Recommendation? Available options for First Responder/Firefighter knives?

Joined
Mar 2, 2025
Messages
6
Hi there,

Due to my previous knife going missing, I'm back in the market for a knife to keep in my bunker gear.

My last one was an old Gerber Hinderer that fit pretty much all the criteria I was looking for. It was, I assume, the earlier model and I had it for most of my career. It worked well with gloves for the most part, though the hook was difficult to access and tended to loosen up over time.

I've got a set of wire/cable cutters in my gear for dealing with wire entanglements and the odd car battery. I also keep a cheap set of trauma shears in my pocket. They're one of the quickest and safest things to use for removing patient clothing.

The knife is mainly there if I need to cut myself out of an entanglement that the wire cutters aren't suitable for (curtains, rope, blinds, etc.) A sharp blade is handy for removing side-curtain airbags at vehicle wrecks. If it also has a good glass punch, that's a nice bonus.

Primary criteria:

1. Usable while wearing Firefighting gloves. (To clarify - can be opened with one hand)
2. Serrated (or partially serrated).
3. Glass punch.
4. Not crazy expensive*
5. Pocket clip
6. Folding**

Secondary criteria:

1. 02 wrench
2. Blunt tip
3. Brightly colored

Those are the main points off the top of my head. I've been looking around at a bunch of different options but I'm interested in hearing some educated opinions and recommendations if possible.

Thanks!

*The Benchmade Triage is obviously the top of the line option. However, considering the cost and high-ish likelihood of getting lost, it's not a viable option. I'd prefer not to be out hundreds of dollars if it falls out of a pocket while I'm dragging hose.
**I could be convinced otherwise. I've gone with folding as my bunker pants have a small ankle pocket for a knife. A fixed blade wouldn't fit.
 
Last edited:
Spyderco made a Byrdwrench, you'll have to look at the 2nd hand market. Not really cheap, go for around $300+.

They also make the Clipitool, runs under $100. Might not have everything you want.
 
Spyderco Rescue might fit the bill. Has a blunt tip, VG-10 blade with serrations and a glass breaker which is retractable.

Safety Orange. The opening might be a tad tough in gloves though.

Knife Center Spyderco Assist

Hogue also makes a Rescue knife that might fit as well. More expensive, but more features.

Hogue Trauma
 
Last edited:
Years ago, when I helped out at a knife store, the biggest sellers to firemen were -

The Gerber River Shorty -

gear-review-gerber-river-shorty-641871_800x800.jpg
.

And the Schrade USA River Rat (still easily findable) -

images
.

Boker sells the Donges Brand Fire Knives now -

expert-fire-fixed-02dg001BnVmbSXHy1Ouk_600x600@2x.jpg


expert-fire-folder-01dg007VNBhJNEmx8tzj_600x600@2x.jpg

Boker / Donges also make a folder decently similar to the Hinderer as their Professional Rescue knife, but it's more of a sheepsfoot than a blunt tip, and it's a big folder (4.5" blade).
 
Last edited:
I’ve found BM Triage knives for relatively cheap, especially the one with the square blade tip with opposing bevels for prying.

I keep one with my tourniquet.

Another almost disposable option is the Dexter Russel serated net knife. I know its totally not what you asked for, but if I was tangled in rope or curtains. There is no better knife to have.
 
Boker sells the Donges Brand Fire Knives now -

expert-fire-fixed-02dg001BnVmbSXHy1Ouk_600x600@2x.jpg


expert-fire-folder-01dg007VNBhJNEmx8tzj_600x600@2x.jpg

Boker / Donges also make a folder decently similar to the Hinderer as their Professional Rescue knife, but it's more of a sheepsfoot than a blunt tip, and it's a big folder (4.5" blade).

Those blades look pretty good. Apparently designed for use with gloves too which is exactly what I'm after.

Have you had any experience with them?

Thanks
 
My vote is for a pair of medics shears like the paramedics use and a Spyderco Endura. The Endura isnt so expensive that if lost or damaged it will be a major problem.
 
Those blades look pretty good. Apparently designed for use with gloves too which is exactly what I'm after.

Have you had any experience with them?

Thanks

Not yet, they're pretty new to being imported to the States, I have seen a few European reports that were positive, but no long reviews.
 
with regard to glass punch, something others have pointed out in previous threads is the likelihood of encountering laminated side windows nowadays. a quick search will provide plenty of examples of how ineffective the standard glassbreaker has become. you may find something more along the lines of a lifeline rescue tool of interest; it's relatively compact and checks off several boxes.
 
