Automatic Knife Disqualifier

4) Poor or no warranty. This is why I won't buy a Microtech or Strider knife. I've had too many knives go back to the manufacturer for service over the years to roll the dice on companies with poor warranty track records.


I respect your opinion, but I have personal experience with two "junk" Striders, Sng and PT, going to Strider and coming back as NEW, ...ZERO cost.
Even CRK will charge you for repairs, IF they will do them.
No "political" discussion is desired.
Sonnydaze


I just had to put a plug in there for Microtech as the timing is too awesome.. I just received my Microtech Ultratech by UPS just 20 minutes ago, back from the factory for repairs. It had a broken firing spring and they fixed it for no charge and shipped it back to me. I am not a LEO or Military. I called their 800 phone number, a human being answered, I told her my situation and they fixed it for free. Hard to beat that!

IMAG1493.jpg
 
Last edited:
Partial serrations are a total disqualifier for me, and serrated edges in general to a lesser degree. I do have some fully serrated edges but not many.
 
It is very unlikely that I will buy a knife without bearings and a flipper. I'm also not a fan of G10 or micarta, I much prefer smooth metal handles.
 
These are some of the disqualifiers for me when it comes to purchasing a knife.

1. Partially serrated edges.
2. Pocket clip sharing the same screw as the blade.
3. No information on steel used.
4. Made in Pakistan.
5. Ultra shiny.
6. Ultra blingy.
7. "Custom hand-made."
8. Frost Cutlery.
 
Alright back on task..

1: Not made in the U.S. (Unlike most other products, there are plenty of U.S. brands to chose from which are also the highest quality and prettiest to look at)

2: For folders, non-frame lock models.

3: Less than 4 inch or especially less than 3 1/2 inch blade length. They all look the same in my pocket anyway, so I may as well get some strength and length.
 
These are some of the disqualifiers for me when it comes to purchasing a knife.

1. Partially serrated edges.
2. Pocket clip sharing the same screw as the blade.
3. No information on steel used.
4. Made in Pakistan.
5. Ultra shiny.
6. Ultra blingy.
7. "Custom hand-made."
8. Frost Cutlery.

Wow. You didn't even say "China made". It is not a disqualifier for me anymore. Two years ago... yes.
Frost Cutlery... well, what can I say? I would add most of the stuff made by United and Taylor Cutleries.
 
I recently considered buying a knife( Benchmade Volli ) that looked like it would be become one of my favorite knives. Right blade steel, right size and right price. The whole deal came to a halt because of one thing: assisted opening.
 
Assisted opening
Partial serrations
Mystery steel (vic gets a pass though)
Cheap/bad steel (being somewhat of a noob my purchases involve quite some research)
Unnecessary tacticality (mall ninja stuff)
Tip down carry folders is not an automatic disqualification but it's a big obstacle
 
Bad ergonomics. If the knife feels uncomfortable in the hand and in use, it doesn't last. Recently, I've seen plenty of knives that are absolute ergonomic disasters. It makes me wonder if some makers are completely forgetting about that entirely.

Bad blade grind. If a folding knife has overly thick stock, and the grind to match it doesn't stay. It's funny since the "overbuilt genre" came into the forefront some makers go out of their way to design knives that look like Sci-Fi props more than efficient cutting tools. A knife must be able t cut, in order to be a knife. Otherwise it's a folding "thing".

Everyone has their own idea of what makes a beautiful knife design. In my eyes, severe asymmetrical design does not look appealing at all. I've seen folders with the pivot screw way too close to the edge of the handle (for my liking of course). Poorly designed pocket clips, bad pocket clip placement, poorly designed locking mechanisms. When the tip of the blade protrudes from the handle is also not acceptable.

Made in China. It is simply not my thing. I will buy knives made in Italy, Spain, South America, and other European countries, but not China. Taiwan is fine, but then again that is NOT China.

Crappy heat treat on an otherwise excellent steel. Why use a high end steel only to run it super soft? Makes no sense to me.

Price can be an automatic disqualifier, especially when the end product is nothing special compared to other manufacturers in the same market.
 
Hmmm...
1. About 8 production knife companies that I just refuse to buy from
2. About 4 custom knife makers (3 out of the 4 make great knives but I've met them and just don't like them)
3. Pakastani and mainland China knives
4. Full serrations and most partial serrations
5. FRN handles
6. Folders where I can run my finger along the non pivot end and it'll catch on the tip of the blade (in the closed position of course)
 
1)- Steel that's worse than VG-10 or AUS-8
2)- Made in China or Taiwan
3)- Serrations
4)- Hollow grinds in fixed blades

I make exceptions from time to time in very specific cases, but I usually end up not using those knives at all. For instance, I bough a couple of serrated H1 Spydies because I thought I ought to try out serrations and they just sit in a drawer collecting dust (I ended up buying plain edge versions of the same knives). I also have a few Cold Steel folders because I wanted to try out the Tri Ad lock, and it was either a Taiwanese CS or getting on Demko's waiting list.

Have you thought about spydercos Taichung offerings? They rival most knives in fit and finish and I've never had a bad one
 
One "automatic" disqualifier - I will not buy automatic knives. (or OTF/gravity knives, throwing knives, or balisongs. I pretty much will not buy any knife I can't carry in public without potential legal trouble)

Also, I don't buy gerbers anymore, and will not buy any 'mystery steel' knives.

I avoid (but sometimes make exceptions for) Chinese knives, 420HC, assisted opening, knives with blades over 3 inches (stupid municipal knife laws).
 
Not too big on serrations unless it's a good deal on the knife.

Knives made by gun companies

440 steel

Knives that are knockoffs of other popular knives(schrade makes a knockoff of the boker Kalashnikov auto knife)

Weak pocket clip
 
Back
Top