BK&T companion.....one great tool

The Magician

Illusionist
Joined
Jan 19, 2000
Messages
1,580
The title should of read "BK&T Campanion....one great tool Sorry about the poor spelling.
I recently received one of these knives in a trade. When I first saw these knives in pictures I was not impressed. I thought that the handle looked too big and that a 4.5" blade could not chop. Well this trade popped up and I thought that if I didn't like it, I could just trade it away later. Well the campanion arrived and my first impression was that I ws very wrong. The handle fits my small/average size hands well. I am sure it will work for larger hands too.The handle is a smooth thick plastic that is held on by three allen head bolts with hex nuts. This makes the scales easy to remove if you wish. The blade is a drop point style and came very sharp. The steel is black epoxy coated high carbon. Right off you will notice the blade is very thick and has a pleasing weight. It is slightly blade heavy, but not too much. It came in a multi carry kydex sheath that was very well done for a factory sheath. The knife is locked in with a "click!" and there is also a nylon retaining strap. The strap is probably not neccessary, but it is there in case. The sheath has a wide nylon belt loop that will go on most any belt, even the GI pistol belt. There is also many holes and slots around the edges to strap sheath to LBE or pack, etc. I would have no worries carrying this knife inverted, I would however use the reatining strap and not rely on friction alone.
As I stated earlier, I was skeptical of chopping with ~5" blade. I had an old painted 2X4 laying around and decided to give it a few whacks. The knife chopped very well. I was extremely surprised and impressed. The handle was very comfortable. I was able to chop through very quickly with almost no fatigue. For comparison I got out my cold steel shovel. In my experience the campanion out chopped the shovel at least 3to1! The shovel seemed to want to just bounce off and vibrate. (yes, it was sharpened)The hooked design on the end of the handle works great to keep the campanion from flying away during heavy chopping. The shove seemed like it wanted to twist and turn.
The 2X4 that I was chopping had another short peice nailed to it using four large nails. I used the handle of the CS shovel to hammer the campanion between the boards. I then pried and twisted the blade forcing the boards apart. I also used the blade spine as a hammer to further force them apart. The campanion worked great.
I next threw the knife down in my driveway (gravel)several times. I am not sure why, this knife just begs for you to try to hurt it. ( you can't) I moved on to living wood, cherry, and it performed well. Chopped small 1/2" branches like butter. I also threw the knife at the tree a few times.
In the end the knife is still in great shape. The black coating has held up well. It has some scuffs and a little paint rubbed on it. There are smoe scratches on the spine where I hammered with it, but still looks good, just used. The edge still slices paper well. It doesn't shave, but will sort of scrape hair off. There are some small spots where the edge has impacted and rolled, but not too many. I think it will also resharpen easily. Overall I give the BK&T Campanion an 8 on the 1 to 10 scale.

[edited for poor typing and spelling]
------------------
Have you noticed that time flies like the wind, but fruit flies like bananas ?



[This message has been edited by bteel (edited 05-28-2001).]
 
I was surprised to read the poor perfomance of the shovel in your comparison testing... you may have inadvertantly used a shovel that slipped through with out getting a proper heat treat.
 
Without a doubt, one of my favorites. This is a BIG knife in a small package. Great steel, great price. Camillus continues to amaze me. I now have four of the Becker's and never cease to be amazed how they can pack so much knife into such an affordable price.

------------------
Hoodoo

I get some pleasure from finding a relentlessly peaceful use for a combative looking knife.
JKM
 
Nice review! I've only held one briefly. I thought it felt too heavy for it's length.

I hope this doesn't sound too picky -- I've never before said a word about spelling or grammar. But, I do think names are more important in that area.

The name of the knife is Campanion.

------------------
Asi es la vida

Bugs
 
<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by Bugs3x:

The name of the knife is Campanion.

</font>


Thanks Bugs! That was not really a spelling error, per se. I have actually been reading the name wrong this whole time! I never even noticed the "a". I just saw the word and filled in the "o" automatically. I can't edit the title of this thread, but I do apologize for my error.


