Best bang for the buck?

Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Messages
17,508
My three favorite knife companies these days, and for a long time, are Case, Victorinox, and Opinel. Case, for the knife I really love on a day to day basis is my peanut. I'm addicted the the Case peanut both as a nice little cutter, and as male pocket jewelry. Devon Thomas damascus steel goes well with amber jigged bone.

Opinel has an old world charm funky design. I love old world and funky. I drove a VW bug for 30 years and still love my old school Vespa PX150. The two stroke motor leaves a smell of oil in it's wake, but that's all part of old Vespa's.

Then there's Victorinox SAK's.

I guess I've been carrying a Victorinox SAK around longer than any other knife, and I've given some away, traded off others in a steady parade of SAK's that came and went in my life. I've tried all kinds of combinations of tools and number of layers, and came to a conclusion that simple is good. But, no matter what kind of knife I had, there was always a SAK around. A lot of things attracted me to Victorinox, like predicable quality, fit and finish. No matter where in the world you are, the SAK you pick up will be just like the SAK back home. No hand sorting of the on hand stock needed. Then there's the iron clad Victorinox warrantee. If something lets go, send it in to the service center in Shelton Connecticut and the problem is taken care of. You can buy a SAK almost anywhere, where you have to sometimes search for a knife shop or buy online for an Opinel or Case. Victorinox seems to be in any Dick's, REI, Lowes, Walmart, Target, or surplus store. I guess being the largest knife company in the world has it's advantages. Victorinox makes more knives each year than any other two, or even three knife companies together.

But when it comes to bang for the buck, they just may be in a class by themselves.

Like I said, I love knives, and have been a knife knut my whole life. But in the past few years, being much closer to the end than the beginning, I've downsized all my stuff. I just don't feel the need or have the want of much stuff. So, in this new found old age practicality, I fond myself looking for the best bang for the buck item to go down the road with. This past summer, when I was going on vacation to Key West Florida, I had to pick just one single pocket knife to mail to myself so I wouldn't be knife less in a sportsmans paradise of fishing and boating. My pick was a Victorinox recruit for 14.95 from Lowes, the big box hardware store. At the end of my vacation I gave it to the grounds keeper guy where we had been staying. Of course he was thrilled by the gift, and brings us to yet another SAK advantage. Instant recognition. Few products have the recognition of Victorinox, aside from Coke, Pepsi, and BIC.

As I said, I left a recruit behind in Key West, and I've had the vague feeling of missing it. Not like I would have missed my Case peanut if I had tried to takeit and it got lost. That would have been really a heart breaker. But still a vague feeling of something missing. I like the recruit model a lot, and it fits in with my minimalist view of things. Simple two layer SAK, my favorite kind. If I'm going out and I know I have some harder use or dirty deeds to do, I'll augment my Case peanut with a SAK. The recruit is one of my most reached for back ups. Looking at the recruit, I had the idea that it just may be the most bang for the buck pocket knife out there.

For the 14.95 they charge at Lowes, it's about the same price as an Opinel number 8, cheaper than almost any other pocket knife made by a reputable knife company, yet gives you two knife blades, two different screw drivers that work on flat or phillips, can opener and bottle opener, tweezes and toothpick. There's a lot of utility packed into that package, and may be very hard to beat the bang for the buck factor. Certainly a knife packing all that for the same price as a simple Opinel is like a free lunch.

Victorinox is a great bargain in todays world.
 
Last edited:
Agreed, I'm very fond of Victorinox for all of the reasons you've stated. Consistent quality, highly functional, at a good price. I also like Case, although I've never owned an Opinel. I personally would add a Buck 110/112 to the list of all time, quality knives at a great price, and something of an American icon, and "best bang for the Buck".
 
I also love Vic SAKs. The one I always have on me is a black Executive. It's been with me since sometime in the late '90s. I've used every feature on it (yes, even the infamous orange peeler), except for the key ring. The black scales are intact but quite scarred up now, which adds to its character, and I have no plans of ever ejecting it from my pocket. No matter what other knife I may carry, the Executive is always there.

In terms of regular-sized SAKs, I realize the old Soldier is still my favorite. It's used a lot around the house, scraping, light prying (with the bottle opener), opening cans (lots of them), turning some screws, slicing fruit, etc.

Jim
 
I own high(er) end ZT's and Spyderco's...and they are all great, but no matter which I EDC, I always toss a Vic Officer or Vic Farmer into a different pocket. Guess which one I usually reach for...

I had someone complain once that Vic's are "so practical that they are impractical." When I was about to punch him in the face, I remembered that I was the one who had a Vic in his pocket daily, and was saved by it daily (and not always by the blade!). I actually felt bad for the guy.
 
The Vic Tinker is my favorite bang for the buck knife of all time, so much you can do with it from so little money spent on it. Thanks for the reminder.
 
