-
The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is available! Price is $250 ea (shipped within CONUS).
Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/
#Are the Polkowski/Kasper Companion sheaths good or bad?
- Thread starter nonbox
- Start date
imho a GREAT knife, w/2 sorry sheaths - have ya seen them?? they just look 'cheesy' and cheap to me, not non functional really, but my on/scene tac sheath is 110% better and cost like $25 or so - definitly need a good sheath for a good knife imho.....
sifu
sifu
I'll echo everyone else's sentiments. The sheaths you get with the knife are ok at best IMO. Eric's sheaths are great. Lightweight, much more versatile, and don't need a long break in period to be able to get the knife in and out without giving yourself a serious wedgie!
I was in on getting the first ones anolg with bugs3x, and I'll swear by Eric's work, it's great.
Hank
I was in on getting the first ones anolg with bugs3x, and I'll swear by Eric's work, it's great.Hank
- Joined
- Mar 19, 1999
- Messages
- 2,278
From the context, I gather the discussion is about the CRK&T sheaths and not what Al makes.
CRK&T should spend the few extra bucks and get decent sheaths made, until then, go with the advice given. I have Mike Sastre's version and I am quite pleased. I am thinking about seeing what Eric's are like in the not too distant future.
CRK&T should spend the few extra bucks and get decent sheaths made, until then, go with the advice given. I have Mike Sastre's version and I am quite pleased. I am thinking about seeing what Eric's are like in the not too distant future.
- Joined
- Oct 8, 1998
- Messages
- 5,403
Are you speaking of the production version or the custom?
- Joined
- Sep 23, 2000
- Messages
- 736
and look at the price of this knife!
at this price the knife is a steal,
and the sheaths are free!
what do you expect from a free sheath?
anyway it holds the knife, give it free when you pull,
and give you more options for carry than some other sheaths!
OK they are not first quality, but for free ...
what do you expect from a free sheath?
If you dont like the sheath forget it,
the knife alone is worth every cent!
Just IMHO
at this price the knife is a steal,
and the sheaths are free!
what do you expect from a free sheath?
anyway it holds the knife, give it free when you pull,
and give you more options for carry than some other sheaths!
OK they are not first quality, but for free ...
what do you expect from a free sheath?
If you dont like the sheath forget it,
the knife alone is worth every cent!
Just IMHO
- Joined
- Nov 7, 1999
- Messages
- 6,651
Hey Non..
I agree..
Nothing wrong with taking a Great knife and turning into an Excellent knife with a custom/semi custom sheath..
The same as taking your favorite handgun and knocking the old sights off of it and dropping in Tritium sights...Or even getting a better holster for it..
Hell handguns don't even come with holsters...
Many knifemakers such as Busse Combat now have options on what type or even Whos sheath can come with their knives...Thats the way to do it..Give the customers options...
Look at what Pete is doing with the custom Bucks...Good Stuff..
ttyle
Eric...
I agree..
Nothing wrong with taking a Great knife and turning into an Excellent knife with a custom/semi custom sheath..
The same as taking your favorite handgun and knocking the old sights off of it and dropping in Tritium sights...Or even getting a better holster for it..
Hell handguns don't even come with holsters...
Many knifemakers such as Busse Combat now have options on what type or even Whos sheath can come with their knives...Thats the way to do it..Give the customers options...
Look at what Pete is doing with the custom Bucks...Good Stuff..
ttyle
Eric...
- Joined
- Mar 19, 1999
- Messages
- 2,278
CRK&T has a price point they are going for with this knife and sheath combo. I understand and I apreciate it. I probably have no clue on this (I have been told I am clueless many times
) but I don't believe bumping up the quality of the sheath(s) would cause that big of a price increase. IMO, istead of offer two bad sheaths, offer one good one that will do the same job both sheaths would. Or, work out a deal with a sheath maker an see if some kind oof discount can be worked out. Something like, by a CRK&T Companion and receive a "coupon/voucher" for a x-brand sheath at x cost.
Anyway you go with this knife, it is a winner. One of the best executed designs I have seen from CRK&T.
Now, if they would only make Al's Scorpion or maybe his Urban Kukri!
) but I don't believe bumping up the quality of the sheath(s) would cause that big of a price increase. IMO, istead of offer two bad sheaths, offer one good one that will do the same job both sheaths would. Or, work out a deal with a sheath maker an see if some kind oof discount can be worked out. Something like, by a CRK&T Companion and receive a "coupon/voucher" for a x-brand sheath at x cost.Anyway you go with this knife, it is a winner. One of the best executed designs I have seen from CRK&T.
Now, if they would only make Al's Scorpion or maybe his Urban Kukri!
Al's custom sheaths are excellent. If you are talking about the production sheaths, I can't opine because I haven't seen it. But I can say that there is nothing more aggravating than having a great knife and a lousy or mediocre sheath.
If you want a superb tactical sheath, NORMARK IS DA MAN!
I have a few of his sheaths and you won't be disappointed. It makes a very big difference IMHO.
If you want a superb tactical sheath, NORMARK IS DA MAN!
I have a few of his sheaths and you won't be disappointed. It makes a very big difference IMHO.
- Joined
- Jan 27, 1999
- Messages
- 5,891
Just think, if this knife/sheath combo was available 10 or 15 years ago at the same price point, it would be/have been the greatest thing since sliced bread. As it stands, it's a super knife design & the price still can't be beat. Agreed the sheath is chunky & loud, but excellent replacements are available. Spend the extra $30.00- you still have a super knife.