I've used bat tape too. It does work good, and actually I think it's a little more grippy than hockey tape. I get the hockey tape for $1/roll in any color except black or white, because the hockey guys typically won't buy the tape in colors. I use colorful tape on the knife handles or orange scales (if I can find them), because I have a bad habit of putting my knives down when cleaning game on hunts and then not being able to find it right away. The orange, yellow, and red tape help a lot.