn't have the greatest relationship. He was a great example of a bad example! Getting the knife back to functional shape would be better than sitting in the garage and continuing to rot away.
If you haven't put it in the mailbox yet, do me a favor and add "FORUM" to the outside of the box. This will help me take a look at it before we do any work.
 
Honestly, there isn't really any sentimental value to it. My father and I didn't have the greatest relationship. He was a great example of a bad example! Getting the knife back to functional shape would be better than sitting in the garage and continuing to rot away.
That's fine. I don't know the story behind it, and like I said, it's your knife.
 
Going through some old tool boxes recently and ran across my late father's Buck 110. This was a birthday gift from his sister some time in the late 70's of early 80's. He carried it every day through several various jobs. He gave it to me in 1998 when I turned 15. Times were hard and we could barely afford food, much less birthday gifts, so he gave me the old beat up 110. It had a broken tip, worn blade and dings all over from being used as a hammer! I carried and used it off and on for a while, but eventually tossed it in a box and essentially forgot about it.

I've owned and carried many different knives over the last 25 years or so. Most of them have been more modern designs with the occasional traditional mixed in here and there. I don't know if it's me getting older or just bored with modern trends, but lately I've been drawn to more traditional knives. For about the last year I almost always have a slipjoint in my pocket. However, for work I need something a little more robust so I still carry my modern overbuilt tank of a knife. That sent me on the hunt for a more appropriate work knife in a traditional pattern. After a little bit of searching I remembered that I had the old beat up 110 in the garage somewhere.

After digging it out and cleaning it up, I've got it boxed up and ready to ship off to Buck in the morning. We'll see what the wizards there can do to breathe life back into the old workhorse. I'll update this thread as it goes.
View attachment 2743469View attachment 2743470View attachment 2743471

My first guess is, with Buck, they’ll likely be happy to see this old knife, replace the blade and give a bit of a facelift. I’m guessing here, but I think they’ll make you happy to work with them.
 
Where the blade broke there was a big pit inside the steel.
But what were you doing with the knife when the failure ?
If it just snapped from say flicking it open, from cutting a zip tie / nylon strapping, or a large chunk fractures off from slightly nicking a deer bone that's definitely a failure caused solely by the defect.
If somebody says " but I pry with my knives all the time and this one just broke too easily " , well then in that case the defect doesn't matter.

I am surprised that they didn't just offer you an equivalent knife to replace it, but I don't know what their assessment was while reviewing your warranty claim.
 
Great story. I’d ask them to regrind the original blade, and leave the rest alone! YMMV
Personally I think that most of the humane element/ history is in the brass, aside from the tang stamp the brass has much more to say than the blade does.
I think it would be awesome to have that brass frame left alone as much as possible while putting a new blade in it, then you've got a knife with quite a story to tell but a fresh new blade ready to write the next chapter in this knife's story.
 
Back
Top