Wow, great timing!

I just finished
Dies the Fire last night myself. Picked it up at the local library, after seeing it recommended on here so much. The recomendations were spot on, the story is excellent.
Spoilers below, if you haven't read the story.
I did have some critiques of the story and of the ideas presented. First, in the beginning, the story is too explanitary (is that a word?) in that, the author has to give a detailed description of the tools/knives/items for, the sheeple who've pick up the book. A sentence would have been fine, but these were a full paragraph each.
Second, everyone they encounter that's good/neutral has a skill they can utilize (horse wrangler, blacksmith, fencing teacher...)
Third, I can see electricity going out (worldwide is a stretch, but I can buy into it...) I was wondering about buried/protected electrical devices. I can also buy into gunpower not working. This was MUCH harder to do, but for the sake of the story, it was okay. (I was curious why no one in the story tried to make new or different power or tried to make some from scratch.) But the thing I couldn't get was, that steam power didn't work. As soon as I saw the word 'railroad', I thought of steam power. It was just too much of a stretch that water pressure/heated water didn't work.
Those quibbles aside, I loved the story. I've hung around with some pagens, so that aspect was okay. I've made some chainmail, shot some archery and tried my hand at blacksmithing (only twice, so I'm still figuring out which end of the hammer to use!) so I loved to see how they did those in the story.
I saw on here from other threads, and on Amazon, that the second isn't as good (too wordy) but I'm planning picking that up as well. (The third is supposed to be great again). Also, he has another trilogy set in New England along the same lines that I'll try to get as well.
I also started and finished the first book in the
Harry Potter (
Sorcerer's/Philiosopher's Stone) series yesterday too!

The first chapter is downright horrible, but it gets better after that and turns into a nice read by the end.