Chuck,
What Photopoint has done is dishonorable and unethical, but I think you'll find that it's probably not illegal
Im not going to discuss here the legality matter and Im also not an expert in American legal issues. After I have met some reports about one beauty have poured hot coffee on her cleavage and won the lawsuit against restaurateur and another beauty have carried on infinite lawsuit against President about some more than disputable f#$%ing about 20 years ago no offence please but Im really not an expert in such matters.
Just to explain some things you probably have missed:
- To sell something they should own this thing first, right? But they do not own my photos, so what way they could legally sell them, no matter me or anyone else? Perhaps software company should know this better than you and me... Is this legal or illegal?
- They didnt provide service what they were paid for. No matter was it small or great amount, they got the amount they have asked. Is this legal or illegal?
- Proposition to sell me my own photos smells for me like proposition to sell someone his (her) own letters or any other private documents with clearly visible between lines mentioning to do net sell them to anyone else. Does it look like some kind of blackmailing, legal or illegal? Please note, I do not mixing publicized photo with document of strictly private contents. The common point is another they do not have rights for both
Greatly probably you wouldnt feel yourself so proud and happy if your allegedly
expensive and reliable file hosting service would do something like PhotoPoint did. Maybe Im pretty naive relying on cheap service but you do not seem less naive for me thinking that higher expense have to warranty you better service.
PhotoPoint never run any charitable business, I guess their so-called free image hosting was asked to get profits from advertising. It is not my business was it profitable or not. I didnt get any profits from their business so why should I bear their costs?
Bottom line, since two years ago my body- and security guards license has expired I have 100% of my household from writing and photographing. But even in this situation I do not recalculate each my word or picture into money. If I would withdraw my support for someone whom I have this support promised no matter paid or free I would feel myself pretty badly, believe me or not...
BTW, I wouldnt have any reservations if they would
lose my images, Im enough serious to make backup copies for all my writings and images and to keep them for long, long time, probably even somewhat longer than my life...