anyone else eat just once per day?

Joined
Oct 24, 2004
Messages
1,032
I have been eating just once per day for the past nine months or so. It is a variation of the "Warrior Diet".

I find I have a lot of mental clarity all day (of course, you all would argue that I don't :D ) and no ups and downs that I used to have, after lunch for instance. So I am more productive, more mentally clear, and I feel much better.

When I do eat, I get very tired. I eat at night and being tired at night feels right.

I know at least one BF person is on a similar diet. I wanted to start a thread about it if there is anyone else following a similar diet.
 
I eat only once quite often, although most of the time it's twice.
 
Actually I'm the exact opposite. I find that I function much better if I eat several small snacks each day. This doesn't mean I eat junk, I eat good food, just small amounts often rather than two or three large meals.
 
I try to eat something every 3 hours or so, though of course not huge meals.

This and weight training has really helped me control my weight. Down to 265 from 300+. (At 6'8", 265 isn't as much as it sounds.)
 
Mike, one of the guys in my company at Basic Training was 6'6" and went from 300+ to 240. He was ripped at 240. I'd guess that you're about right at 265.

On topic, I normally eat small meals often like gajinoz. I also have an extremely high metabolism like my Dad, and absolutely no desire to continue eating once I feel full. IMO there is no one-size-fits all plan for when and how much to eat; everyone's body works a little differently. Getting more exercise is more helpful if you're trying to control your weight.
 
If it works for you, go for it. But man, that would not work for me. I feel lousy if I even miss breakfast. I'm in the other group on this one. But I've weighed 130 pounds for about 22 years and am very active, so my situation might be different than most.
 
I could do one meal a day -- for one day. Then I'd be dead. I'm a diabetic on insulin, so several small meals suits my bionic metabolism better :rolleyes:

I'd be much happier with a decent breakfast and a good dinner. Having to find food in the middle of the day, especially away from home, is no fun. I prefer to fix my own food.
 
I vary somewhat, but it's usually just coffee in the morning and one meal after that - lunch or dinner. Sometimes I add in a very light snack.

The holidays nearly killed me though. Eat, eat, eat. Too much good stuff. Now I've gotta' diet.
 
I eat once a day too...unfortunatly its for 14 hours straight LOL....would be interested in hearing about what you eat specifically on your one meal a day diet..protien? carbs? If you could share some details it would be great..

thanks

Ren
 
I am following a variation. I don't eat much anything on two days a week. Stabilized my blood sugar better than anything else. I also try to eat at as irregular times as possible, that is to avoid the "of it's lunch time" feeling. I have followed this for several years, has worked so far.

TLM
 
Due to a set of circumstances i'm on a similar "diet" for about two years now. I am currently at ~62 kilos (~136 lbs) at ~178 cm (5' 8") but this is definitely not something to do if one is working out or working hard (manual labor). This is just temporary until i get my ass moving harder again ... i used to be as heavy as 77 kilos and later as light as 57 kilos, now i picked up few kilos again over the past 9 months or so.

he daily intake that could get me through the day would be 1 banana, ~80-90 gramsof white bread and 130 grams of hamburger-alike meat, a beer and some ice tea (or anything to make water colored :) ). Obviously i don't eat the same stuff every day, 1-2 days in a week it's ~7 sardines + bread, sometimes it's junk food (like potato chips), somethimes some rice and 100 gram steak, some sweets/cookies to go along, etc. All in all i have apparently stabilised at said weight so my intake is obviously enough to cover my base metabolism + whatever [little] training i do. I do look quite "fat-free" though, no beer belly, no fat elsewhere on the body :D
 
Diabetic Type II - gorging once a day is the worst thing for me. I eat several small meals consisting of things like an egg and a sausage - next meal might be a banana or an orange - next maybe half a sandwich, then a handful of grapes or nuts, etc... Even eating small meals, as a diabetic it is very difficult to lose weight, but if you take it slow it will come off. I've lost 18 pounds over the past 6 months and I'm still about 80 pounds overweight. My doctor says that is a good pace and in about two more years I'll be where I should be. For diabetics, slow but steady wins the race! :)
 
I have been pursuing diets for weight control second, but overall health first. It's been almost a hobby of mine. The web has made it more fun because it's easier to research stuff and share experiences.

Here's how I got here to this once-per-day-plan.

