Bidpay has changed quite a bit since severing ties with Western Union. The new Bidpay is for auctions only, and it has some pros and cons relative to pay pay.
The clear "pro" is that Bidpay offers better buyer and seller protection. Pay pay looks for ways to get out of their obligations wheras Bidpay has blanket coverange.
The "cons" are what prevent me from switching to Bidpay. For one, Bidpay takes a day or two before approving the payment. Buyers are used to instant payments through pay pay, and the 1-2 day delay will get complaints. Bidpay uses the 1-2 days to ensure a letimate buyer and legitimate seller are hooking up. Another "con" is that Bidpay lets the buyer choose payment amount, including shipping. I.e., Bidpay users can pay less than the full amount, and of course buyer and seller can squable at each other. There are more cons IMHO with Bidpay (vs. pay pay), like ease of use. It's enough to keep me in the pay pay fold for now.
whitie