Benchmade Offsider Vs CRKT M60 vs CS OSS

Joined
Dec 2, 2004
Messages
11
Hello all, I am looking to buy a large fixed blade knife just because I can. I have no special purpose or need for the knife I just want one. It looks like I can get any of the three for around the same price $60-$70. So, of these three choices which would you choose and why? Any and all opinions are welcome.
Thanks Fenrir.
 
I think I would go with the Benchnade offsider for a couple of reasons. One it has a full length and width tang that the handles attach too. I think it would be a very solid set up. I've read that Cold Steels Kraton handles can become loose although I have not had this happen on the SRK I owned. Secondly I like the blade shape of the offsider, I think it would be a pretty practical shape. Plus I just like its looks better than the other two. I hope to pick one up eventually. Just my .02. Good Luck!


John
 
I have no experience with the other two, but I can comment on the CRKT M60. I own and have used the M60-14PK (serrated spear point).

All things considered, it's a good knife, particularly given its cost. Surprisingly, I'm more a fan of the drop sheath than the knife itself, and I have gone on a number of outings with a Delta 5 in the sheath and the M60 back home on my desk. The sheath is versatile, adjustable, and comfortable, and the secondary pouch is perfect for carrying a multitool or mini survival kit. The M60 itself is a decent blade. it has a full edge grind on one side only, making it an 'almost chisel-grind.' The coating is solid. I'm not sure how it will last in the long run, but it shows wear less than a Ka-Bar. Edge retention is also decent, and sharpening is a breeze, even with a pocket ceramic. The handle shape is extremely comfortable, and pretty grippy, particularly with light gloves. The raised thumb area of the handle / guard allows you to control the knife during precision work. HOWEVER, the thumb serrations must have been designed by someone who wants to sell band-aids. With any serious use, you are bound to tear up your thumb unless you are wearing gloves. Ultimately, it's not a bad knife, but I would prefer a blade with a dual (V) grind and more comfortable thumb serrations. The sheath design is great, though.

I hope that helps. I second GarageBoy's comments about the Swamp Rat, although I would suggest a Becker BK7 or Campainion as well.

- Mike
 
The Offsider is an excellent knife. If you don't get the Offsider I'd look at a Becker rather than the CRKT or Cold Steel. (Or spend the bucks for a Ranger or Swamp Rat.)

The Offsider is basically a modern Sheffield bowie.:) It's a hair under 1/4", balances just in front of the forefinger, and has great ergos in saber, hammer, or point down. I'm not a big cordura sheath guy, but this is a good example of the breed - tool/folder/stone pouch, multiple carry options and tie downs, and a formed plastic insert for the blade. Lots of Velcro, lots of features.

It seems pretty purpose built as a fighter that can do utility work, rather than a woodsmans knife - like I said, holding it, instead of looking at it online, it screams bowie. It cuts well, nice double hollow grind with a swedge that comes unsharpened but is thin enough to hone. I made a big pot of chili with mine for a potluck, it was thick for onions but hell on peppers and beef, and the straight profile and short integral guard let it work well in full rocking chef knife mode.

It is NOT designed as a chopper. It does chop, fairly well, but it doesn't have the balance or edge geometry to outchop even a light bolo, khukri, etc. If you're looking for your first chopper, this isn't really it. But it's a good all around field knife that chops fine on light stuff and does OK on the thicker wood, it just can't chop a 2x4 or thick branch any where near as fast as a serious whacker can. It would be awkward as a skinner.

It would, in my opinion, be an excellent boar hunting knife, in the finishing thrust sense - great ergonomics, pointy but not narrow, wide wound channel and deep penetration.

I'm very fond of mine. I don't own a M60 or OSS, but compared to the CRKT and Cold Steel fixed blades I do own, the fit and finish is significantly better and the value for the dollar is incredible.:thumbup: :thumbup: :thumbup:
 
See if you could pick up a Benchmade Presidio. It looks really nice, but I know it's a little more dough though.
 
Back
Top