I just had a chance to read everything, and like everyone, I am under the dilusion that anyone cares what I have to say, so...
I liked the changes in format. Sure, there's some tweaking to do, but it's sure better than the 40 year old format of "put knives on table and smile for three days. " I think that sometimes it's ok to change for change's sake. However, I want to make clear that was not the intention of the show committee. They put a lot of thought into the changes, and for the large part, I think it worked.
One thing I found interresting was that as a maker, I had very little chit-chat time with other makers. Usually, on Sunday, we all walk around while it's slow and catch up. In the past, I've had long conversations with nearly everyone who comes, and I feel like I know everyone a little, and I only see most of them once a year. This year, it was all bang, boom, and it was over, and I'm saying goodbye to guys I never acutally said hello to. Tim Hancock had the table behind me and I hardly said more than a quick "hi" til about 3 on Saturday afternoon.
This show will continue to evolve. It presents a little "chicken or the egg" dilema, as indicated by Bailey. Makers generally want to have a place to sell their very best work - even a reason to push themselves to new places, as long as there is someone with the means to give a sale a chance. However, the collectors with the means and the desire to buy such a knife will not come unless they suspect that high quality work will be present. I think that after six years of the show, the work has undeniably progressed, and the collectors who attend expect that.
The show was envisioned as a Mastersmith only show, and was offered as such the first year. But, when they got only about half the makers they needed, they opened it to JS and Apprentice smiths. The show was an unknown quantity that first year. Since then, many who turned down the chance to go that first year have been stuck on a waiting list - soem very fine makers for sure. However, the show committee started a tradition that first year of awarding those with faith in the unknown that first year with first shot at the next year. The turnover at the show is very small from year to year compared to others, and I'd bet that 75% of the tables this year were held by guys who were there on year one.
If you plan on coming to San Antonio, which you should, just save that trip to the zoo for after the show. We don't want you stuck in the hospital with heat stroke til after you've had a chance to get some knives....
