Part 2 of 6
Here are some smaller sections of the group:
There is a whole lot of Bushcrafter and Arete goodness on that table. You might have guessed by now that Phillip and I share a love for the rounded pommel models.
After the big group photo session was over , we transitioned to picking up every knife and commenting about our favorite features and/or nuances of each one. While we doing that, we talked about many of our Fiddleback friends who we had dealt with to acquire certain knives. As Phillip said in his opening comment, there are a lot of outstanding folks who frequent this forum. It is fun to trace the genealogy of certain knives and determine that they have made two or three moves in some cases before they came to us.
We started with handling the models that we had no personal experience with. For me, that was the new style 2 Finger Karda and the Big Paw (Bear Paw?) Bushcrafter. For Phillip & Meredith, it was my Patch.
The 2FK has a very thin handle that makes it a great EDC when carried in a pocket sheath. Since I cant carry concealed in California, that model is out for me. The Big Paw is a beautiful knife with a very comfortable handle and nice balance. In the end, I decided that the blade shape is just too pointy for my taste. I know that I am in the minority with that opinion, but I call it as I see it.
Phillip & Meredith found the Patch to be more comfortable than they expected. I think that they might look to add one to their collection down the road.
When we started comparing the Bushcrafters, we had a unique opportunity to experience what hand made really means in terms of variations. Between the two of us we had eighteen BCs to compare. Fourteen (as of today!) are his and four are mine. We have examples in 1/8 tapered, 1/8 SFT, 5/32 tapered, 5/32 SFT, and 3/16 tapered O-1. He also has one 5/32 SFT in CPM 154.
Our feel test results were not always as straightforward as you might think. Every single one felt unique in ways that are difficult to quantify in ways that align with our mathematical minds. Phillips favorite is his Slate Blue one. After holding it, I could find any reason to disagree with his choice. The other two that I was surprised to find that I really like are his canvas Blue Black with the sandblasted handle texture and the 3/16 tapered O-1 with the Buckeye burl handles. I dont think the Blue Black knives sold as well as the regular finish ones. That is probably a shame because based on my handling of Phillips knife, it makes a superior user. The Buckeye burl surprised me by feeling so relatively light and very well balanced. The wood is exceptional also.
Since we were so involved handling knives and talking, we did not get around to taking more pictures of the subjective handling and feel tests before dinner was ready. A Cardinal sin I know!
In order to make it up to everyone, I decided to take some photos at home yesterday to backfill the storyline and provide some visual reference for our observations.
The following knives are my four Bushcrafters:
Here is a pommel view showing the differences in handle thickness going left to right from widest to narrowest. The Blue Jean burlap over natural with racing stripes is my newest one from a couple of weeks ago. It is definitely has the widest handle of all eighteen BCs we compared. My Emerald burlap from January 2014 is what Andy described in the Friday ad as thick in the grip. That is still my favorite user. The Ruby one is a Model Standard thickness and it balance the best of my BCs. The Oreo BC is my lightest and thinnest.
Here is a similar shot with the focus on the center palm swell. In regard to the thick handle on the Blue Jean BC, I heard from a trusted forum friend that Andy has received numerous request for thicker handles to be available from time to time. I dont know if that is true or not, but I have seen photos of one other BC from a recent batch that has similar thick handles. Andy continues impress with his customer service attitude.
