Best stainless steel for beginner and heat treat/scale questions

Joined
Aug 1, 2016
Messages
644
Newbie here working on only my 2nd thru 4th knives right now, specializing in kitchen knives, stock removal only. All 1084 for ease of backyard heat treat. BUT... I just found a programmable kiln/oven at work that goes up to about 2200°F (1200°C), and we have an ultra low freezer that goes to about -109°F (-80°C) both which I could use on the weekend. I've already had multiple friends ask me to make custom knives and I know most people aren't as willing to care for carbon steel in the kitchen, so stainless would be a nice option.

My google-fu is weak, not finding a lot of recommendations for stainless for beginners. For ease I would like to air or plate quench for HT. Also I've been leaving the black scale on 1084 for a rustic Japanese kurouchi look, can this be replicated in stainless by HT without foil? I've looked at normalization, HT, and tempering recipes for 440c and AEB-L.

For 440c without full cryo liquid nitrogen, it looks to max at hrc 61-62. If I want 60-61 final hardness, the tempering temps seem very low (what I found on Alpha KS site). Is the only thing happening converting retained austenite to martensite, or is there another benefit? Could tempering be skipped in this case? Thanks for sharing the knowledge!
 
Last edited:
Others with more experience will have better answers, but to start things off:

> can this be replicated in stainless by HT without foil?
No, removing the foil or other barrier will cause significant decarburization unless you are operating in an atmosphere that is non-reactive (argon?).

> converting retained austenite to martensite
For all blades, I am of the understanding that tempering, however minimal, is a benefit.
For stainless steels, there are additional considerations - the tempering can impact the corrosion resistance as well as increasing the toughness of the blade.
 
If you want Rc 60-61 as a final hardness, either pick a different steel or setup a dry-ice bath. Tempering is important and can't be skipped.
 
no foil no go all carbon will be burnt out at soak temp/time
any high alloy needs cryo dry ice is a mostly good go at it
as for alloy to use CPM 154 was what i uesed for years before ti got hard to find and have switched to CTS XHP at the least i woudl in your shoes use 154cm then im not sure how pricign worked but cpm154 or aebl again dure to cost since i have not bought any in years i dont know how XHP falls into the price range
 
Why would you do this without foil?
You just lucked into a free HT oven. Buy a roll of foil. Plate-quench in the foil packet. Believe me, you'll be shocked at how little decarb there is compared to forge-treated carbon. You might never go back...

For kitchen knives for a beginner, with that equipment, I'd pick AEB-L, VG-10 (I think), or CPM154. AEB-L will be the cheapest, I think (never bought or treated VG-10 myself).
 
Cpm154. 1950 for 30 mins and plate quench. Subzero and temper at 525 twice for 3 hours gives me 61RC all day long. I normally run 440c at 58RC and am not sure how it'd perform at 61RC. You can get a roll of foil for $90 from Travers.com and it will do 200 knives or so.
 
Back
Top