Becker testing

Joined
Dec 14, 1998
Messages
4,870
I just confirmed it for myself. The Beckers are bad to the bone! Rope cutting , chopping,
you name it we did it. After all the tests I checked the edges. Every one was in the same condition as when they were fresh from the box. Great products. Got to meet Mr Becker and the camillus gang also . Good folks.

------------------
Web Site At www.darrelralph.com
 
Darrel
Did you get to test the Magnum Camp? Would like to know what you think of it after the tests. I did some things with it that the custom knives did not do during out last cutting competetion at the school.
jf
 
Mr Fisk NLT :; I bow to da king!
Yes ! We tested the magnum camp with all the other knives.
Of coarse being an ABS guy I was IN LOVE with it. I felt it needed more testing because of its nature and multi fuction. It was put through the same tests plus more and was a great design for sure. Now for the real great news . The design fit just what you said it would do. A camp knife. A camp knife should be able to do small chores and large chores IMHO. Most feel it is a fully rounded knife for a one knife carry in the camp situation. I feel it should be a knife that even if you need to... will do everything from fillet a fish or chop a tree down. THIS KNIFE WILL DO IT.
I got meat cutting detail from Mr becker in the kitchen. We used it to carve bear meat and deer meat roasted.
I did a raw deer loin taking off the thin tendion( this is a bitch) and cutting it up, bacon, 8 full hugh garlic cloves,hot peppers and sevral other kitchen chopping and cutting chores . It went then to the hanging rope cutting test and passed. Then on to the wood chopping test and passed.

IMHO when cutting (slicing ) the rope (2") on a board it did the best of the line.
All the knives were hammered on the backspine to split wood also.
At first sight the handles looked a bit different to me on the camillus becker line. But after using the knives I know why they were designed the way they were. THEY WORK... no blisters and they are rounded in the right places to allow long use times without losing your grip and making your hand cramp. We also did a paper slicing test.. The magnum camp did the best here also. The others have a thicker blade for other types of use.
But for the folks who like thick kick butt knives for other types of use the thicker knives kick butt in that arena.
One thing I have to say is I thought the coating would scratch BUT IT DIDNT. It mared a little but it hung through some tough testing with magazine, and many other camillus clients watching.
The brute was a great knife for anything extreme.
The maxchex (SP) did the chores it was designed for very well. I didnt understand the thinner section of the curve. After I was educated I understood . It is for shaving log ods and shaping wood for building and then is a hachet type tool on the front end. It will cut a tree down in a heart beat.
The companion is for smaller heavy duty chores.
The tac tool is bad to the bone and will be a popular tool for leo's, spook, and tac operators. The folks who attended that are versed in pure tac arena had coments like yup every tac team will have this one soon.
I think thats all of them and I hope the knives in my mind eye are correct to the name.

Note this is just my opinion of what I saw in real life. I have been to the factory . The heat treat and steel choice combonation is the real heart of these knives. Camillus uses excellent heat treat processes to get this high standard.

I was also the edge checker. NONE of these knives had a flat spot,ding or wrinkle on the edge after this type of REAL life use. They were as sharp as when the came from the box..
These knives are a good well thought out product.
Im sure there are other extreme tests for these knives. IMHO they were tested for there
real life purpose and not tests that do not apply in my world.


------------------
Web Site At www.darrelralph.com

[This message has been edited by Darrel Ralph (edited 06-07-2000).]
 
Thanks guys,
You've got me blushing
redface.gif
biggrin.gif


Darrel, your right, the MAGNUM CAMP is one Turbo-Charged Tactical Camp Knife! My hat is off the the insightful design from Mr Fisk!

One more point, ...Darrel lets not forget one of the REAL standouts during our informal testing, New-Comer Matt Lamey's Bowie that Lombardo had with him. That knifewas awesome at rope cutting. I think I'll need to give Mr Lamey a call myself.

I'm up too late now, and off outta town tomorrow, but when I return monday, I'll try to get some pics up from the CAMILLUS POST BLADESHOW RETREAT. Take care folks!


------------------
Stay Sharp!
Will Fennell
Camillus Cutlery
www.camillusknives.com
 
Hey Will
Yes the Lamey Knife was a rope cutting machine. Very ASB style bowie.. Nice!
But hell you got me going now! How about a Kit Carson model four folder that went half way through? Thats a great knife also. Low weight short blade and it did the job well. It takes some big kahunas to let a wild man like you swing a folder in a rope test that they were not designed for. Confidance in strength design was the question in my mind as the folder can slamming down at 450 miles per hour! Im sure Kit was happy!


