Bark River Knife and Tool Hudson Bay Camp Knife Review

k_estela

Co-Moderator, Wilderness and Survival Skills Forum
Moderator
Joined
Feb 23, 2001
Messages
2,101
HBCK_DCM.jpg
I recently had the opportunity to field test the Bark River Knife and Tool Hudson Bay Camp on a canoe trip in the Adirondacks. Used as a camp knife for assorted tasks, the BRKT Hudson Bay excelled in camp crafting and all purpose cutting, chopping and slicing. There was something satisfying about using a traditional blade for traditional tasks in this region of NY. Unlike the many sharpened pry bars with painted on finishes, the Hudson Bay Camp doesn’t scream “threatening”, “Tactical” or “military-style.” This review demonstrates the difference between what you want and what you need.
Far too many knives are overbuilt. Thicknesses in excess of .25”, rough handles with deep checkered handle slabs, “skull crusher” pommels, these are all features not necessary for a woods-going knife. While these features look great in movies, in the hands of camouflaged models in knife magazines or when drooled over in showcases, they serve no real purpose or function in the field. The BRKT Hudson Bay Camp on the other hand, is the perfect blend of function, style and craftsmanship. From the high polished brass to the period-correct sheath (mine was treated with the proprietary “E” Sharpshooter Sheath System extreme weather conditioning), the Hudson Bay Camp is a work of art and historically true to form.
Measuring in at .215” thick and 8.25” long, the BRKT Hudson Bay Camp blade is thick enough for heavy duty use yet ground the full height grind aides in slicing. Combined with a convex edge, the blade is an amazingly sharp and virtually friction free design. The high finish (not quite mirror) is not something many knife makers provide in their products since it takes more time and skill to apply. The brass bolsters are held on by pins which are almost impossible to see since they are blended in flush. The handle on my test knife is Dark Curly Maple and it is large enough for use with gloved hands and smooth for use with bare hands. At 13” overall, the Hudson Bay Camp is not a fixed blade you carry with you all the time. You should already have a small 4” sized blade for that purpose already. It is a knife that can be hung in the camp kitchen and used by whoever whenever.

100_2123.jpg

The knife was used by me and the rest of my group. Those who handled it said it cut nicely and had a good feel to it. Perhaps the best use of the knife came with an impromptu lesson on battoning the adults gave a couple of the younger kids in our group. I’d venture so far to say a little kid using a knife incorrectly can put as much strain on a blade as an experienced user with good form. In good form and in bad, the Hudson Bay Camp made its way through beech, maple and birch with no damage to the blade at all. In setting up my camp, I carefully used the side of the blade to pound makeshift tent pegs into the semi frozen ground. The wide body of the blade worked great as a spoon and as a quick way to get roasted sausages from the fire to my mouth.

100_2141.jpg


100_2127.jpg

As a general purpose camp knife, the Hudson Bay Camp passes every test. There are no cinder blocks to chop through, no car hoods to pierce and no free hanging hemp rope to sever. These fantasy tests are for those who don’t use a knife in reality. Wood to be split, meats to be sliced and fuzz sticks to be shaved are the true measure of a camp knife and something the average user can expect to do in reality. As previously mentioned, this knife was a joy to test in a region where it could have been used years ago, the Adirondacks. Could I have used a sharpened prybar, yes, would it have worked, yes, but was it more than I needed, yes again. With the BRKT Hudson Bay Camp, I had more knife than I needed but well within reason.

100_2135.jpg



It is easy to want knives that are overbuilt or designed to look a certain way. It is also difficult to accept the knife you actually need. I think the needs of the average knife user could be met with a $20 pocketknife. However, these users are compelled to take out a second mortgage on their houses to afford an aesthetically pleasing and overpriced big blade. Now, a dedicated camp knife exists which combines practicality, value and style, the BRKT Hudson By Camp knife. As an outdoorsman you’ll have all the knife you need and if you are interested in historical pieces and quality, you’ll have all the knife you want.


100_2128.jpg
 
Last edited:
great review kevin...:thumbup: those H.B's look cool... i really like the traditional aspect of them....:) i love the pic of it next to the dutch oven...
 
Nice review and pics man, that's a super-sweet looking blade. I like the blade shape and how the balance 'appears' to be. Too many blades on the ol' wish list already!
 
awsome review :thumbup: the hudson bay camp knife is one of the BRKT's that i really think i need to get. i dont have any bark river knives yet, but this one or the little creek are my favorite designs from them.
 
Thanks for the review. It's a good looking knife except for the bolsters. Don't know what it is but I can't stand them.
 
Nice review Kev. :thumbup:

I’ve been testing my Hudson Bay Camp Knife for the past few months and have been quite impressed by it’s performance.

hbc045zh3.jpg


hbc102kl2.jpg


hbc108uh2.jpg


Plus, like you point out, not only is it a pleasure to use, it is very appealing as well.

I smile every time I find an excuse to put it into service. :D



"If you're not living on the edge, …you're taking up too much space."

Big Mike
 
hbc054bm7.jpg


As knives go I found it to be a very good chopper.




"If you're not living on the edge, …you're taking up too much space."

Big Mike
 
Great review kev....It looks like you guys put it through its paces!! Thats a great lookin knife, I was looking at it the other day. Interesting clippoint shape on it. It has almost a tribal look to it. I like it, even though I must not use a knife in reality.:o;)
 
Nice review Kevin. I take it you weren't in a very 'tactical' mood today. I certainly never considered BRKT's as underbuilt knives and at .215" thick it is pretty close to 1/4". It does look like a great camp knife. The lack of guard on it coupled with having a really pronounced clip on the blade like that does makes it look a bit strange to me.

I sort of prefer the visuals of the CDN Camp Knife and Big Sky Camp knives to this one. Still it looks like a solid performer and is a bit longer then the others too.
 
Last edited:
I've been trying NOT to want the Hudson Bay since I first noticed it awhile back. I like the Lil Nessy in your picture too.

I've been trying to cut bck my accumulation of knives, and this isn't helping!
 
Kevin, awesome.

I have "needed" this knife like I have needed so many other BRKT knives for so damn long now....:sigh:
 
Back
Top