I tried all kinds of diets. I did a calorie reduced diet promoted by the late Ray Walford (author of the 120 Year Diet and well-known researcher) for awhile, about 1300 calories per day.

Then I got into low fat. But low fat diets are high carb diets, something I didn't think about in the mid 1990s when I was doing low fat. Low fat diets should be called high carb diets.

Then I finally discovered low carb diets around 1997. That worked better for me. I did Protein Power and then Atkins and finally Paleo (where you eat only food that we are genetically designed to eat, basically meat, fish, poultry, eggs, veggies, no beans, no grains, no refined sugar.)

Eventually, early 2004, I found the Warrior Diet on the paleo maillist. By then, I had pretty much concluded I should be eating 6 times per day, small meals of mostly protein. It was outrageous when I found people who believed the opposite was true, that eating infrequently is best.

To my rebellious mind, it made sense and I loved the fact that "everyone" thinks it's crazy and unhealthy to "eat this way".

But I researched it. I read Ori Hofmekler's books and they made sense. What really convinced me is that this diet has science to back it up: several rodent studies that show that eating this way can lead to longer life and greater resistance to disease, WITHOUT the muscle wasting and deprivation of the low calorie diet I had been on (a la Ray Walford).

What you are supposed to do on this diet is get into it gradually: eat breakfast later and later, until you are eating say only lunch at 2 and dinner at 7. Then you move lunch up and finally eliminate it altogether.

In March, 2004, I went cold turkey (pardon the pun), and stopped eating during the day. Even though as I said, Hofmekler recommends gradually going to this diet, but I did it whole hog (pun again).

At first, I was very hungry and felt bad for a few weeks but then I felt great.

I have discovered great mental clarity now. Amazing focus and I do not have the ups and downs anymore. Before, I would get all antsy in the late morning, and then I'd feel kinda tired and low in the early afternoon. Now I feel great all the time.

I can work all day solid without a break and feel great mentally and physically.

I can even lift weights and not eat until the evening and still feel great.

Here is what I do. I eat nothing during the day. Not even a vitamin pill. I drink lots of water and some tea or occasionally coffee. Around 6:00pm I start eating. Last night I started with 3 eggs and cheese. Later I had my real dinner, pork chops in a mushroom cream sauce with fresh tarragon, buttered parsnips, yams, and a few pieces of chocolate for dessert.

The idea is to start with protein and eat a lot of different protein things, then have veggies and finally your carbs and some dessert. I don't always do it that way. Over the holidays I got into junk. But basically I do it this way.

Why does this diet work? Because the key to health is *fasting insulin levels*. That means, what is your insulin levels when you have eaten nothing? Your body has its own means of regulating blood sugar. If you eat all the time, your body gets screwy and always is secreting lots of insulin which is not healthy. If you fast most of the time and only eat off-and-on like this, your body re-learns to regulate its own insulin and blood sugar levels, and your fasting insulin level tends to get low.

One thing that does happen is this: when I do eat, I get very tired. That is because my body is very insulin sensitive now, which is a good thing. That is why the diet emphasizes eating at night. We are naturally designed to wind down, eat and get sleepy, I think. I try to eat early in the evening so I don't go to sleep with a full stomach.

For those of you who are type II diabetics -- you need to do your own research. Type II runs in my family big-time. I would have had it, had I not started down the road that led me here. I had a lot of health problems that were getting worse and they have improved a lot. I don't get sick much anymore. I am in better health at 44 than I ever was. You need to rely upon your own research because doctors are mostly very untrained and not nearly as knowledgeable as they think they are. Research this and discuss with your doctor but make your own decision. I believe that eating *frequency* is the key to longevity and health, rather than just *what you eat*. Studies are backing this up. This is the Next Big Thing. Remember you heard it here first on Bladeforums :eek:
 
Ren the devils trailboss said:
I eat once a day too...unfortunatly its for 14 hours straight LOL....would be interested in hearing about what you eat specifically on your one meal a day diet..protien? carbs? If you could share some details it would be great..

thanks

Ren


Same here. I only eat once day, it just takes all day to eat it all. :D :D :D Just kidding!!!!!!

There is no way I could ever only eat one meal a day. I think I could get by fine on two. For me, I can't eat for at least 1-2 hours after I get up or I'll get sick. :barf: But after that I got to eat because I sometimes get the "shakes". And almost the same thing will happen at night. If I eat dinner to early in the evening and don't have a snack, I have a hard time sleeping.
 