------------------
Web Site At www.darrelralph.com

[This message has been edited by Darrel Ralph (edited 06-07-2000).]
 
I have the Brute and am very impressed with it. Since I got it home and gave it a little road test on the jungle like vegetation here, I've been chomping at the bit, waiting (impatiently) for the arrival of the Magnum Camp Knife at my local dealer. The same day he gets'em, I'll have one.
biggrin.gif

Guaranteed! I've got the money if he'll just get the knife!

------------------
The individualist without strategy who takes opponents lightly will inevitably become the captive of others.
Sun Tzu
 
The Brute is worthy of its name.THE ONLY KNIFE I BOUGHT AT THE BLADE SHOW!As soo as I picked it up I knew it was the knife I have been looking for.A hardcore knife for hardcore guys.This badboy will be firmly strapped to my side each and every time I go camping or hiking.All I have need to say bout that is now I can I leave the axe at home(A plus when backpacking).This S.O.B went through a 3 inch rope like it was butter.After going through it 3 or 4 times it was a conceded that it was no contest.The Brute kix ass and takes names.I am proud to have been present for this testing and to have met Ethan Becker personally.A truly great guy and one hell of a cook.

The Machaxe is another badboy.I personally saw this knife chop threw cedar trees like it was nothing.This knife should be eagerly anticipated on the market.Its beyond words.I very fine tool indeed and the only contender the Brute has.It went through those trees like it was no ones buisness.One should keep this knife in mind if you ever are going to be spending some serious time in the woods or the jungle.A very nice khurki variation.Bravo Mr.Becker!And Camillius did all of the BKT justice in the manufacturing process.Give yourselves some pats on the back y'all.Keep up the good work!
 
I’m impressed with all the Knives in the Becker line but if I had to pick a favorite it would be the Magnum Camp. It’s a fine slicer with enough bulk to chop if necessary. With its extreme cutting qualities and superb balance it handles tough jobs with minimum effort.

… If I could only have one … but wait I already have them all … even the Matchex !!
biggrin.gif
smile.gif





------------------
“We are the pilgrims masters; we shall go, always, a little farther.”
 
Scott
I like three designs the best. Magnum camp,
brute, and machex (sp)
I like the others but this is just my opinion and only MY opinion for the purposes I need the knives for. The tac tool is awesome also.
I feel for the design intended it is #1.. I dont have need for it but for those who do WOW its great.
The companion well I will let Will and Phil explain the purpose for this knife.
In this size I carry a folder.. 4.5 in blade.. BUT thats just me.
Please there is a purpose for this knife.. I just need educated on the thought process here.

------------------
Web Site At www.darrelralph.com
 
Darrel,
Like I said I’m a fan of them all ….

And by the way it was good to meet you.

From the test we preformed Monday I would take the Machex if I were stranded in the wilderness and in need of building a shelter or a log canoe as it has multi tool function-ability. Ethan (Becker) handily demonstrated this on a few of Will’s cedars showing how quickly you can get from simple chopping into more complex wood shaping operations. The brute has many similar qualities but for me would be preferred if any trail blazing was likely. Not only does it cut well but it is an absolute premium hacker; putting to shame any short machetes that I know of.

As for smaller knives … (now that you mention it
smile.gif
) … I wouldn’t mind having one of your folders in my pocket.
biggrin.gif


The strength of the Campanion is … well … its strength. I don’t see how you can hurt it.



------------------
“We are the pilgrims masters; we shall go, always, a little farther.”
 
Darrel-

About the Campanion - I have one of the original ones and it definitely has advantages over a folder. Due to it's "aspect ratio" (ie thickness to length) it's about as strong as they come. Smal enough to be used for most any chore, but big enough to do some chopping. It's also small enough that you can conceal it fairly easily. I can cut >1" trees in one chop, can your folders do that? I think it's a great knife, and normally I like thin stock cutting machines. BTW, I have a Magnum Camp on order - I think it will be my fave. I kicked myself a thousand times for not getting it when BJ made them. Have a good one.

-Bart
 
I can think of a few large folders that can but you have a point. It is a damned good entry tool. Small trees ect it would do the job. My heart likes the magnum camp though. Just a thin blade nut in me I guess.

------------------
Web Site At www.darrelralph.com

[This message has been edited by Darrel Ralph (edited 06-19-2000).]
 
I just got the Magnum Camp in. Yep, it's my fave, too. I am looking forward to enjoying this one!

-Bart
 
Back
Top