Hi all:
I bought a Topo Meridian at a local retailer a couple of days ago. I must admit that I am going to return it today. Luckily my retailer has a good return policy as long as the item is not used and I have just flipped it a few times. Bottom line: I LOVE the design and looks but the manufacturing standards are not good on mine. I looked at several in the store and rejected a couple due to dings in the anodized surfaces, etc--right out of the box. I found one that looked good in the store and bought it. Once I got it home and inspected in good light and up close, several other defects became apparent. First, the not-metallic top layer of the scales was manufactured poorly--there were defects in the cutouts around pins--like the holes were milled too large or unevenly. Second, and most surprisingly, the spine of the blade had casting defects--not huge, but notable upon inspection and enough that I would have expected the knife to be rated as a second---certainly by the kind of standards that SOG shows on their site for seconds. This has no impact on functionality of course, but it was well below the standards I expect for the price and from SOG. The other notable issue is blade play from side to side. At first, the assisted opening did not engage when flipped. Once I flipped maybe 5-10 times, this loosened up, but then I noticed that the lateral blade play was very high---far higher than other assisted opening knives that I own. Bottom line is that the lateral blade play is far more than any other decent manufactured knife that I have seen---it is simply not worthy of the brand.
I really like SOG knives and I have carried a PE II for 4 years and a Gentleman (as a dress knife) for 2 years and find that their quality is outstanding. On both of these knives, the fit and finish is top notch. I really like the design of the TOPO Meridian and I can only think that the folks at BLADE had a better manufactured version of this knife. I hope to pick one up later in the year but I will inspect it more carefully and hope that QC improves.
Overall, I am seeing these kinds of issues more and more on good brands of manufactured folders in the $70-$100+ range and it irks me. The Topo Meridian is a great EDC but I bought it as a collector and hence want a high level of fit and finish. I am not asking for perfection. I would be perfectly happy with quality that is on the order of any of the Buck knives that I own, all of which cost less than this knife. The most obvious comparison is my little Buck with assisted opening and anodized handles and a double lock and that knife is completed to a notably higher level of quality than this SOG.
On the good side, the design is really nice. The blade grind is good too--albeit with a very small defect in the edge right out of the box. The assisted opening is quick and smooth and I like the double lock for when its in the pocket. You can also do both locks with a one handed opening.
I know that SOG reps read this and I would love some reassurance that this is an anomaly. This knife is NOT a second--I bought it at a premium retailer (McGuckins in Boulder, CO)--and there is nothing on the knife or box to indicate a second.
Regards,
QBoy