another survival tale in the woods, not so happy ending

Joined
Jul 10, 2007
Messages
3,282
http://www.foxnews.com/us/2012/12/0...friend-vanished-in-mountains/?test=latestnews
A Nevada woman who was lost in the Sierra Nevada mountains for nearly a week is recovering after she was rescued by her own brother Wednesday, but her boyfriend, who left her to try and find help, was found dead.

Citrus Heights police spokesman Officer Bryan Fritsch says 46-year-old Paula Lane was found near Highway 88 in Alpine County around 8:30 p.m. Wednesday.

Fox40.com reports Lane and her boyfriend, 44-year-old Roderick Clifton, were on an off-roading drive through the mountains on Nov. 29 when their car apparently got stuck in the snow.

Lane's doctors told Fox40.com Clifton left the car to try and find help, but never returned. Lane then wrapped herself in blankets and headed out on her own, trying to reach a road.

She slept in hollowed-out trees and ate snow and tomatoes to survive. Eventually, she discovered Clifton's body.

Meanwhile, KTVU reports, the woman's family refused to give up looking for her after authorities ended their search.

Lane's brother headed out into the wilderness to search for her, and eventually found her walking alongside the highway.

Lane is being treated for severe hypothermia and frostbite, KTVU reports.

Read more: http://www.foxnews.com/us/2012/12/0...d-in-mountains/?test=latestnews#ixzz2ENFhNTsH
 
Probably about 95% of people who travel through mountains in winter will not even think to have a well stocked emergency kit in their vehicle, it's just how it is. I think a media based education campaign would be a good to at least plant this idea in peoples heads. It's not common sense for alot of people to have warm gear, flares, rations, etc in their vehicles in case of remote break down or winter storms. My grown daughters look at me like I'm crazy by just recomending they have 6 cases of water stored in the basement, they really are smart girls, but like most, don't think about bad stuff happening.
 
Especially if you are going to leave the main roadways to go off roading, to do that without proper gear is risky.
 
Really. Offroading pretty much includes the chance of getting stuck. Besides the normal survival stuff in my car we usually toss in a come a long and an axe or saw.

Smart lady to use available shelter rather than wast energy building one.

Wonder if the guy left her with all the blankets?
 
Sad Story

File a Trip plan

Carry the best gear you can afford

Plan for Murphy or he will get you in time(Murphy as in Murphys Law)

Most experts agree that you are to stay with /near the vehicle--but in this case looks like not doing that was her better choice

and Most off roaders would agree that you never go off roading alone without the gear to get yourself unstuck

Again--sad story
 
They had to ignore Forest Service signs (Road Closed) and get around a locked gate designed to prevent driving up the closed road.

A strong storm hit that weekend, with heavy snow and wind. That prevented immediate aerial search.

The deceased male was found about .8 mi from the stuck SUV.

She was found CRAWLING along a road.
 
I read that story, another tragic end where the guy goes out for help and dies from exposure. Happens every year.

If stuck with a broken-down or otherwise immobile vehicle in the middle of the wilderness, the first thing one should do When the sky is clear, is to burn that spare tire and send up an oily black signal visible for miles (farther when viewed by air). If you keep spare gas & flares, they light up rather easily (I know).

I'd also burn the other tires, the seats, stuffing, etc. in order to keep that smoke column going for as long as possible during daylight.

Even after their vehicle becomes useless to them, people still have a hard time deciding to rip-apart their cars in order to survive, and some die as a result.
 
It always seems those that stay with the car seem to survive. Reminds me of the story about a cnet editor and his family ( a guy whom I read on a regular basis and watched when he was on techtv) ran into a problem going to their thanksgiving in a mountain lodge weekend. He left the wife and kids to go for help....he was found later unfortunately dead and ironically close to the lodge. They went down an abandon logging road and got stuck. They were looking for the lodge. Someone left the gate open on that logging road. The wife burned tires and breast feed the kids to keep them alive for several days. She was also starting the car for a few minutes to heat the car then turning off. They survived, the stayed by the car and slept in it. Cold weather is not forgiving. I have watched experts like the husband wife (hawkes) from man woman wild, who had to give in during a snow and cold episode. If it happened to me I would stay with the vehicle. You have shelter, larger object easier to identify from the sky object and some resources such as tires and so on.
 
Last edited:
I know this area pretty well as I drive through Hope Valley to get to work. Those gates are closed for a reason. I'm glad she was found alive. Too bad they both didn't make it. I don't recall any Search and Rescue reports going out on this. We work with Alpine County and it seems like they would have been found quickly.
 
SAR gave up, which was why her brother went out by himself. I don't know why SAR stopped so soon especially since the weather cleared up quickly (budget?)
 
One thing that I keep in my winter car kit along with blankets, a saw, an extra coat and enough non-perishable food to last for about three days or longer if you spread it out (the amount of time given the area I live in to either be found or walk to safety if forced to do so) is a self made emergency heater. It's just an empty quart paint can (has never had paint in it) with a lid that can be purchased cheaply at most hardware stores crammed full of toilet paper. It's fueled by 70% rubbing alcohol (crack a window if using it your vehicle though fumes are very minimal). The toilet paper itself doesn't burn and acts as a wick. I don't store it fueled, but I carry two quart bottles of rubbing alcohol as fuel for it. It won't hold quite the whole quart though, so there's a little extra for medical use as well. It produces more than enough heat to keep the inside of your vehicle warm or to cook food etc. It sounds like if they'd had a kit like this, things would have turned out a lot differently.
 
