Hi Stich,
I don't think you've read what I said... Do I say Buck BK&T and RAT are arent' good knife? NO
I say IF I have to choose a knife, specialy for something as serious as survival, I prefer invest a bit more money in a proven quality knife than buying a cheap medium quality knife.
I don't say Buck RAT and BK&T are BAD, but compared to Swamp Rat, they're medium, and that is a fact...
That said I personnaly own some very good Buck 110, Spydercos etc...