Bark River Smoke Jumper Action WOW!

Joined
Aug 1, 2008
Messages
491
Often times, there is a particular question that arises. "If I only needed one knife..." and I am sure you know how the rest of the story goes. I had the opportunity to put the Bark River Smoke Jumper to use and through a few paces this weekend. With the beautiful Wisconsin River and it's banks as my playground, it was time to see how well this knife would serve in the field.

Any image may be clicked for enlargement.



When I removed the Smoke Jumper from it's box and unwrapped it, the first thing that came to mind was how light and nimble it was. For a knife with a 6.2" blade and 11.2" overall, it handles and feels very small. The handles are nicely contoured and very sizable to accommodate the largest of hands, while still being very controllable in smaller hands. It wasn't until I actually started to use it that I finally broke down to call Mike Stewart and tell him just how impressively lightweight this knife was for it's size. Even more intriguing is the knife steel comes from .175" stock. This is no bunny poot knife by a long shot.

Putting the knife on my belt for the first time told me the knife was going to be easy and lightweight to carry. The dangler style sheath carries well and the knife is held in place securely with a retention strap.



The first thing I needed in order to start putting this knife to work was a heavy weight baton. I found a cluster of Ironwood (musclewood) and there was a small tree that looked like the perfect diameter to me to fashion a baton out of. Since I didn't yet have a baton, I had to whittle my way through the small tree and this proved to be a very easy task. The Smoke Jumper chewed and clicked it's way through the wood quite easily. While this came as no surprise to me, I found that I was more impressed with this knife than some others I have used for this task given the VERY heavy convex geometry. In the pictures to come, you will see that the grind only comes up about 60% of the height. Compound this with a very thick .175" stock, and you have a very heavy geometry on this knife. I guess, knowing this, I was pretty impressed.





Now that I had a very strong and fairly heavy baton, I wanted to see how well this knife chewed up some hard wood cross grain style. I found a 5" diameter long maple log, propped it up on a fallen Oak tree from a recent wind storm and started to throw some chips. If you look at the maple log, this is not green wood. It is tough, dry and apparently older given what the wood looks like under the bark. Now, keep in mind, this is a tremendous amount of work for a knife to do. Obviously, people will use a chainsaw or an ax for a task like this, but what this instills in my mind is the ability and confidence in the knife should I ever need to call on it for such a task. The Smoke Jumper took the hits with ease, it chewed deep and was easily controlled in hand.



Snap cutting a branch off of that Ironwood tree was almost a joke. It really was not fair. I was even more surprised at how I drove clean through with 2 hits from the baton. I figured it might have taken a few whacks given how steep the geometry was, but I really was pleasantly surprised.



I am a sucker for a good campfire, and given the "camp utility" built into this knife along with the ability to double in the tactical role, I decided a good fire was in order. Now I can split up some wood with it. I had several red and white oak logs sitting down by the fire pit next to the river, and proceeded to use this wood for my review.

What I enjoyed about the way this knife drove through the wood, was how it lengthened the split drastically, almost in ax-like fashion. Again, and I have said it several times, the heavy geometry really made exceptionally short work of splitting this wood. It took far less hits with the baton than a knife with thinner geometry.



I even purposely sought out a big knot in the wood. I have put light kinks into knives before by hitting a knot, but this wasn't the case for the Smoke Jumper. While I only have one picture showing this, there were many splits that I purposely sought out a knot on. I am quite positive the Smoke Jumper was getting a little bored with this task. It was effortless.

 
I also wanted to see how well I could shave off some curls for the upcoming fire. Having used this knife for well over an hour now, and not having sharpened it, this was a good test for edge retention. I am a sucker for Bark Rivers A2 steel. It is tough, holds an edge and just does not stop. The Smoke Jumper comes equipped with a very tough 50-100B carbon tool steel. I have a couple Bark Rivers in that steel, but I have never really whomped on any of them like I did on the Smoke Jumper.

Edge retention was remarkable. I sliced off many curls by hand, and had little trouble doing so.







After gathering some dry tinder and sprinkling the dry oak curls on top, and having split up an adequate amount of starter wood, it was time to get this campfire going and declaring warfare on the mosquitoes and moths.





I decided this was a great time to get the KSF Firewallet a little exposure as well, so after getting a spark on some char cloth from the flint and steel and wrapping the char cloth in some fuzzed up jute, I placed the bundle into the tinder pile, and with a couple puffs, my fire came to life.







This knife saw a lot of work. It never complained about any of it and performed every task with great efficiency. The edge, even after all this work and not touching a strop, still shaved hair. Needless to say, I quickly gained a new respect for this steel. I am impressed with the build quality, the attention to detail for usefulness, the comfort and the serious lack of weight. The Smoke Jumper has now replaced my Bark River SOCOM 5 in my truck. It is a fantastic and well designed tool.

Don't forget to swing over to Derrick's site at www.knivesshipfree.com to pick one of your choosing. He is an active member on these forums and a great guy.
 
Great review - I am not a fan of the guard - but that is TOTALLY personal choice.

Isn't it nice to have a knife that you think 'I love this thing - I don't think about it - it just does what I want' ?

