Assisted opening.

I really like the Benchmade Axis Assist models due to their action and the fact that they ALL have very positive blade locks that guarantee that they cannot open in the pocket. Relatively strong closed detents too. All except the 470 Emissary, which has a different safety mechanism, are also totally ambidexterous. Good for lefties and in some emergency situations IMO.

Having lived in the tropics (Philippines) I agree with the comments of the poster who worries about spring corrosion. A lot of electronics, and leather goods, did not like the climate either. I am now in Nevada though.
 
I generally dislike assisted openers simply because it makes closing the knife and bit clumsy. In fact, if you measure the "speed" of a knife as the time it takes to draw the knife, open, use it, and put it away rather than simply how fast the blade opens, manual openers, particularly those with axis or compression style locks that can be flicked closed, are often much faster and safer to operate. The fact that you have to overcome spring tension to close an assisted opener just flat out makes them slower and more dangerous to close, especially in high stress situations. Besides that, I generally see assisted opening mechanisms as an unnecessary gimmick used to sell knives, particularly to the general public who just wants a "cool" knife and feels like they're getting away with a legal switchblade. A well designed and we'll built manual opener is just as fast to open, and MUCH quicker and safer to close.
 
I don't like hearing a "snap!" every time I open my knives. Especially if you're trying to be quiet about it in public. Also, it's just one more thing to break on a knife. If they made the knives smooth opening, you wouldn't need assisted opening. A smooth knife will open just fine unassisted.
 
For me I used to LOVE assisted openers. I was a huge switchblade fan yet couldnt safely own one where I was living. So when assisted knives came out I was in hog heaven. The IKBS was introduced into production knives and other bearing systems became popular. Now I dont care for either side opening autos or assisted openers. The draw and appeal to me was the gadgetry and something so simple yet so fast. With bearings its just as fast or even faster and its even more simple and even less to go wrong. It really is a situation of how did it take this long for something that simple to become commonplace. My bearing addiction is such now that if its not a balisong or an OTF It has to have bearings for me. And even in butterfly knives I really really try to have at least bushings.
 
Bearings are awesome, I hope more knives start coming with bearings. The Spyderco Brad Southard I have is really fun to open. Probably the smoothest knife I own!
 
More to break.

Increases cost.

A great many of Kershaw's Chinese made budget line are assisted-open and are priced around $20...ie, the same price(or less) as Spyderco/Byrd Chinese made knives that lack AO. If a company is claiming AO increases cost I'd be a little wary about believing that.
 
I love AO knives for the most part. They sure are fun to play with. The only AO knife I've handled that I would prefer was a manual is my Kershaw Knockout. The reason being is that it's my first frame lock and when I close it I have a tendency to push against the lockbar with my middle and ring finger while trying to disengage the lock, so I have to adjust my grip so I don't do that but then the torsion bar is difficult to overcome when closing without using two hands or pushing the back of the blade against something.
 
It all comes down to preference in the grand scheme of things. I prefer unassisted knives but I like assisted knives. I don't like auto's and not just because I'm not allowed to carry one. I'm allowed to own them in my state though. They're cool and stuff but I just haven't warmed up to them for regular carry, if I was allowed to of course. I have a few speedsafe knives and I prefer that if I go with assisted. It's different than a coil spring assisted like a sog twitch. I can't really explain why I prefer manual though. I love the feel of both, it all comes down to where I'm going and what I could be doing I guess. I have a wave mod on my Para 2 and I have a waved endura coming soon as well. Those will open faster than any auto because they'd be half open before it leaves the pocket. But my leek if I need it quick I can find the flipper and get past the detent before it's out of my pocket and is just as quick. for out in public when I don't want to scare anyone or cause any kinda of issue I will just use my victorinox. If you're scared by a "boyscouts" knife then well...idk what to tell ya.

To sum up:
I prefer the feel of a manual over an assisted
A kershaw speed safe is real close to a manual for me, I have a hard time choosing between them
I don't like coil spring assist knives or autos.
For me, getting a knife out quick isn't an issue with the way I carry things and also unlikely I will ever need to draw a blade quickly anyways.
I need another beer
Overall the smooth slowness an unassisted knife can have just beats out everything for me.
 
I have the Kershaw leek and I have no problem opening or closing it with one hand and I am not even looking at it when I am closing it. the blade is very good steel. I made my very own knife Sharpener and it sharpens up very good.
 
I love it, a gimmick going on about 15 years now. Pretty good gimmick. Got this average public guy who's had a knife in his pocket for about 30 years now to buy more than a few. There is even a board here full of unknowledgable gimmicky knife buyers, who knew? Oh not all AO's rely on the spring for detent.
 
Like Richard Thurman said, the Kershaw Leek is really easy to open and close one handed. But I've also had other assisted knives that aren't that easy to close one handed, like the Needs Work.

One thing I like about an assisted knife is that it is pretty much guaranteed to open all the way and lock. Unlike other knives like the Kershaw Skyline that won't open all the way if you mess up the flipper technique or don't give it a wrist flick. I've only come across one assisted knife that didn't always open all the way, and I think it's because it was a coated blade and the pivot was too tight.

I hear the "less parts to break" reason a lot, but it isn't that big of a reason for me since I can always just grab another knife if the spring breaks or stops working properly. I did just that with my first Kershaw Leek. I haven't used it in over a year because something happened to the spring where it's not as strong anymore and there's a rattle when I shake it and the knife is open. I just have to send it in for repair but keep forgetting to do it.
 
