Best whittler?

Joined
Feb 12, 2006
Messages
45
Hi.
First of all, I think I'm more and more becoming addicted to Spydies..
I'm more of a lurker and eager reader of other peoples writings, but I guess I'll lay some backround anyways.

When it comes to Spydercos, It all started with Dragonfly. Then came some other brand folders, but when Tasman Salt came available here where I live, bam!Had to have one.Love it.
Then got my father a Byrd Meadowlark, It's his EDC ever since. Just yesterday got confirmed that a Cricket is on the way from ebay.. and now desperately looking for Dodo. Later Harpy and maybe even Civilian. I have a passion for hawkbills at the moment as You can see :)
And what better company to get one (or many) from than Spyderco. I have learned to trust the quality, even if I'm quite picky about what I buy, because I can't afford any high-end no-use knives. They have to be able to stand some usage. Also the fact that company's "big chief's" are taking part in this kind of open forums, it's a big plus. Gives lot's of credit to their products. :thumbup:

Now, I have a guestion for all of You Spydie-holics.
What kind of Spyderco blade do you consider the best whittler?
I know there are other manufacturers too, but I'm quite sure that I'm sticking with Spydercos.. :)

Let me explain. I love outdoors. Where I live(Northern Europe), I've used fixed blade Puukko's ever since I was old enough to have any kind of knife handed to me. My granpa gave me my first knife, it was a Marttiini puukko. with that I learned to do chores in the woods.
I've had many folders, of course SAK's and slipjoints etc. when I was a kid, but none of them were any use when carving or handling wood.

Nowadays I use my variety of puukko's in the woods, and outside that, I carry my folders, on and off duty.

Not so long ago I started to think, what kind of folder would be a good carving/whittling knife. I've tried hollow and flat ground blades, but somehow they don't "feel right". Also the handles are often hard on your hands after a while. They get the job done, it's not that, but when you are used to sabre grind fixed blades, that basicallly have no "micro bevel", they have this certain "touch" with the wood when carving, which is not present in any folder so far I've tried.

Maybe my dream-folder for the job would be something like:handle from D'allara drop point, (maybe even with wooden scales),front bolster for looks, combined within to the bolster a solid lockup-say ball-bearing, and sabre grind blade, maybe even forged out of high carbon steel.. Wish I could draw what I mean. Imagine Folding Puukko with Spyderhole. Ugly, maybe, but in a good way.
-- smaller whittler and larger drop-point hunter... daydreams, I know..( Spyderco, if You ever make one, sign me up for one of both right away :D )

But what are your favourite grinds, and models of Spyderco (existing or wishful thinking) for whittling and wood handling ?
 
My favorite whittler is an old Imperial slippy with a 1" pen blade and a 1.5" pen blade. No idea what they were new, but thats about what they are now! Nice carbon steel takes a razor edge on holds it great, with a very controlable blade length...

That said, I've made a few fuzzy sticks with my Native and the nice thin blade works great. I just don't trust that tip for anything! ...not to mention other problems its given me...
 
My favorite Spyderco for whittling is my C39 Dyad Jr.
I much prefer flat ground to saber ground for most tasks. The distal taper and splinter picker tip, combined with the shallow belly, make a very precise blade for fine work. In fact, I don't even know where my Xacto knife is anymore.

I believe the Centofante C25 would work very well, as the blade is similar to the BM 640 Mini-Spike I used for years. I know the C50 Cento II works pretty good, but the blade is a bit long for detail work.
 
I would bet that the best whittling knife Spyderco makes is the Kiwi. I mean it would be perfect for it. I would think that the Centofante 4 would be good too even a little on the large side.
 
I like the Salt1, the H1 steel gets super sharp and cut wood really well.
It's easy to sharpen, you can even strop it on your shoe, cardboard, a piece of wood, and bring it right up sharp.
 
I would bet that the best whittling knife Spyderco makes is the Kiwi. I mean it would be perfect for it. I would think that the Centofante 4 would be good too even a little on the large side.

The Wharncliffe blade on the Kiwi is perfect for whittling and the shape of the knife with the two choils, the "bump", and the Spydie hole make handling the Kiwi very easy for whittling. The VG-10 blade takes a great edge and can be polished up to a mirror finish (perfect for pushing through wood fibers) but I'm not a fan of using hollow ground blades for whittling. Hollow ground blades tend to bite too deeply - not a problem when roughing out or making stop cuts, but it can cause you to go too deep when removing very thin shavings.
 
Hollowgrind also lacks the strength to pry a piece out when it cuts too deeply. No spydies come without a bevels (i might be wrong). So it's really down to the kind you like.
 
I used my Cent 4 to make a few walking staffs a few weeks ago when I was hiking. It worked really well but it wasn't precise work.
 
Best blades I've used from Spyderco for whittling were the leaf-shaped flat ground blades found in the Manix, Calypso, Para etc.
 
my vote is for the kiwi too. If you're doing something big like a walking stick it might not be the best, but I think that the blade shape and handle are quite comfortable and offer great control.
 
Captain is a great whittler! :thumbup:

Again jaislandboy I am in total agreement with you and I do think that the C-111 Captain model has the potential of being a great whittler.

Now to the next point of interest:>> there are 2 Small Spyderco Hawkbills that everyone is overlooking for being potential whittling tools. The Dodo and the Spyderco Karambit both are geometrically ideal for whittling. I've even been told by a woodworker that the Karambit is great for detail work. I would also have to believe that the Dodo would also be a gem for detailed woodworking or just plain whittling. With all the great Hawkbills that Spyderco has blessed us with I think we could take whittling to a whole new level if we did some more brainstorming.
 
I could see a ZDP Delica with a 30 degree inclusive flat grind by Tom Krein as a very good whittler. It would cost 100-110 total in USD.
 
JD, it depends on what kind of whittling you are doing. For debarking sticks and making points on them, the Dodo works great. But the blade is too wide and the edge is on the wrong side for most of the detail work I do. YMMV ;)
 
Back
Top