Better to Have One Premium Knife or Several Good Knives?

Joined
Sep 5, 2005
Messages
2,826
Not everyone has money to have both, and when I was a college student wanting a gun to shoot, I didn't have enough to buy anything but a lousy RG .22LR chrome-plated revolver with brown plastic grips that needed constant tightening.

Still, I was happy with it and it was better than nothing. I still have fond memories of feeling fat and happy if I had a clean gun and two boxes of cheap .22LR ammo. Finally, I sold a nice telescope I used to like to look at the mountains with, and the moon. It was a spotting scope, really, a 15-60x zoom. And though I hated to do it, I was able to use the money to buy a Ruger .22LR Standard Auto.

That was clearly a step in the right direction, but while many of us ponder our next major expense in which knife we'll buy, students are still students. But then there are holidays and birthdays, and these are times when little birdies drop a few coins into the nest for some very temporary wealth.

But what to do? With some money they can use and not feel guilty about, what would be YOUR choice? With a very limited collection, would the QUALITY or the QUANTITY be your primary concern? Or, to put it another way, is it better to have a lot of presents under the tree or just one big one?

I'm not talking about bottom of the barrel el cheapo knives. I'm talking: 1) S&W or CRKT entry level knives; 2) Cold Steel, CRKT, Kershaw, Byrd; or 3) Spyderco, Benchmade and more of your upper tier (and I realize some brands interlap greatly). Even if you're not in the predicament of being a broke student, what would you prefer? And what would you recommend to others?

The above refers to folders, but would your baseline outlook be the same for fixed-blade knives? Or do fixed blade knives have a bit more latitude in the inexpensive categories?


Knife_Collection.JPG


knives.jpg
 
I've asked myself the same question repeatedly. I've ended up going for quantity then quality and then again for quantity. A bad combination. Now I have a bunch of really high quality expensive knives. It's a sickness.
 
I don't have much experience with standard folding knives or fixed blades, but I do know the story with balisongs.

Basically, almost none of them can be considered "good" until you hit about the $70 price range or so.
 
For me it would come down to my budget and intended uses. If I had no knives and only $100 to spend, I'd probably get a $50-$70 knife and a SAK and maybe a nice user Opinel. This really comes down to one's preference.
 
many is good, better than one.
 
I value one premium over several lower end knives. Of course, it would be best to have several premium knives.:thumbup::thumbup::thumbup:
 
I prefer to keep a tight nit pool of premium users. I have four fixed blades and five folders. I'm not a collector. If I get a knife that fills a position better than another, I sell the inferior knife.
 
Would you rather have 10-20 pieces of junk, or one or two pretty decent blades?

20 Moras or one Busse Badger Attack TAC ? That's easy. (ok, buy ONE Mora to use while you save up for the Busse !)

12 Pakistani folders or one Benchmade Griptilian ? Another easy one.

Crap in quantity is STILL crap.

.
 
The focus of my colleciton has shited towards purchasing knives with a high price to performance ratio. This generally means purchasing a knife from Spyderco, Benchmade or Kershaw. While I have no intention of getting rid of my customs, I've found that quality production knives meet my needs quite well. Quality and performance are my primary concern. If a $100 produciton knife meets those needs, so be it. I think the overall cutting performance between a nice production knife and a custom knife is similiar in many cases. It really comes down to personal preference; buy whatever floats your boat. However, I think that quality need not be "expensive".

Most of the fixed blades that I buy are made from carbon steel. Many companies offer a variety of carbon steel fixed blades for almost any need at reasonable prices. In this case, inexpensive is not an indicator of quality. A $12 Mora does most everything I need a fixed blade for.
 
I've got a:

Ranger RD-4
Vic Ranger
Mora #2000
Mora 760MG
Benchmade Mini-grip

and a few others...

I don't really see how a sebenza or some other custom knife could top these when it comes to performance.
 
If I'm spending $400-$500---it won't be a knife---I'll be looking at firearms. Actually with the new digital standard coming I'm needing a new TV.

I've worked my EDC combo into a $100 Benchmade and a $20 SAK---and they work quite well.

If you have limited funds---look into the alox handled SAK's---sometimes you can find a Case on sale for not too much---if you need a lock, try a Buck 110 for $26 at Walmart.
 
Dude, I've been straddling the fence so long I been goosed!
Basically, you gotta pay to learn! no way around it. Its a journey without end.
I went from quality production knives to customs. Fewer knives, better quality.
Still, I hate "safe queens". The beauty of knives, their virility, is in their function.
If you don't carry them or use them they are fey.
Collecting, or even accumulating knives is like hunting, it is about the pursuit, and finally the score. Then its the "morning after". It is wise to score knives you can sell. Keep the nest egg, minimize learning cost, move on.
It's about suffering, excruciating, ecstatic pain.
 
12 Pakistani folders or one Benchmade Griptilian? Another easy one. Crap in quantity is STILL crap.
Technically, true, but we're not talking about the SAME 12 knives for the one great knife. After all, it's no fun to play with the same 10 or twelve knives!
 
several good knives, as in some for the kitchen, some for the pocket, some for the BOB, etc. I don't know what price ranges you are talking about, but I would take a variety of $50 - $100 knives over a single $400 knife if I didn't have any.
 
A Sebenza and a Fallkniven s1/micarta.

I'll take quality over quantity every time.

Someone in the Kershaw forum said, "There aint no education in the second kick from a mule."
A good philosophy to apply to purchases.

I'm not a collector though, I just like fine tools and lots of space.
 
Quality over quantity, of course. What' the point of having many crappy knives when I could have a couple of excellent knives that will last me longer anyway? To collect things? Why collect crap? That is the question.
 
Back
Top