The more you read the worse it gets.

Forget thinking about what they could have had with them for survival, 'cause they left without their brains.

http://www.nevadaappeal.com/article/201 ... ile=search

By the way, every radio station, TV station, newspaper, electronic highway sign and internet site had been forecasting "StormZilla" for DAYS before these two took their little detour.
 
Says: This is an invalid article or has been removed from our site.


###################################################

Woman survives 6 days in Sierra
Brother finds her Wednesday night; companion perishes in search for help
By Kurt Hildebrand and Adam Trumble
khildebrand@recordcourier.com


Email Print

ENLARGE
Paula Lane's sister, Linda Hathaway, speaks at a press conference at Carson Tahoe Regional Medical Center on Thursday afternoon.
Shannon Litz / Nevada Appeal
A Gardnerville woman is recovering from mild frostbite at a Carson City hospital after spending six nights stranded in a remote area of Hope Valley. Her boyfriend died in an apparent attempt to hike to a highway during a snowstorm the morning after their Jeep Cherokee got stuck on a dirt road near a small Alpine County, Calif., mountain lake.

Gardnerville resident Paula Lane, 46, and boyfriend Roderick Paul Clifton, 44, were reported missing after they left Citrus Heights, Calif., on the afternoon of Nov. 29.

Family members late the next night called Douglas County 911 Services, which serves as dispatch for Alpine County, to ask searchers to check Burnside Lake. Douglas authorities said that message was passed on to Alpine County shortly after midnight.

On Wednesday, five days later, Lane was found along Burnside Lake Road by her brother Gary, who took a frontloader from a nearby state transportation shed and drove up the road. Alpine County Undersheriff said the brother was convinced that the couple had gone to Burnside Lake, where they'd camped before.

“Gary Lane commandeered a CalTrans front loader that was parked in a sand shed nearby,” Levy said. “Lane drove up the road with the loader for several miles where he found Lane distressed. Lane loaded Paula Lane into the bucket of the loader and returned her to Highway 88. Once there, they proceeded to Sorensen's,” a small resort on Highway 88.

Levy said Clifton decided to try out the four-wheel-drive capability of the 1989 Jeep Cherokee, which had just been purchased, and drove around a locked gate blocking access to the road. But the vehicle became stuck in mud at Burnside Lake. The U.S. Forest Service had closed dirt roads throughout the Sierra for the season on the same day, because of the expected storm.

Levy said the couple spent the night in their vehicle, and on the morning of Nov. 30, as a major storm was rolling into the Sierra, Clifton tried to walk down to Highway 88, about six miles away.

“Lane attempted to convince Clifton to stay with the vehicle,” Levy said. “Lane stayed with the vehicle until Monday when she attempted to walk and crawl out.”

Lane told responders she'd found Clifton's body while making her way down the road. Searchers from El Dorado and Alpine counties rode snowmobiles up the road and found the body about a mile north of Burnside Lake.

Lane is at Carson Tahoe Regional Medical Center recovering after she arrived there at 9 p.m. Wednesday.

Lane's older sister, Linda Hathaway, spoke at a press conference at the hospital on Thursday afternoon.

“My sister is doing well,” she said. “The family has been through a lot. My nephews and my mom and I are very happy she made it. It's been a rough haul waiting all those days.”

The mother of 11-year-old twin boys, Hayden and Samuel, Lane is eager to get home to them, Hathaway said.

“All I can tell you, is she wants to get better so she can get home to her babies,” she said. “It is hard to sit there as a family waiting. You don't know, your mind plays (through) so many things.”

Hathaway said her brother said he had a feeling about where they were.

“We couldn't stop him, we just let him do what he had to do,” she said. “He had a feeling. They have a special bond, they really do. It is an unusual bond, it is different than the one I have with my sister.”

A friend was with her brother when they found her. After they got Lane to a certain point, Hathaway said they cut her clothes off her to get her warm. They knew she was near hypothermia.

“Last night, I gave her the biggest kiss I could without hurting her,” she said. “My sister may be little, but she's mighty. She is a survivor and she loves life. God was looking over her.”

Dr. Vijay Maiya reported that her condition is remarkably good for spending most of a week in the mountains.

“She is currently in stable condition and recovering nicely,” he said. “She has a long road ahead of her, both physically and emotionally.”

She suffered from first-degree frostbite on her toes. First degree is the mildest form, fourth being the worst. She also was malnourished.

“Once she found out her loved one wasn't coming back she knew she couldn't stay in the truck and attempted to then go and find help on her own,” the doctor said.

She ate and drank snow to stay hydrated. Before the couple left California, they stopped at family members' homes and got some tomatoes, which helped to sustain her during the ordeal.

The doctor said they found Lane in a hollowed-out tree.

“She realized after she left that she couldn't make it, so she had a blanket and tomatoes and (stayed) in a hollowed tree until rescued,” he said. “She was lucky, I can't comment exactly on what she did to stay warm, but she was very lucky.”

Maiya said he is hoping to keep her just through the weekend at the hospital, and that's just precautionary.

Clifton's cause of death is pending an autopsy, Levy said.

The search came to light on Monday after Citrus Heights authorities issued a bulletin asking people to be on the lookout for the couple and describing the blue 1989 Jeep they were last seen in.

At one point a helicopter joined the search tracing their route up Highway 50 and over Luther Pass on Highway 89 to the junction with Highway 88.

Cell phone reception is almost nonexistent in the Sierra around Hope Valley.

• Nevada Appeal News Editor Adam Trumble contributed to this report.
 
Back
Top