Ask a Stupid Question. . . .

Joined
Aug 21, 1999
Messages
63
Hello to all of those interested in the art of blade making. Call me stupid. Call me naive, but a decent spark of thought was formed in the general discussion forum that I want to transport here to either be snuffed out or tindered into a flame.

I have SAKs. I have Leathermans. Every knife nut I know has one or the other or both. What are the obstacles to making and marketing mass produced or one-off aftermarket blades that will fit the popular SAKs and LMs in steels other than 420 and 440?

Everyone I seem to know that owns the aforementioned products bitches about the "inferior steel" and I see their point. I already have owned my SAK Champ for five years, it has paid for itself in that time. I would gladly pay anywhere from $20-50 to have a well made VG-10, BG-42, D2 or some other tougher, sharper, more durable SS main blade fitted to it. Perhaps I could also have the little one done in a different steel. It seems at least on the SAK secondary blade one could fashion the piece from scrap bar stock instead of recycling it at a loss.

It seems strange that such a thing hasn't been proposed before. It probably has. That means to me that it must be impractical or something else is wrong with the idea. I, however; believe that if someone wanted to get into blademaking or perfect their technique, this could certainly be a sideline possibility.

Any comments?

------------------
"The cannibals of the West wear suits and ties"--Midnight Oil

[This message has been edited by lawdog (edited 17 September 1999).]
 
From my experience it is easier to work on new product than do repairs. This would falll into the class of repair because few individuals would have the desire to disassemble their tools and replace the blades. The second problem would be accurately reproducing the locking/pivot area so it could be a direct replacement.



------------------
george
www.tichbourneknives.com
sales@tichbourneknives.com

 
Lawdog,
I have done exactly what you are talking about. I have done knife repairs and restorations when I wasn't busy. It took me alomst 4 hours to complete a locking multitool blade in D2. Lazer cutting would cut the time considerably, but...I dont think that even the best tools are made to close, consistant tolerances to chance having a run of lazer cut blanks produced.
I have given this some though and must agree AGAIN with George, It would not be profitable!!
 
LD
It could be done. I would get into line for one myself (I carry a sak). As above its not cost effective . You may fine someone who would do the change for 100.00 per blade . They would have to have 100 knives to do though!

------------------
Web Site At www.infinet.com/~browzer/bldesmth.html
Take a look!!!




 
SOG is the only multitool manufacturer that I am aware of that you can remove and replace blades readily. This should reduce the cost of a higher quality blade replacement to the cost of the blade. I doubt if it would make replacing the blade economicly feasable, but it would at least make it a little more praciticle.

Take care,

Mike

------------------
TANSTAAFL


 
Well heck, I knew there'd be something wrong with the idea. That said, if you ever hear of some guy who wants to go from serious hobbyist to a blademaker, this could still be a loss-leader to get their name out there couldn't it? After all, someone making blades as a hobby is losing money already isn't he? At least this way one could convince the IRS that they were attempting to make money on their hobby. Does anyone know of such a person? I am actually tempted to try some stock removal myself.

[This message has been edited by lawdog (edited 17 September 1999).]
 
Back
Top