------------------
Have you noticed that time flies like the wind, but fruit flies like bananas ?
 
Same for me! I always thought it was the Companion. I wouldn't feel too bad though. I noticed A.G. Russell has it wrong on his website too. I wonder how many others? Anywho, any way you spell it, it's a heck of a knife for the money. BTW, when I first held mine, I felt the same way as Bugs3x. But it sure turned into a user for me. The Campanion has turned into a wonderful hunting companion for me. I've said this before but what the heck. I use this knife while hunting birds and rabbits. It's perfect for chopping away the annoying twig that will poke your eye out when your chasing grouse into the thick timber and it will take care of those pesky brambles that want to cling to your coat or pants when you follow those bunnies into a tangled thicket. And it will do it without banging against your knee. Big knives are great but carrying a long, heavy blade all day, along with my shotgun, shells, lunch, etc., is not my idea of a picnic. The Campanion is a great compromise and will do the job at hand. And if you get lost and have to spend the night in the field, the Campanion will build your shelter for you and make short work of small saplings. Sure, bigger knives will do it better but the Campanion will do it and do a fare job of it and carry a little easier. BTW, you can increase the leaverage for chopping by putting a sturdy loop through the lanyard hole, and wrapping it around your wrist. By holding the knife pommel with two fingers circling the end of the pommel, you can now swing the blade with a lot more leverage. But you have to be a more careful because you lose some control as well.


------------------
Hoodoo

I get some pleasure from finding a relentlessly peaceful use for a combative looking knife.
JKM
 
ardfy:

<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">I was surprised to read the poor perfomance of the shovel in your comparison testing</font>

I have a CS shovel and after sharpening the bevel it would still chop very poorly. Its performance was low because of the geometry, regardless of the heat treat or even steel used, that is simply not going to chop well.

In regard to the 3:1 ratio, I have not used a Companion, but based on what I have seen of the shovel that doesn't seem unlikely. The shovel would be outperformed at a much higher level by a decent chopping blade like the PAB from Strider.

-Cliff
 
---------------------
Cliff
I have a CS shovel and after sharpening the bevel it would still chop very poorly. Its performance was low because of the geometry, regardless of the heat treat or even steel used, that is simply not going to chop well.
---------------------------


I thought the comparison with a shovel was obviously tongue in cheek.... and attempted to respond in kind. I guess I should have put in one of those smiley face icons to make it clear I was joking. Sorry...

By the way Cliff, I ran across a fascinating old thread discussing the relative merits of production vs. custom knifes. Near the end of the thread, it seemed Mat Lamey was going to send you
a semi finished custom knife for review purposes.... Did that ever happen?


 
Sorry to be so slow getting back to this thread. Am glad no offense taken by my "correction."

Just yesterday, was over at Muzzleup's, looking at his knives again. (I'm sure I leave there green -- with envy.) Anyhow, once again, he handed me his Campanion, and made a comment about my post in this thread. It felt completely different to me this time. Yes, it is a solid knife, but I had no sense of the unrealistic heaviness I recall from my first inspection.

Am thinking it might be sequence or something of the sort. I do remember being greatly impressed on the first visit with the Becker Magnum Camp. I really like that knife! I think maybe Ron handed me the Campanion right after I put down the Magnum Camp. It has a substantially longer, but thinner stock blade than the Campanion, and is extremely well balanced. Yesterday, I didn't touch the Magnum, and the Campanion felt just fine. I could feel that the balance was there for decent chopping, despite the short blade.

Soooo, guess I need to somehow retract what I said in my first post. I'm thinking now that the Campanion is a far more versatile, worthwhile knife than I did at first glance.
redface.gif


------------------
Asi es la vida

Bugs
 
Just got a Magnum Camp in the mail (Thanks, Thomas). I'm very impressed. It's not shaving sharp, but it's not that kind of knife. The balance is excellent, and I really like what they've done with the handle.
 
Back
Top