Another (Maybe Stupid?) Idea

Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
1,506
I tend to like really big folding knives, blades with lengths ranging from 4.5 to 6 inches. Case in point: before I found out about Spyderco, I always carried either a large CS Twistmaster (5") or an X2 (6"). I would love to see Spyderco make a real user that's affordable for everybody and would make a good compact knife for putting in the glovebox or the door panel of your vehicle or in the hull of your boat and forgetting about it until you need a bigger knife than your EDC. I'm not sure what kind of reception this would receive, I was wondering what the general opinion was?
I was thinking a 5.5 to 6" blade of H1 or VG10, either plain edge or fully serrated, either a drop-point or clip point in style (but a trailing point would be awesome---that's what I like). A very strong lockback mechanism would be my top choice, like the one that goes onto the Chinook or Manixes. A 14.5mm opening hole for hands with gloves. Make it slim, and have FRN handles; or maybe do like the Military and give it a liner lock with plain G10 handles---gotta keep the weight down in a knife this big. Put a wire pocket clip on it, but make a nylon belt sheath or a molded Kydex sheath optional for handier carry if your pockets are full. And keep it slim, like the Police so it feels like a much smaller knife. To me, it sounds like a good idea---a big, slim, lightweight folder with huge cutting potential when you need something a little bigger. Thanks for your opinions.
 
Steel Scout I Second that. Im so happy they came out with a full service fixed blade with the hossom line.
 
I love it!! I also turn to a Cold Steel 5" Voyager for an outdoors/truck knife (and feel guilty for it too). I would like to see a lightweight backlock that is kind of a morph of a 5" Military blade with an Endura 4 handle and lock. Sorry steelscout that is probably a little small for you! I have wondered why Spyderco never made a 5", most of the knife guys I show my CS 5" to end up buying one eventually.

The Chinook was an awesome knife but handles made it way too heavy for me.
 
I always liked my Chinook. 5" is a little small..and the design of the X2, while it may not be called "good", was a lot better than the Opinel-knockoff Twistmaster. I had to replace the cheap lock on that with a titanium one I milled for a Scout project..it's a lot cooler now :D. Anyway..5": not bad; 6": best. Sal, please let us stop feeling guilting for carrying CSs and put a BIG Spyderco in our pockets! :D
 
I think light weight and strength would determine if it did well (in my mind). Generally, I like to carry smaller knives (3-4 inch blades) siince they are more legal in some areas. Theres little point in carrying an illegal knife. But if your in the woulds or mountains who the heck would care. Maybe Sal could chime in?

mmmotorcycle
 
I figured that a knife this size would be more suited towards use in the woods, mountains, deserts---the rought terrain---than it would be for use cleaning your nails in church. I don't think a knife like this would be intended for EDC; that is, not a constant companion in the pocket. I personally would tuck it away under the truck seat or strap it to my life vest when boatracing for emergencies or for cleaning bigger animals including whitetail deer, etc., when something a little bigger might be needed. I intended it to be more oriented towards the larger chores necessary in the outdoors when the size, weight, or other disadvantages of a fixed blade aren't wanted. It would offer compact, lightweight cutting power. It would be ideal for people ranging from fisherman, to hunters, to ultralight backpackers who need an efficient, large cutting tool but can't afford more than a handful of extra ounces and don't have much space in their packs. I would have killed for something like this at Philmont.
 
Does anybody have more feedback? I wanted to know if this is supported..or maybe I should review my territory and hit the drawing boards again? I would appreciate it..thanks.
 
I think skeletonized metal liners would still keep it pretty light..I haven't seen too many (or even one?) linerlock in an FRN knife.
 
Back
Top