Weither or not a knife has AO is less important to me than design, for most flippers, like my ZT300 it compliments the design well, some others not so much(axis lock models or wave designs). I actually prefer the spring acting as a detent, it makes the initial motion to flip it easier and smoother, and all but guaratnees it will open, the noise of hitting the stop and locking is a good indicator of a successful lock, if silence is needed, then opening with 2 hands works.

I really don't have the problems closing AOs that some have, at least with a few KAI speedsafe knives and a SOG flash, in some ways they are a bit safer, instead of flopping closed once the blade moves past the lock, the spring keeps tension on it, and contact with your finger for more control in closing. The spring can and does fail rarely, but so do locks and other hardware, in many cases the knife still operates, but even if it doesn't it is an easy fix for anyone with the ability to disassemble and maintain a knife. If you think a broken AO spring would be a disastrous fail in a survival scenario, then you probably should carry at least 2 fixed blades in that situation.

I also own a ZT561 with KVT, love the bearing action too, far better than bushing designs, and I prefer KVT or good PB bushings over AO when used with thumb studs/spider hole, gives better control, but it still can hang up when opening in some cases, and when closing it flies closed if you get hung on the detent and push past, need to make sure your fingers are clear. Each knife and mechanism has it's own design, and individual personality, some like it, some won't. It is true AOs may scare and intimidate some people, as do most knives, firearms, dogs, fast cars, hot women, and any number of great things. Here in southern PA we have a name for these people frightened of all things awesome, sitzpinkler. I do not live my life to pacify them or consider their irrational fears when I decide what is lawful and useful to me, or how I conduct myself.
 
Last edited:
I like kershaw's speed assist, but generally most knife owners can open their knives as fast or even faster than an assisted knife..

I generally dislike any knife that benchmade puts out that has both an axis lock and an assist. They are not very fast (470 Emissary) and are generally harder to close.
 
I like kershaw's speed assist, but generally most knife owners can open their knives as fast or even faster than an assisted knife..

I generally dislike any knife that benchmade puts out that has both an axis lock and an assist. They are not very fast (470 Emissary) and are generally harder to close.

While I can agree with the 470 being slow, the barrage series is on its own. I own 2 barrages and both FLY open hard, with zero blade play. My subrosa is the same way, but its a non axis assist. I find AOs handy and convenient. A lot of times I'm holding something to cut and just a tiny fick insures its open. I don't go looking for AOs, but it definitely not a deal breaker if I like the knife. Closing it one handed is easy, just takes practice.
 
I like kershaw's speed assist, but generally most knife owners can open their knives as fast or even faster than an assisted knife..

I generally dislike any knife that benchmade puts out that has both an axis lock and an assist. They are not very fast (470 Emissary) and are generally harder to close.

The reason that the BM Axis Assist knives are harder to close is that the spring powers the blade all the way until fully open and even with the blade fully open the spring is still under some tension. Not true of the SOG and Kershaw assisted knives I have tried which only have the spring driving the blade for part of it's opening travel. The BM Axis Assist spring design does give more positive opening and is closer to the action of the spring on many full automatic knives I believe. My two Buck spring assist knives are closer to the BM action in operation. My Embassy opens as fast and positive as my other BM assisted knives.

I have Barrages, both regular and Mini, the Embassy and the Volli and like them all. IMO the Embassy is only harder to operate due to both the narrowness and relative thinness of the handle compared to the others. This narrow and slim design seems to be common to all Benchmade's "Gentlemens Knife" designs. They are designed for unobtrusve pocket carry.
 
Like Richard Thurman said, the Kershaw Leek is really easy to open and close one handed. But I've also had other assisted knives that aren't that easy to close one handed, like the Needs Work.

One thing I like about an assisted knife is that it is pretty much guaranteed to open all the way and lock. Unlike other knives like the Kershaw Skyline that won't open all the way if you mess up the flipper technique or don't give it a wrist flick. I've only come across one assisted knife that didn't always open all the way, and I think it's because it was a coated blade and the pivot was too tight.

I hear the "less parts to break" reason a lot, but it isn't that big of a reason for me since I can always just grab another knife if the spring breaks or stops working properly. I did just that with my first Kershaw Leek. I haven't used it in over a year because something happened to the spring where it's not as strong anymore and there's a rattle when I shake it and the knife is open. I just have to send it in for repair but keep forgetting to do it.

I have had mine for around 10 years or better and It Is still going strong.
 
I have had mine for around 10 years or better and It Is still going strong.

My Leek was my first assisted knife so it was flicked open lots of times. But I still don't think more times than yours in 10 years. I must've gotten a lemon because my spring started acting up after a year or so.
 
I do not have any problem with assisted opening. And like OP I would sometimes wonder why some people sort of make a deal of it. I do not consider that an important issue either way and I do not find it generally interesting if somebody has any specific preferences. it's like with handle color: some like it black, some like it orange and wish it was available for all knives - but either way, does not make an exiting conversation topic.
 
A great many of Kershaw's Chinese made budget line are assisted-open and are priced around $20...ie, the same price(or less) as Spyderco/Byrd Chinese made knives that lack AO. If a company is claiming AO increases cost I'd be a little wary about believing that.

If they removed the AO system from the Kershaw Chive and simplified the design, it would cost less.

Do you agree or disagree with that?
 
Back
Top