Fruitbat, it's all in your head. Try drinking some water (as much as it takes until you feel you're not thirsty anymore nad have the "full" feeling in your stomach) instead of bedtime snack. There is absolutely nothing wrong with many meals a day (in fact it's healthier, says my former schoolmate, now fitness instructor and whatnot) but the food you ingest before going to bed will only be converted to fat unless you did some serious exercise just beforehand.
 
faramir said:
Fruitbat, it's all in your head. Try drinking some water (as much as it takes until you feel you're not thirsty anymore nad have the "full" feeling in your stomach) instead of bedtime snack. There is absolutely nothing wrong with many meals a day (in fact it's healthier, says my former schoolmate, now fitness instructor and whatnot) but the food you ingest before going to bed will only be converted to fat unless you did some serious exercise just beforehand.

Actually drinking water before bed does help. I've been doing that almost everynight since Christmas. During the holidays I started eating ice cream before bed every night. I got addicted to that!!!!!!! But now I drink 1-2 10oz bottles of Deer Park water and it has helped me "kick the habbit"
 
I need to get back into one meal a day... getting there slowly.

I used to eat 4-5 times a day, and about 2K calories...
got down to 2 meals a day and 1500calories
did 1 meal a day for about 6 months, 1200-1500calories...

got a job with coffee breaks every 2hrs, got back up to 4-5 meals a day...

been off work with an injured wrist for 2 months now, back down to a meal at 2-3pm, and snack around 1am when I'm watching movies

if it wasn't for the holidays I don't think I would have gained any weight. Now to find out what I'm sitting at at the end of this month.

high carb, high protine.

today's 3pm meal was:
300grams (pre cooked) of inside round steak, medium well done
fried onions(tossed in raw and cooked as long as the steak)
can of mushroom soup used as a sauce
1 whole wheat dinner roll.
 
What I've read here is really opposite to what I've read in "professional" diet things. Most dietitions recommend eating more calories in the morning and fewer at night, and starting your day with higher-protein meals.

I was anorexic for over three years... I ate nothing during the day, exercised at the gym for 1-2 hours every day, then came home and would eat something "healthy" but low-cal afterward. I looked great, felt horrible, and nearly died almost two years ago. Since then, I've gotten much healthier after starting to eat "healthfully", but I've also gained about 50 lbs due to my screwed up body/metabolism. (I was formerly, according to my doctor, 30 lbs. UNDERWEIGHT.) I exercise every day and eat healthfully now, but it seems impossible to undo the damage I'd done to my body before. Even after a year, my body is still in "starvation mode." Unless I starve, my body wants to hang on to everything I put into it, even though I still exercise and weight-lift.

My point here is: don't let yourself get to where I've gotten. Eat regular, healthy meals and practice moderate exercise and you should be fine. Sounds cliche, but... everything in moderation. I wish I'd stuck with that in the first place.

~ashes
 
I have to emphasize that I eat *a lot* when I do eat. Yesterday I had two double quarterpounders with cheese and a bit later I ate dinner :)

I think that iIf you are going to eat once per day, when you do eat, you eat as much as you want and can (good things hopefully...I consider QPs with cheese good things other than the bread. )
 
Oh boy ... what's the point of one meal then ? I mean, your stomach gets larger (because it has to acomodate larger meal), if you eat stuff with lots of fat and high glycemic index you'll get hungry again soon - this is self-torture if you ask me :)

What Ashes said, go easy on the gravy and the total intake but don't "underdo" it, if you're moderate you won't get fat. When i do eat hamburger it's usually ~80-90 grams of bread, 130 grams of hamburger meat itself and perhaps a banana for that one day and i can function perfectly fine. What Cognitivefun eats is twice that much :D It'd make me :barf: to eat that much.

Oh and one mroe thing: many of you mentioned weight change - fat doesn't weigh as much as muscles do (has lower density) so don't let the weight change alone mislead you. You coudl actually be improving your physical condition by burning fat and building muscles (if you are working out with somebody who knows what they're doing that is) when your weight goes up - or you coudl simply be getting fattier. And vice versa, losing weight doesn't always mean you're doing the right thing with your diet & [lack of] workout :)

Stay healthy !!!
 
Back
Top