SAKs are great. I got a Recruit too, nice and light. Over here, the Recruit can be a bit hard to find though, but the Spartan is everywhere and has the same price as the Recruit.
 
I just got my first two SAKs in years (a Bantam and an alox Cadet). Just amazing quality for the price. I haven't had a chance to really use them much yet, but just playing around with them brings back good memories of my high school years (I watched Macgyver religiously).
 
Agreed. Though I still buy and carry other types, if pushed to pick one for the duration it would be my alox soldier.
 
SAK's are very handy! I have a couple of Tinkers and Ramblers that see alot of pocket time! I do rotate the Tinker with a Leatherman s2, which is the best lightweight MT out there!

I have a SAK Rambler on my keychain and use it all the time, whether I am using the philips head to take a desktop apart or the tweezers to pull a splinter or the little blade to open a package! :)
 
The Vic Tinker is my favorite bang for the buck knife of all time, so much you can do with it from so little money spent on it. Thanks for the reminder.

:thumbup: +1. As Father Flanagan used to say, there's no such thing as a bad Victorinox. OTOH, although the Recruit is okay, it is not the top "bang for the buck" SAK. That distinction belongs to either the Spartan or Tinker, a choice depending on whether you spend more time drinking or screwing.

There is no awl on the Recruit, which ditches it for me right there. Also, the Tinker ph driver works better in general than the small fh on the can opener, which is especially useless when the screws are countersunk. However, if you really need to pull a cork when a dedicated corkscrew in unavailable, the Spartan's is a lot more elegant solution than punching it into the bottle.

So, for two more implements in the same package at the same price, we have two clear choices for best in category. I like the Tinker.
 
Last edited:
In this day and age, when you can spend (to me at least) a passel of money on a piece of crap that falls apart in 2 weeks--and that seems to be the standard, a company like Victorinox ( and the others mentioned) put ou a product that is consistently good, inexpensive, and will last a lifetime. I have no idea how they do it, but I sure hope that thy can keep it going.
 
great post carl!.... yes, Victorinox give tons of knife for the money...

its very well build, high quality, affordable that every person should have one or some, superb steel, lots of options so every one could choose what suit them best... i mean whats not to like? its a great companion that would came handy when those high dollar and supersteel knife could not be use to tighten some screws, pick a splinter, filing some metal, twist some wires and you name it...

based on the EDC post on the main forum, even those with expensive blade carry the small and humble sak in the key ring, pocket and so on...

for the money, IMHO SAKs are true winner...
 
I love my Case peanut, but if someone decreed I could only tote Victorinox products for the rest of my life, I would not even flinch. GREAT knives at a great price, with models to cover every real-world scenario.
 
I'm fond of SAKs and Victorinox is my favorite. My wife even made me a birthday cake formed as a red SAK once. Although I believe the Swisschamp is the best of all time and I EDC one for 25 years (it was something more than 100 heavy $ of the Reagan era, it is incredibly cheap today), my most cost effective is an alox cadet my wife bought me during 1986. I was divided between this and a red farmer (about the same amount then), and choose the Cadet because it was more pocketable. Even with the higher then prices (for Greece) it costed a few cents a month to save my day countless times with it's 4 basic tools.
All around, the tools that I used more from any Victorinox I own are the blades, scissors, small pliers, screwdrivers and metal file. But the fewer times I needed the wood saw, hook or anything else, they also worked beautifully.
Victorinox spoiled me. Because of their products Wenger never satisfied me, although very close. And I looked at other knifes with certain disapproval. That's why I never got an Opinel until recently and I got my No 8 Outdoor in order to save my XLT's blades from destructing dirty work, just to see that they are another kind of high quality tool, spartan and functional and without the bells and whistles of a SAK (although my Opinel has a whistle, literally!).
 
Received my Victorinox Craftsman today, and having gone over it, I have to again agree with jackknife...Victorinox, CONSISTENTLY, makes a knife with excellent fit and finish. IMO, they're pocket jewels, and the Craftsman only cost $38. I plan to try out the Craftman as my EDC, because it has all of the tools of the average multitool, but is more pocketable than those, or a Swisschamp.
 
I agree that a SAK is a dang good deal.

Want to hear an amazing deal? On our way back from a huge flea market, my wife and I stopped at a little roadside booth. I had never had a SAK before. He had some lightly used Tinkers, and I talked him down to $2!! I love that dang knife. Great knife, and a great deal!
 
SOME Tinkers? Should have grabbed the lot and spread the joy at that price.

Good deal on a good knife. My son has one and it is very pocketable (is that a word?).
 
Pocketable is a word now! Lol.

I didn't know what I was even looking at then! It was two years ago and I wasn't in to knives at that point. Wish I could have bought all of them though!
 
Back
Top