Review Brother 1510

JTB_5

Gold Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2017
Messages
7,828
This is a brief review of the Brother 1510.
881B346D-CB28-495E-9B15-95B5A230B04B_1_105_c.jpeg
As you can see it is a zulu spear blade, VG10 steel, with green micarta (a little brighter than Olive Drab, but pretty close) handles and satin finish on the blade, bolsters, and bar shield. There is a lanyard hole on this one as well.
In this video (pardon the sound, I was roasting coffee at the time) the walk and talk is very good on this knife. It has that nice "bounce" at the half-stop when closing, and everything in the action is very crisp. The fit and finish is impressive for this price range. There is a small gap between the bolster and cover on the show side, and the secondary grind is just slightly uneven on the pile side. Otherwise the transitions are very smooth, the pins are flush, and there are no burrs on the lanyard hole or liners to snag the fingers. The knife was hair shaving sharp when I received it. Initially I saw some small gaps inbetween the the liners and the backspring, but upon further inspection I believe these gaps are due to the washers that the blade is riding on. It is hard to see, but they look to be phosphor bronze rather than ceramic. There is also a stop pin in the blade well. The pull is a solid 5 to half stop and then about a 6 from half stop to opening. The half stop is a little bit lower than I've seen on most traditional knives, meaning that the blade hangs below perpendicular at the stop. You could cut your finger if you had it up too close to the pivot and closed the knife to half stop.

Unfortunately, I couldn't find anything about the company, which seems to go by the full name of "Watchman Brother," which sounds really weird and kind of creepy if you think about it too much. It is manufactured in China and with the precision it makes me think they have CNC machines or some other equivalent automated system. I hate to say it, but having just bought a recent Case knife released this year (Copperhead), I'm more impressed with the quality of this Brother 1510.

I hope you folks enjoyed the review!

Edit: I was able to find some information about Brother and this knife in particular. Apparently the washers are copper, and the bolsters, spring, and pins are "steel." They do use CNC machines for some of the manufacturing and the two owners have been making knives since 2008 (the company came into its own in 2013). Here's a blurb they have about themselves:

"The brand BROTHER was named by our two founders, they are classmates, mechanical design and manufacturing major, friends, brothers, have the same passion on knives, the same dream to do create good things with spirit of craftsman. They start to design and make knives since 2008, over 10years experience, they had good sense of knives and now we have a professional design team and our own factory. We are committed to combining the traditional craft and modern technology to make better knife."
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the detailed review. I noticed the stop pin in some of the videos I watched but your review is the first time I've seen or heard it mentioned. I've been looking at the brand too and I currently have their 1503 in transit. Looking forward to checking it out.

I'm very curious about what appears to be a pin going through the shield. You can just barely see it in this picture and I've seen it in other pictures as well. My curiosity stems from the fact that I asked an owner of a similar Brother knife about it. He told me that he can see the pin on the outside of his knife too but it doesn't go all the way through to the liner. He can't see any evidence of a pin on the backside of the liner.

I'm not sure what to think about that and I'm anxious to inspect mine when it arrives.

Brother 1503.jpg
 
Thanks for the detailed review. I noticed the stop pin in some of the videos I watched but your review is the first time I've seen or heard it mentioned. I've been looking at the brand too and I currently have their 1503 in transit. Looking forward to checking it out.

I'm very curious about what appears to be a pin going through the shield. You can just barely see it in this picture and I've seen it in other pictures as well. My curiosity stems from the fact that I asked an owner of a similar Brother knife about it. He told me that he can see the pin on the outside of his knife too but it doesn't go all the way through to the liner. He can't see any evidence of a pin on the backside of the liner.

I'm not sure what to think about that and I'm anxious to inspect mine when it arrives.

View attachment 1508017

Nice! Let us know what you think when it arrives. I don't think the knife I have has a pinned shield. I cannot see it on the shield and there is no evidence of a hole in the liner when I look in the blade well either.

I was sure this was going to be a printer review that somehow got lost. :) They seem to make some nice stuff.

Every time I did a search to find out more about the knife, Brother printers came up.
 
881b346d-cb28-495e-9b15-95b5a230b04b_1_105_c-jpeg.1507872
I've seen some of their other knives and nothing really spoke to me. But that one has nice lines and a good blade shape. Still not sure I'd buy one, but it is attractive. Glad it has good quality for you too.
 
Thanks for the review, Joshua! :thumbsup::thumbsup::cool:
I've run across this brand somewhere and it aroused some mild interest on my part, but I haven't done any serious research yet. I don't recall seeing any multiblade knives from Brother; have you noticed any?

- GT
 
I've seen some of their other knives and nothing really spoke to me. But that one has nice lines and a good blade shape. Still not sure I'd buy one, but it is attractive. Glad it has good quality for you too.
Thanks, John!
Thanks for the review, Joshua! :thumbsup::thumbsup::cool:
I've run across this brand somewhere and it aroused some mild interest on my part, but I haven't done any serious research yet. I don't recall seeing any multiblade knives from Brother; have you noticed any?

- GT

I haven't seen any either, GT.
 
