Bark River Bravo 1 or Fallkniven F1????

Joined
May 19, 2008
Messages
1,746
Hey guys Im looking at getting one of these two blades. Ive already had the Bravo but sold it, hated the thumb ramp. The handles were crazy comfortable though! Ive been searching the forums and have come across problems with both, either chipping, rolling edges and breaking. I know different steels are available for both, A2, S35V, VG10, G3. What are your thoughts on these two, one better than the other, better reputation? Thanks
 
You can get the Bravo-1 with out the thumb ramp (or buy the config you want and send it to Bark River and they'll take the ramp off for you), they're also out in CPM-3V now, that would be my choice (I have a Bravo-1 in A2, and plan on getting a Bravo-1.5 in 3V when they come out) Although I also plan on getting a VG-10 F1.
b1_blue_black_rampless_259_95_600.jpg
 
Last edited:
You can get the Bravo-1 with out the thumb ramp, they're also out in CPM-3V now, that would be my choice (I have a Bravo-1 in A2, and plan on getting a Bravo-1.5 in 3V when they come out) Although I also plan on getting a VG-10 F1.

Well, you were no help! LOL I did forget to put that in my OP, I would look at the Bravo w/o the ramp.
 
F1s only have chipping problems when they're brand new. After a couple of sharpenings they perform flawlessly. I like mine a lot and carry it more than any other small outdoor knife.
 
I have an use both. The Bravo-1 is 4.25 inches while the F1 is 3.8. As others have said you can get the Bravo-1 in different steels. The A2 is fine and sharpens well. I do like 3V and may get one in that as well to see the difference. I like the Bravo-1 a bit better because of the handle, blade shape, and larger size. Both will serve you well.
 
Last edited:
Both great knives, available in great steels.

Either will serve you well.

The Bark River handle and being made in the USA makes my choice easy.



PS - Some Fallkniven models are available with Bark River handles, making the choice even harder.




Big Mike
 
Anyone else own both and use them?

I have both. I like the Bark River better, though I cary the F1 more. The F1 is quite a bit lighter than the Bravo 1, so it gets a lot more dirt time.

I think you'd be hard pressed to find something you could do with one that you couldn't do with the other.

I've had micro-chipping on the F1, though nothing to get too worked up about. I had serious edge rolling and breaking on the B1 because it was ground too thin at the factory. I sent it back and they reground it and it's been fine since.

I have a Bravo 1 Necker in 3v and while it's a nice, tough steel, I'm not that sold on it (the steel). It stays sharp for a long time, but it looses that wicked sharpness very quickly, and it's a bear to sharpen.

If I had to pick just one I guess it would be the plane-jane F1. With the factory handle you can find them for around $110; about half the cost of a Bravo 1. Or you could go with the 3v F1 if you like wearing out sheet after sheet of sandpaper.
 
Last edited:
Have a bravo 1 that rolled...my F1, S1 or A1 never chipped or rolled...and I beat them significantly harder and far more often! Never liked the thumb ramp on the Bravo 1 either and too lazy to send it in to get ground off. Handle is also slick when wet for that damn waxed micarta! Dont like that as well! Didnt have the experience with my Bravo 1 I thought I was looking for. It is a nice knife, I just strongly prefer my Fallknivens to it...hell I prefer my Fallknivens to everything...they are my favorites
 
  • Like
Reactions: vba
My vote is for the F1 simply b/c I have never really heard anything bad about them, even though I must admit I do like the Barkies
 
Its a tuff call for sure. The F1 is better priced, but it can be had in a Micarta for a lot more. However it would feel like the BR, someone told me or I read, that BR puts the handles on these? Is that correct?
 
Its a tuff call for sure. The F1 is better priced, but it can be had in a Micarta for a lot more. However it would feel like the BR, someone told me or I read, that BR puts the handles on these? Is that correct?

That's correct. KnivesShipFree has a large selection of them, though the prices are steep. I had a hard time justifying paying over $100 for a pretty handle on a utility knife.

I REALLY didn't like the look of the factory handle on the F1, but after using it I found I quite like it. The handle is also one of the reasons the F1 weighs so much less than the Bravo 1.

If you're so inclined you can also buy a F1 blank (for about the same cost as a stock F1) and put your own handle on it. You'd have to come up with your own sheath, but frankly the F1 sheath (and the new BRKT sheaths) are pretty poor.

For me, the F1 with the factory handle is like a Glock; all utility, no flash, no charm. The Kimber is your pride and joy, but it stays in the safe while the ugly-duckling Glock goes into the field every day.

The F1 is just not one of those knives you lovingly fondle to admire the ergonomics and old world craftsmanship. It is, however, the knife that gets used the most because it works so well without any extra fluff to lug around.

Before any Bravo 1 fans get their panties in a wad, I'm not detracting from the utility of that knife. It's a great knife and much "nicer" than the factory F1. But it's twice the price and (for me) not as useful, or at least not a knife I use as much.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: vba
I got both my Bravo-1's, albeit with basic micarta handles for $130 NIB (two and a half years ago) and more recently a slightly used one with the factory leather sheath for $140. Look around there are deals out there, especially on the secondary market. You can always send it to BRKT for their "Spa Treatment" for the price of return shipping.

That being said, the F1 is a nice little package and will do just about everything a knife should do.

IMHO, they are very different knives. I like the stainless of the F1, and its a good, versatile woods/survival knife. Mine lives in my flight bag, but doesn't get used much, hence why I like the stainless. It is a SMALL, compact knife, with a 3.8 inch blade.

The Bravo-1 while only a bit longer is a much larger knife. Its thicker, with a wider, slightly longer blade at 4.25 inches. It feels much bigger than the F1 and gives me more all around confidence for the woods. I carry this knife on day hikes as well as backpacking/camping.

Hopefully somebody will post side by side pics. A better comparison to the F1 would be the ESEE-3, BRKT Gunny and Fiddleback Forge Production Recluse. I have these as well and its hard to pick from them. They are all that good.
 
F1 or get A1 .....................fallknivens steel is pretty good and doesnt rust!!!!!!!!!
 
bravo1 has spine thats too tick and edge is very thin.......dont understand that concept at all..........
 
F1 or get A1 .....................fallknivens steel is pretty good and doesnt rust!!!!!!!!!

bravo1 has spine thats too tick and edge is very thin.......dont understand that concept at all..........


So you recommend the A1 that is thicker than the B1 with a saber grind, thin edge and an overall steeper geometry?


I dont understand that concept at all..........

Mod. A1L
Total length: 280 mm (11")
Blade length: 160 mm (6.3")
Blade thickness: 6 mm (0.24")
Tang: Almost full tang, tang visible at handle end
Weight (knife): 305 g (12 oz)
Steel: Lam. VG10
Blade hardness: 59 HRC
Handle: Kraton®
Sheath: Läder
 
Back
Top