Buck 112 Auto and Auto Elite - Thoughts?

Buck knives have been around for 100+ years and have earned a reputation of being honest and trustworthy.

I think I’ll go by Bucks recommendation rather than someone I don’t know from Adam. I’d rather be safe than sorry and I wouldn’t want to have some poorly given advice that causes someone to get injured on my conscience. I don’t care how many times you’ve tried it and got away with it !
 
Hmmmm...^^^ reminds me of someone that has been on this forum several times in the past under different names.

I was thinking the same thing.
Opinion substituted for fact.
Yep, that's him.


Go ahead, carry the knife in your pocket.
Just don't tell people it's safe to do so.
 
Last edited:
Well, I've never been on this forum before. Maybe you could just learn something from others. It isn't necessary to learn 'everything' from experience! And, I guess if you had anything to say, you would have addressed the content of my post, and not me as a person.

The truth is free to all. Like gold, truth is where you find it. Truth will set you free! And, I would add, in general, it's a good idea to follow manufacturer's recommendations.
 
Then we should all do that. Did you know all battery manufacturers recommend storing batteries at room temperature? What does that have to do with anything?

Manufacturers make recommendations based on their own best interests. If you try to pin them down, they will always recommend what's best for themselves, without regard to their clientelle.

Batteries last almost interminably in a freezer, and go bad soonest the warmer the environment! But they must know what's best for everyone! And companies are nice? They don't want to trick people into believing one thing and not the other.


Granted, there's a lot more at stake with an auto in a front pocket! But the whole idea of proving a point, because 'it's what the manufacturer says', is flawed!

Is it really the 'best' way to change a faucet washer to put on work gloves, eye protection, steel-toe boots, an acid-gas filtering respirator, and even after all that, to 'use extra caution to avoid personal injury and/or death?'

No, it's not! Then why does the manufacturer recommend it? Because one time a guy left the water on and disassembled a faucet valve! But the drain was also plugged up, so there was sitting water on the basin. When the faucet valve was taken apart to replace the washer, the water pressure caused it to burst open, which caused the sitting water full of acidic drain cleaner to go in the guy's eyes, and in his mouth, so he breathed it in, and went blind and got permanenly lung damage from it!

So, the faucet-washer company said, "We better warn everyone, so this doesn't happen again!" Plus, the guy was awarded 160 million dollars in a lawsuit. So, they put their heads together and came up with a list of precautions suitable to the task.

So, saying 'the manufacturer says so' is not evidence by itself that it is reasonable or correct. But I do happen to agree with you, anyway. I don't carry autos inside my pocket!
If Buck says it can open in your pocket, so use the sheath they send with it, I'll believe them.

I only buy side opener autos with locks because w/o a lock they can and do open unintentionally. I even read about it in the paper happening to young man fleeing the police. Just missed the femoral artery.
 
Hmmmm...^^^ reminds me of someone that has been on this forum several times in the past under different names.
I could swear I replied to this. But I have not been on this forum i n the past. I just joined recently. Don't worry, I'm basically rational. I just need better reasons to do certain things than that the 'manufacturer says so.' That's why I keep batteries in the freezer, even though the manufacturer says not to.
 
Back
Top