How was the edge retention - after you beat the crap out of it - how was the edge? If you haven't stropped it yet - run it through some magazine paper - and see if it sticks or tears. If not - she is a TRUE slicer.

I will wager, after doing this type of stuff with my Aurora that you will find you will need to strop this knife like once a month! ;)

One last thing - did you test the tip by giving yourself the tat on your inside forearm? ;)

Good show man - good show!

TF
 
Great review and thanks for all the pics. I havent seen that model. I am really digging it. Gaurds dont seem to bother me too much especially on a design like that. I'll have to check it out, I like Bark Rivers and think that looks like a good one to add to my collection.
 
Excellent viewpoints and comments folks.

The guard was not much of a hindrance at all. Matter of fact, now that I am putting some thought into it, I really didn't even know it was there. Keep in mind, this is a "do all" utility knife. Designed to function both in the woods and in military situations. A lot of the Spec Ops jungle hoppers in Nam carried Randalls. Many of them had double quillion guards.

There are a few single quillions available. I am pretty sure if you asked Bark River, they would remove both if you sent it in. VERY easy fix.

The edge shaved arm hair afterwards. I did not even touch it to a strop after all that.

LOL on the tat. My good friend, and one who went to the Bark River Ice-In back at the end of Feb with me did that work. It cost me a Bark River Blackwater Boot knife in Maple Bark Bone. The 15" Eagle tat that he did on my back cost me a Bark River Little Chute. We are pretty damn good friends. :D
 
I think that with a thicker blade - battoning does not touch the edge nearly as much s it does with a thinner blade - I think this helps slpit wood easier and also retains the blade sharpness.

TF
 
Great review Jeff, :thumbup: :cool: :thumbup:

…Glad to see that I’m not the only one to see this knife as a great all-a-rounder.


Looks like you have had more field time then me, and the knife is working well.

I look forward to getting the Jumper out in the woods soon. :)





I love the fact that it’s in 50-100B high carbon steel, some tough stuff.





"If you're not living on the edge, …you're taking up too much space."

Big Mike


Forest & Stream
 
Nice review, glad you are so pleased with your blade! It looks like a real winner. I don't care the swedge too much, but I think that is a lot of conditioning related to spending time here on W&SS. I do like the wrap around handle and can see it being very useful in the winter.
 
Mike, I know your review is going to be first rate. I can't wait to read it.

KGD, the swedge is the "tactical" side of things regarding the knife. I agree that it will not appeal to everyone, but it will damn sure do most anything anyone asks of it. I think that is really what sets it apart. Keep in mind, the knife will penetrate well with the swedge, but it also shaves off a bit of weight as well. You just cannot believe how lightweight this knife is for the dimensional size it carries. It is really not like any other knife in that size I have handled and used.
 
Looks like a real good knife.
I've yet to see a Bark River that actually sucks.

I've got to ask -- what's everyone's problem with swedges? It allows for a husky spine with a fine tip.
 
Good review! I like my Smoke Jumper, too. It is light and strong. For me, the 6" blade works well for a field knife. More blade means I can split bigger wood. Mine has the single quillion.
SJ015.jpg

SJ007.jpg
 
I've got to ask -- what's everyone's problem with swedges? It allows for a husky spine with a fine tip.

A clip does that just as effectively when done right. You don't need to have the top side sharpened to produce an extremely pointy point. Just have to touch on of Magnussen's points to figure that out real quick.

I think it is a visual aesthetic and the fact that the swedge associates it with a weapon or pig sticker. But then again, I admit it is just a small bias for me. In the end it looks like everyone is readily able to baton their smoker jumper without chewing up the baton too badly so it isn't that much of a handicap to performance and provides a nice way of optimizing the balance of the knife.
 
Mine has the single quillion.


Looking good Vic, :thumbup: :cool: :thumbdn:

…the Single Quillian Guard does not take much away from the overall look of the “Jumper”.



I think it is a visual aesthetic...

...and provides a nice way of optimizing the balance of the knife.


There is something about the extra facets provided by the swedge that really adds a lot of visual interest for me. :cool:



I understand the down side, and have torn-up a few batons beating on swedged spines, but they are just batons. :eek:

The combination of good looks and good balance tip my opinion toward a swedge every time. :D



That said, I’m less likely to want a swedge on a dedicated chopper.





"If you're not living on the edge, …you're taking up too much space."

Big Mike


Forest & Stream
 
Thanks. It is worth the price.

As far as the swedge goes, what was impressive alone was the tip strength. I mean I beat on the front of that blade pretty hard, especially in that big maple log. I probably hit it harder than I actually would have in real world hiking and camping use. Of course, I don't really fear doing this given the Bark River warranty either.

Vic, I agree with Mike on that single quillion. It looks great on this knife.
 
In the end it looks like everyone is readily able to baton their smoker jumper without chewing up the baton too badly so it isn't that much of a handicap to performance and provides a nice way of optimizing the balance of the knife.

OK, to everyone in general. . .are you all using some special kind of baton that you don't want it chewed up? Mine just end up being the last piece thrown on the fire.

Do you guys finish them, decorate them and reuse them or something?
Seriously, I always hear about guys not wanting to chew up the baton, and wonder what I'm missing.
 
Back
Top