They both have their place and for most squirrel hunting situations, the difference is negligible as you have to be patient for the headshot anyway. I always end up going back to my Marlin 60 though. It's nice having those 15rd's in the tube and not having to reload throughout the hunt. Every now and then you get a tree with multiple squirrels and after the first shot, not having to move lets the others settle back down and gives time for the follow up shots.