• Preorders are LIVE for the 2024 BladeForums Traditional Knife

    Traditional Knife Information Thread - make sure you go in there and read up.

    Requirements: Be a Gold or higher member or have been a member of the forums since 6/2023 with at least 100 posts in the Traditional Forum. Preorder is for people who live in the continental US only, international orders will be separate.

    Delivery expected in Q4 2024, hopefully before the holidays.

    User Name
    Serial number request

Buck or Case Fixed Blades....Who Has the Best Steel??

N

Nalapombu

Joined
Oct 26, 2001
Messages
300
I have been checking out both the Buck and Case fixed blade for hunting. In the Buck line I like the Pathfinder and the shorter one. The 119 is a nice knife but I think it may be a bit too big for hog and deer field dressing.
In the Case line I have been looking at the stacked leather handled fixed blades particularly the 3 inch version and 5 inch blade with the thin blade. Basically the same knives as the Buck, or very close anyway.

What I would like to know is which one is currently making the better knife, Case or Buck? Does one hold and edge better than the other? Are they both made in the USA out of quality steel? Which brand would you pick if given the choice?

Lastly, I also believe that KaBar makes models that are also very close to those I mentioned by Buck and Case. Do you think the Kabar is a better choice than either the Buck or Case?

Thanks for your time.

Nalajr
 
Depends on the model and the alloy.

Buck 420HC holds an edge significantly better than Case Tru-Sharp.
Buck also does an excellent job with the other alloys it uses, S30V and ATS-34/154CM.

If you were comparing Case ATS-34 to Buck ATS-34, I do not think you'd notice a difference.
 
Buck 102, 105, Gen 5, or Vanguard would all be an excellent choise and Buck has a superior warrenty comparred to any other US maker. Case is over priced and caters more to the collector market. Kabar really does'nt have much in their hunting line thats not made overseas.
 
Oh. forgot about the KaBar. kaBar 1095 Cro Van will hold an edge better than Buck 420HC.

But the KaBar models that look similar to Bucks are much softer steel, DIN 1.4116. The Buck will outperform them.
 
Kabar's 4116 is of quality though-it's a sturdy steel that takes a razor edge with minimal work. I find it superbly effective. I've heard awesome stuff about Case's CV steel, have a yellow delrin Sod Jr on the way from them and I'm pretty stoked to test it out.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top