This interested me, I'd like a large single blade Spear in stainless, Barehead is a plus. looked at a few of their other offerings, a White Bone Wharncliffe looked pretty reasonable but feel I have enough of those already. Also a Rope knife with anchor shield seemed promising. I'm put off by delivery time, the Post Office here just leaves stuff unsorted for weeks in Hki with covid excuses when it's because they're besotted with digitalisation and chucking out all the workforce, meaning chronic undermanning. An 'express' parcel that cost me 40€ for 2 GECs on their way to Britain took nearly 4 weeks before it even left here! Another packet from US sent over 3 weeks ago no sign and one from France 16 days ago still not here..:poop:

This brand could have potential if it gets the aesthetics & quality right.:thumbsup:
 
Nice! Let us know what you think when it arrives.

My 1503 arrived about 2 hours ago. My initial impressions are that I’m pleased with the knife and the price I paid.

The 1503 is a lock back and naturally, the action is very smooth and the blade is easy to pinch open. Lock up is rock solid. No play in any direction. Lock release is just a tad bit sticky but not difficult to disengage.
IMG_5797.JPG
IMG_5798.JPG
IMG_5799.JPG
IMG_5801.JPG

Backspring area has a few minor gaps but I’m fine with that on a $40 knife. Aside from that, the construction is very good to excellent. Smooth transitions all around and the pins are flush even when running my fingers across them.
IMG_5803.JPG

Overall construction and materials closely resemble that of my A.G. Russell Vest Pocket Semi-Skinner which is a fantastic knife.
IMG_5796.JPG
About the pin on the shield. If you look very closely at my pictures above you can see a ghost of a pin at the cross section of the shield. I see the very same thing on the liner inside the blade well opposite the shield. It doesn’t look like a hole with a pin pressed into it. It looks just like what I’m seeing on the shield on the outside of the knife.

So unfortunately, I’m still not 100% certain that the shield is pinned but I’m going to assume that it is.

One of my major pet peeves is when I buy a brand new knife and the tip when closed sits so high in the blade well that I can catch my finger on it. Ain’t gonna happen with this knife.
IMG_5804.JPG
I’m pleased with my purchase.
 
My 1503 arrived about 2 hours ago. My initial impressions are that I’m pleased with the knife and the price I paid.

The 1503 is a lock back and naturally, the action is very smooth and the blade is easy to pinch open. Lock up is rock solid. No play in any direction. Lock release is just a tad bit sticky but not difficult to disengage.
View attachment 1510100
View attachment 1510101
View attachment 1510102
View attachment 1510106

Backspring area has a few minor gaps but I’m fine with that on a $40 knife. Aside from that, the construction is very good to excellent. Smooth transitions all around and the pins are flush even when running my fingers across them.
View attachment 1510103

Overall construction and materials closely resemble that of my A.G. Russell Vest Pocket Semi-Skinner which is a fantastic knife.
View attachment 1510104
About the pin on the shield. If you look very closely at my pictures above you can see a ghost of a pin at the cross section of the shield. I see the very same thing on the liner inside the blade well opposite the shield. It doesn’t look like a hole with a pin pressed into it. It looks just like what I’m seeing on the shield on the outside of the knife.

So unfortunately, I’m still not 100% certain that the shield is pinned but I’m going to assume that it is.

One of my major pet peeves is when I buy a brand new knife and the tip when closed sits so high in the blade well that I can catch my finger on it. Ain’t gonna happen with this knife.
View attachment 1510105
I’m pleased with my purchase.
Thanks for this. I've looked at this knife several times. How thick is the grind on it?
 
How well do they cut (and what did you cut with them)? How do they feel in hand while cutting?

Thanks,

-Tyson
 
I've been eyeballing a couple of these. Thanks for the reviews/impressions.
 
It's hard to tell in the pic but is the 1510 thick or thin behind the edge?

Good question! I haven’t measured it but it is a bit thicker than a typical GEC if my eye is any good, but it didn’t have any problem slicing through cardboard when I cut up a box yesterday. It certainly isn’t as chunky as a modern folder typically is.
 
How well do they cut (and what did you cut with them)? How do they feel in hand while cutting?

Thanks,

-Tyson
I've used the 1503 enough this morning that I feel I can give an honest and accurate opinion.

Things I've cut:
About 3 feet of cardboard. The factory edge didn't seem all that sharp to the touch but it zipped right through the cardboard effortlessly. No problems with the wide grind getting hung up or wedged.

Packing tape to open 4 boxes. If I had any issues at all, this would be the one. While cutting the top of the boxes where the two pieces of cardboard meet and are sealed with packing tape the blade did get wedged a little bit. It didn't cause me to stop the cutting motion but it would have went smoother with a thinner grind. I was using only the front 1/2 inch or so of the blade near the tip for this task.

Cut the shrink wrap off of 1 pallet of product. No issues.

Cut about a 10 inch length of bubble wrap while it was laying flat on a wooden tabletop.
Again, no issues. The factory edge zipped right through the bubble wrap.

The above are good examples of the kind of tasks that I generally use my pocket knives for. Maybe an occasional zip tie or nylon band but I haven't had to do that today.

The knife felt fine in my hand during all of those tasks. No complaints there. I can get a full four finger grip on the handle.

For those of you who might have concerns about the blade grind on the 1503, all I can say is that it looks pretty wide but so far I don't see having any major issues with it. If I use the knife long enough to sharpen it several times it will obviously get thicker behind the edge. I may have issues then but right now I have no complaints.

I tried to get an edge on pic so you folks can have a look at the taper of the grind.

Brother 1503 Blade Grind.jpg
 
Back
Top