You guys are all ooohhing and aaaahiiing. Fair enough.
The emperor has no clothes.
That this was done in Russia is amazing, I will give you that. The metal carving is top notch, better than most anything that I have seen with maybe the exception of Wolfe Loerchner, Larry Fuegen and stuff in museums, but...
The damascus is totally not right for the dagger grind, the pattern wisps off to one side about two inches from the point. The pattern also competes with the rest of the work. Blued carbon steel would have been the right base for this sculpture.
The ivory carving is a bit better than when Dr. Paul Grussenmeyer started using his dental drill to carve stag and stuff, but is still sophmoric, and a waste of good ivory IMHO.
I hate to bring this up, but I wish that one of you had. Can you not see it? Or are you just too polite to mention it?
The guy from Tula has massive potential, and I hope that he can work with someone who can help him refine his skills, like Virgil England or the afformentioned Wolfe, who does EVERYTHING with files. That blows me away, and has for 20 years.
Let the public flogging begin, but this cycle of a guy posting a picture and then everyone going "WOW, that's amazing" when there are clearly apparent flaws, or the knife is a copy of something Jerry Fisk did 5 years ago makes my head feel like it is going to explode.
Let's have some critique here, not just a back-pat session.
Rant off,
Best Regards,
STeven Garsson