BM940 or Endura??

Mistake made. Reopened though. :) Sorry about that. Learn new stuff everday here.
 
Last edited:
Having had both I would try out a flipper like a zt 566, boker kwaiken... Are you a big guy. The endura is a lovely knife but a bit too big for my 5'9 self to edc. Nothing bad about the 940. It was a must have knife for me and good to experience an axis lock first hand. That said I'd also suggest a Domino.
 
Also take a look at the spyderco manix 2. S30v, g10 scales with steel liners, a bit smaller than the endura, ball bearing lock that is comparable (but not as smooth imho) to the axis, and you can find them used for under $100 lnib if you scour the exchange.
 
Last edited:
The entire purpose of the Exchange is to buy and sell knives. General Knife Discussion is for discussion of knives themselves.
 
Have both (several of both), like both. Both are great knives...but I'm not sure I've ever been (in your words) proud of an Endura. The regular 940 comes pretty close, though, and if you can splurge a little more, the 940-1 definitely qualifies.
 
Wow! Thanks to everyone who commented. Lots of great information. Perhaps I should have mentioned what I intended on using it for. It would be with me 95% of the time, and most of its use would be at work. I work in underground utilities/civil construction. So it would see a fair amount of use. Not looking to beat on it or use it as a pry bar, but many items cut would be dirty, muddy, gritty, greasy, or oily. After reading many of your responses, seems as thought the 940 would live longer. Having said that, if something happened to either knife at work I would be less upset if it was the Spyderco that bit the bullet. Turns out I live 20 minutes from warriors and wonders.com in Vancouver so I am going to have a better look at each tomorrow. Thanks again to everyone that chimed in. I will return tomorrow with the results of my purchase!
 
Both are great. I've owned both and while I'm a Spyderco guy, the BM 940 feels better and looks better than the Endura in my opinion.

The VG-10 is a great steel, easy to sharpen. S30V is also great, holds the edge longer but can be a little harder to sharpen. You win either way really.

Pick the one you like the most. The 940 feels like a $200 knife. The Endura feels like a $100 knife. In this case, you do get what you pay for but can't go wrong with either.
 
onojoe said:
Or.... compare the 940 to a Spyderco PM2, now that is a hard choice.
Click to expand...

Except that the PM2 is a better slicer, has better handle material with G10, has a lock that is just as strong, has the same very good blade steel , seems a bit stronger overall and costs 90 dollars less. It s too bad you can t hold these knives.
 
Not sure if it has been mentioned, but the 940 is just FUN to play with. It flys out of the handle, like it doesn't want to be closed. The Endura, for me, took some break in. It was VERY gritty and tight upon first use. After about 2-3 days of constantly opening and closing, it broke in. It does flip out, but I have heard it is bad for the lock. The lock back nature, having the tang slam into it, can cause damage.

So for me, I got both. =)

I think for myself, they are both wonderful knives. I use and carry them, often, together. It just boils down to the little things, though. For me, the ease of opening the 940, would get my vote.
 
I may be biased since I love my 940-1, but...

If you buy the 940 and don't love it, you can easily trade for an endura.
If you buy the endura, you will have a hard time trading up for the 940 even if you add some money.

Both are worth a try (I'm a delica kinda guy), but it sounds like it will be harder to try the 940 later.
 
The lock on the 940 will be more secure while in dirty/gritty conditions and easier to clean out while in use, the lock back on the endura will be more likely to jam and slip or not engage at all.
 
Here's a 940 next to an Endura for comparison...

940_Endura_open_800x423.jpg


940_Endura_closed_800x399.jpg


940_Endura_length_800x518.jpg
 
Mat-A said:
I work in underground utilities/civil construction. So it would see a fair amount of use. Not looking to beat on it or use it as a pry bar, but many items cut would be dirty, muddy, gritty, greasy, or oily.
Click to expand...

Sounds like the Para 2 would be much more suited towards your needs. I love my 940, and the blade is very robust. However, for harder, daily use, the Para 2 has better ergonomics. The blade is very robust and a better slicer than the 940. The G10 is grippier. The gimping is perfect. And, it's still easy to close one handed. It's pillar construction means no backspacer to trap dirt and muck.

It's easily much more in the same league fit and finish wise as the 940. Comparing the 940 and Endura is really more apples and oranges. The 940 is a better "fondling blade" (it's just perfectly balanced for the Axis lock). As a heavier duty work knife, Para 2 is more appropriate. For about $125, it's an outstanding deal. There's a reason they're so hard to find (at least new from a dealer).
 
If you like to take your knife apart and clean/lube it, then get the Endura (easy peasy on the reassembly).
If you don't care about disassembly/reassembly, then get the 940 (PITA to put back together!).
 
I got soaked in the rain last Friday at work and my 940, just in pocket for the work day, started rusting pretty bad. Came home and took it apart to remove the rust and ... now I can't get it back together! Great knife though. If you're looking for something to use hard then get the 940. If just for opening boxes and the like, get the endura. I personally don't think the 940 is a very good slicer.
 
Well guys, went down to the shop today. Handled each knife for close to 20 minutes, think the sales guy was getting annoyed haha! Now only time will tell how much I love the knife I settled on. It fits my hand quite nicely! Razor sharp right out of the box, easily shaved the hair on my arm. Lock up is great, fit and finish is beautiful. The Endura sure is a great knife, and I like it quite a bit. I can tell it will be a great tool to have on ones belt for any cutting need.......But that isn't the knife I bought! I couldn't put the damn 940 down. I loved it right away, so it came home with me! I am pretty excited about this knife, I have already been cutting things around the house. Wife wasn't as impressed with the shredded bottom of the calender on the fridge like I was. Excuse the lighting in the photo, it was taken on the kitchen table with an Iphone. 940 pictured with my surge, these will be with me every where I go. Thanks again to all who offered suggestions and experiences.
IMG_1607_zps8fed1016.jpg
[/URL][/IMG]
IMG_1601_zps76ec0783.jpg
[/URL][/IMG]




hope the photo worked!
 
Excellent - you'll love it, for sure! Just remember, if you ever want to disassemble it, you will need three hands to get it back together!!! Blow it out with compressed air on a regular basis and you may not have to take it apart for cleaning.
 
Congratulations on your sweet new blade :thumbup: My 940 has been a maintenance-free pleasure for 3 years; actually just picked up a second one with a different blade configuration last month. Very useful pocket companion. Enjoy.
 
Great choice, you will love it and it should serve you well for quite some time.
 
Agree with these guys... :thumbup:

link2derek said:
Excellent - you'll love it, for sure! Just remember, if you ever want to disassemble it, you will need three hands to get it back together!!! Blow it out with compressed air on a regular basis and you may not have to take it apart for cleaning.
Click to expand...

NJBillK said:
Great choice, you will love it and it should serve you well for quite some time.
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top