My agency equips us with end caps for our expandable batons that have ceramic points solely for the purpose of breaking car windows should we need to. This came after a lesson learned following an incident where some of our guys struggled to get into a vehicle to an uncooperative, armed subject with handheld breakers or just the expandable batons without the ceramic points, and getting in faster may have made the incident go quite a bit smoother.

In almost 20 years as an LEO, I’ve never needed to cut a seatbelt off anyone, or bust a window to rescue anyone. I’m not saying the possibility to have to does not exist, and we all love to be prepared for anything, but I don’t know that I personally would need a do-it-all folding knife for extrication purposes, when I could probably manage with what I already carry on me if I needed to. That is to say, I carry a knife primarily for cutting things and as a backup defensive tool if it needs to do that. I would rather my knife be excellent at being a knife, rather than a compromise of gadgets in one tool for extrication purposes. But that’s me, and I’m not a firefighter/EMT who may have different needs.

That said, my agency doesn’t issue us a crash axe for getting through metal, but I carry one of my own in my car, you know, just in case.

It was my, perhaps errant, assumption that fire/EMS (those services are combined in my area) members typically carry trauma shears, which I imagine would work on a seatbelt just as effectively and as safely as a seatbelt cutter/hook, though it may not be as satisfying and fast as zipping through one with a hook. Please correct me if I’m wrong.

I will say I did once see a rescue crew borrow a Spyderco PM2 from someone on a scene to cut away a side-curtain airbag to get to a patient. Nobody seemed to be concerned with the pointy tip at the time, they were just careful not to poke the patient, and it worked very well.
 
Victorinox swiss army knife Rescue Tool
Includes :
Large Locking Blade
Phillips Screwdriver
Window Breaker (removable)
Strong Screwdriver/Crate Opener with:
Bottle Opener
Wire Stripper
Reamer, Punch
Seatbelt Cutter
Key Ring
Tweezers
Toothpick
Disc Saw for Shatterproof Glass (removable)
Luminescent Handles
Nylon Cord
Nylon Pouch
 
As a professional firefighter of 32 years, here’s what I learned….. you won’t be doing to many daring rescues while dangling off the side of a building with fire and smoke blowing out the windows above and below you…..you will however find yourself in need of a can opener, because B shift has lost once again the one in the kitchen. A screw driver and pliers are always handy due once again to B shift loosing nearly every tool in the tool box. C shift has no need for a can opener as they eat only organic and they don’t need a pair of pliers or screwdriver while constantly working out and admiring themselves in the mirror. It matters not what shift is on, there won’t be a sharp knife in the kitchen, and if someone does sharpen one, it will be done on the grinder in the tool room….. lots of luck cutting butter with it.
My advice is get a buck 110 and a leatherman tool….. and don’t loan them to the bone heads on the other shifts. That’s the best advice this old fireman has to offer….. well one more piece of advice…. If your on B or C shift…. Transfer to A as fast as possible.
 
Last edited:
As a professional firefighter of 32 years, here’s what I learned….. you won’t be doing to many daring rescues while dangling off the side of a building with fire and smoke blowing out the windows above and below you…..you will however find yourself in need of a can opener, because B shift has lost once again the one in the kitchen. A screw driver and pliers are always handy due once again to B shift. C shift has no need for a can opener as they eat only organic and they don’t need a pair of pliers or screwdriver while constantly working out and admiring themselves in the mirror. It matters not what shift is on, there won’t be a sharp knife in the kitchen, and if someone does sharpen one, it will be done on the grinder in the tool room….. lots of luck cutting butter with it.
My advice is get a buck 110 and a leatherman tool….. and don’t loan them to the bone heads on the other shifts. That’s the best advice this old fireman has to offer….. well one more piece of advice…. If your on B or C shift…. Transfer to A as fast as possible.
I just knew there had to be one firefighter somewhere capable of being funny!
 
I kept a cheap serrated hawkbill in the bunker gear. Might even still have it here somewhere. It would rip through anything really quickly.

Honestly one of those Milwaukee knives from home Depot will be great for this purpose.

If you want a multi tool for glass and gas bottles and whatever else I'm sure you can find one. Keep the blade separate. My opinion anyways.
 
It was just good ol’ cop to firefighter ribbing good sir. Gotta keep the notorious antagonizing between the services alive!

Thanks for all those years of service! I have only few left before I can figure out which WalMart I can go be a cantankerous greeter at.
I inderstand that and I appreciate it….. the cops versus firemen was always fun. The years are gonna go by in a blink…… it did for me anyways…you will enjoy retirement, I really do enjoy hot
Meals and sleeping all night. 😉
 
Back
Top