Even though I have known about collectivization in Soviet Union I did not connect it to this art.
J
jake pogg
thank you for reminding me about background and also for pointing out socialist/communist propaganda aspect of that painting.
My grandfather on the paternal side was a blacksmith. One morning, he found a note on his shop that going forward, he is going to work under a new employer, the Communist State, and his pay is going to be amount X.
That's when he put his hammer down and took up a job with at the railroads. He did not suffer the idea that his work, tools etc. were going to belong to someone else, and him becoming a simple "user" of his property.
With the land, I can only imagine how having it confiscated and then forced to work it for the benefit of "the State, Party and People" felt. This happened to my grandmother's (maternal side), when she was a teenager. I guess, she had to be thankful she hasn't been declared "an enemy of the State", thrown in jail or worse, as she was wealthy, of Hungarian nobility. This was happening in Transylvania.
Having seen what communism actually means, I get pissed off to no end when I see people throwing words around, having never lived true adversity *under totalitarian regimes* (pray you never get to know what "commies", or "nazis", are). "Don't devalue words, don't strip them of their meaning.", is what I always tell - even to youngsters that haven't been around to live and remember those times.
*
So yep - it is a very touchy subject, but it's worse to forget history. I, for one, *in this context*, value art for being art, even if it was propaganda. Pretty much, back then, if you wanted to be an artist, you had a quota of such works, the others had to pass censorship; you, again pretty much, had to sell your soul to the devil. Some did it happier than others.
So, keep the discussion going - don't worry, you won't hurt anyone's feelings - at least mine
.
(If anyone is interested in how the State (in this case, Romania) was dealing with its enemies, I recommend this reading:
https://www.crossroad.to/Quotes/communism/communist-senate-hearing-wurmbrand.htm . It is the testimony of a priest that refused to be a "collaborator" and paid dearly - if Christianity in general triggers you, I suggest you skip this.)
One last comment: by no means, as a hater of Communism, I am making them to be worse than devil itself. It wouldn't be fair. Not everything they did was...evil. While they couldn't care less if I were starving - it didn't happen, but I'm quite sure my parents did a few times, so that me, sister (brother was born after Communism was - in theory at least - history) didn't, the education I received (minus the brainwashing) was performance-oriented, and I, to this day, reap its benefits. Some things were done right.)