If you are working in a correctly tuned propane forge, it is not needed as a flux. If all the parts of the billet are ground clean and maintain full contact in the initial stack up and you do everything right setting the initial weld, borax is not necessary for the weld to take. Having done several billets without it, just to see if it was possible, I still use it as insurance. If the steel is not in complete contact or things get wonky when setting the weld, without borax, you often ruin the billet or large parts of it. If you are just starting out I would highly reccomend some kind of flux that you can get your hands on. I have not tried it with coke, coal or charcoal and don't plan to because I rarely use those fuels.