Breeden Peacemaker Mini-Review

Joined
Feb 14, 2008
Messages
1,093
Well, "review" might be a little bit of a stretch - more like a little gloating that I got to handle this one. I did play with it though, as Bryan twisted my arm pretty hard to get me to try it out.;) Check out the Peacemaker. This is a knife very much at home outdoors.

I didn't get to keep this one but I will be getting one that I can keep - my own. I am not a big fan of knives much over 4" and use knives less than 4" more than anything. When I saw the Peacemaker, I got a bit excited. When I got it in my hands, it was not really excitement I felt so much as just a sense of comfortable familiarity. The handle, in all its plain shape, the weight, balance and dimensions all just sort of "fit." It is an easy knife to pick up and use. It's sort of a "plain Jane" and has a simple, natural beauty in its defining of a purposeful and useful tool. Ah, the aesthetic creeps in every time. The "look" fits in well with the "feel." As I had stated in another post, one could envision this one tucked into a long-hunter's sash for a game-gathering foray in the early virgin forests of the Eastern Woodlands or in a Trapper's belt headed for the Rockies,... or hanging off the strap of my Timbuk2 Messenger Bag.

Yeah, that's Cherry again and I did do the obligatory batoning of a dead "stick" (not a four-inch saw-cut log) that I wrenched out of the ground.
PM10.jpg


Workmanship complements the material - Osage Orange and nice, even and consistent shaping and "finishing." The metal work exhibits the same mildly rustic look with the same consistency and evenness.
PM03.jpg


Quarter-sawn grain is more stable (grows and shrinks at a lower rate) than flat-sawn and is desirable in the absence of synthetics and stabilizers. It also looks better.
PM05.jpg


While it is a sizeable knife, it is not unwieldy. It is not overly large and balances well enough that it feels light a lighter, smller knife.
PM06.jpg


Plenty of handle but not excessively large that it poses any portability issues.
PM07.jpg


Comparison shot with it's "cousin." This Pathfinder is one of two "first knives" built by Bryan's nephew under Bryan's supervision. I am particularly impressed with the high convex edge, which, when stropped lightly was SHARP. Bryan seems to be a pretty good teacher among other things.
PM08.jpg


Comparison shot with another familiar face.
PM09.jpg


In use, it handles about anything you would expect with its 6" x 1 1/8" x 1/8" blade. I remember that but can't remember the actual length of the handle but it seemed to be about 4 1/4" to 4 1/2". It handled the rougher chores of harvesting 1 1/2" to 1" saplings, batoning deadwood and the more intricate tasks such as food prep, fuzz sticks and general cutting chores easily. The flat-grind is complemented by a secondary convex edge, which was sharp and stayed that way. What is most notable is that it never felt like a "big" knife - a six-inch knife is a BIG knife to me. The edge is ground almost to the handle, which makes a lot of finer work more controllable - there is effectively no ricasso. As a natural all-'rounder, the Peacemaker would get my vote and I plan on having one of these around. I am also more of a spearpoint fan, at least a drop-point, but this didn't seem to be the place for that - not having a clip was good enough. Had there been a swedge or a clipped point, I don't think I would have been drawn to it like I was - which is what led me to want to get my hands on it.

Thanks for watching.
 
Last edited:
Yet another nice design from Bryan. Caught a glimpse of this model in another thread, knew it was only a matter of a week or two ( ;) ) before more pictures showed up. This one looks very nice, although I do think it's a bit long for my taste. Really want to try out one of Bryan's knives with a convex edge, though, they look very good.
 
Jeff has all the fun! Excellent knife Brian and great write up Jeff!
 
Awesome. I like the osage on that one. Looks like a very simple, practical design:thumbup:

Nice review Jeff!
 
Nice work Jeff and Bryan sure knows how to put a convex on a blade. Quarter sawn Osage is the way to go!

-RB
 
great knife! i like the look of brians orange handles for utilitarian reasons, but those osage scales are really nice looking.
 
Nice review and excellent photos. Those trademark white liners look great with the Osage.

Jeff
 
Excellent review! I was particularly interested in learning about how this knife feels in action and its balance. Jeff, I already ordered mine and Bryan just finished it and is shipping it out. I fell in love with its, as you say, simple and timeless design the first time I saw it with Bryan's post.

I also had him make me another kat knife in which he married the PSKK handle. Here is his pic. I already posted this pic this morning - so I apologies to the folks who saw this one already. But given Jeff's excellent review, I think this pic belongs in this thread.

101_0813.jpg
 
Aw, there ya go, now! KGD, I was doing just fine and you go and post that pair! Now I want BOTH! Glad you reminded me because I forgot to ask for a Kat knife and now I can have it done with the same handle shape. That's a great pair for the woods! Thanks for sharing.:thumbup::thumbup:

Must keep moving - appreciate the comments greatly. Ask anything I may have forgotten to cover, I can probably answer it.

Thanks:thumbup::thumbup:
 
Hi all, Wow thanks for the review and glad you like the osage handled Peace maker, Jeff. You mentioned a spear point ? I started this one last week it is pic of it in the early early stages of becoming a knife.

101_0826.jpg

Yea my Nephew spends time with me in the shop when his chores are done and has made up a couple of knives for his survival kits that he has. That is his pathfinder in the pic, he did I bet 90% of the knife making of that one, he also wanted a a blackened blade and black liners on his.

This is is getting a 5" blade length though not the 6" like the one you handled and reviewed. and it has a bit more of a internal steel guard.

Thanks for all the kinds comments on Jeffs review of the peace maker
that Jeff wrote and about the knife I made.

Kgd your knives are on ther way to you I can hardly wait to hear what you thoughts are.

Rocketbomb Since you are only a hour away or so, come on down to the shop and see what goes on here and help make your perfect knife.:D And for anyone else who is in the area stop in and say Hi. LOL

Thanks again all for the kind comments on Jeffs review and have a great week end I would love to stay and chat some more but I got fence to check on ( do not need any cattle out LOL )

Bryan
 
Some nice photos and information, Jeff. :thumbup: Yep, as a reenactor and cowboy action shooter, I can easily see the Peacemaker in my kit. Very attractive knife.

The more I see of Bryan's knives (and use my own), the more I want to try some of his others, too.
 
...Rocketbomb Since you are only a hour away or so, come on down to the shop and see what goes on here and help make your perfect knife.:D And for anyone else who is in the area stop in and say Hi. LOL

Hey Bryan, I'll definitely be making my way down there sometime soon. Am going to try to do it before the university gets their yoke of slavery completely attached to me for the semester. I'll give you a call sometime. Thanks again for the offer.
 
Danny that sounds good and again Glad you like your knife.

Rocketbomb Great look forward to that time and you are very welcome.

Bryan
 
Thanks, ALL, for the comments.:thumbup:

I have been a bit remiss in keeping up here and apologize for the lack of repsonsiveness. A LOT going on in the family right now and I have been running around a lot. None of it "fun" stuff, unfortunately.

Bryan,
That is one sweet-looking blank there! For me, I would omit the guard since the handle forms an "effective" guard but, some guys like that extra peace of mind. I applaud you for your ability to materialize a fella's ideas while offering your own experience and good sense without forcing your ideas on someone. As I said earlier today, that is bordering on "Kephart" and that is a pattern which, for good reason, is very popular.

This is an important point for anyone talking to Bryan about a knife - he will offer insight and ideas but will not force you into something because he thinks it's "better." Listen to Bryan and mae your decisions considering his insight with your desires and you will get a knife you want.
 
Back
Top