But a folding knife won't work for that...

Status
Not open for further replies.

stabman

Gold Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2007
Messages
21,327
Oh yeah?



Man stabs woman's pit bull to death after it attacks his smaller dog

By Matthew Robinson, Vancouver Sun November 21, 2013



An aggressive pit bull was stabbed to death near Kitsilano Beach Park on Wednesday afternoon by another dog owner, police say.

A 72-year-old man had been out walking with his pug when he encountered a woman with her pit bull, Vancouver police spokesman Sgt. Randy Fincham said in a news release. The dogs went up to each other for an introduction when the pit bull suddenly chomped down on the smaller dog's neck.

When the two owners were unable to pull the pit bull off the pug, the man pulled out a folding knife and killed the attacking dog, Fincham said.

The injured pug was taken to a nearby veterinary hospital where it received stitches for wounds on its neck. The dead pit bull was picked up by animal control and delivered to the BC SPCA.

Lorie Chortyk, general manager of community relations at BC SPCA, said it was the first incident of its kind she could recall. Chortyk said an initial SPCA investigation suggested the pit bull had likely got away from its owner before the attack. The society now expects to perform a necropsy on the dead dog. Marcie Moriarty, the BC SPCA's chief prevention and enforcement officer, said the necropsy would help determine whether the dog died from a single stab wound or multiple wounds, and whether it died immediately or if there was any pain or suffering.

That investigation will include speaking with witnesses, and with cooperation from the owner of the pug, they will examine the smaller dog to confirm the police report that it had been bit during the attack.

Fincham said both parties cooperated with police and they are not considering charges at this time.

The attack comes a little more than a month after Burnaby made it tougher for residents to own dogs the city considers vicious, including pit bulls.

That city boosted fines and impound periods for dogs involved in vicious incidents. Dog owners can now be fined $500 if their pet bites someone, or $200 if they are aggressive without biting. The impound period is 21 days, with a $400 fee for dogs designated vicious.

In Vancouver, the fine for an unmuzzled aggressive dog at $500, and the fee for an impounded aggressive dog is as high as $430.

mattrobinson@postmedia.com

© Copyright (c) The Vancouver Sun


Read more: http://www.vancouversun.com/news/st...acks+smaller/9192995/story.html#ixzz2lItRNld7

I guess that guy didn't read the threads here telling him it wouldn't work. ;)
 
Too bad the situation had to escalate to that level.

I wonder what sort of folder he was carrying (ie: menacing tactical or old timey slipjoint) and what sort of legal ramifications he might be facing now if any for stabbing the dog.
 
It's too bad but I would've done the same thing. Gotta protect your own. I'd give the owner a chance but good luck with a pit bull.
 
I'll bet it was a Case Peanut hehe! Sucks all around but I didn't read anything about the pitbull taking the knife off of the guy to use it against him, hmmm....
 
First, I wanna say pits aren't aggressive unless raised that way or if they have mental issues, which is usually apparent.

Second, I guess this guy was trained in "canine knife fighting", because the forum experts say you can't use a knife to attack or defend without seriously hurting yourself!:rolleyes:

Edit: Dang, Crom beat me to it!
 
Sucks all around but I didn't read anything about the pitbull taking the knife off of the guy to use it against him, hmmm....

Second, I guess this guy was trained in "canine knife fighting", because the forum experts say you can't use a knife to attack or defend without seriously hurting yourself!:rolleyes:

Yes, I too was waiting for the back and forth as the dog and man took the knife from each other in a continuous cycle of disarmament. :D

I totally skimmed over that line in the article... :foot::D

Thanks Stabman. :thumbup:

No problem. :)
 
That's why the "experts" get their own special room. Oh, I have a pit/sharpei mix and she's the sweetest dog I think I've ever had the honor to share my home
sallysk8.jpg with.
 
Most vitals can be hit easily with a 3", as long as the blade has a lock and is sharp, folders work great for tactical situations.
 
If another dog attacked my Pugs, I would try and kill it with whatever was at my disposal. Whether that be my hands or my knife. I grew up with Rotties, I know things can go south, I have been in the middle of dominance fights (not fun). I try to keep my animals on a short leash when on walks to avoid such situations...
 
Yes, I too was waiting for the back and forth as the dog and man took the knife from each other in a continuous cycle of disarmament. :D



No problem. :)
I just had a visual of the knife fight in the Bourne trilogy with the enemy agent replaced by a dog. Oh, the lawlz.
 
Just want to make sure its known- the attacking dog could of been any breed or mutt, that it was a pit has no real effect on the outcome.

That's all I'm gonna preach in the subject, I own 3 pit's and a wolf hybrid, all of them are the nicest dogs and are totally safe for my family (including my 19 month old) and friends to torment without issue, also other animals including cats.
 
Unfortunately, the only dogs that get any news mention are "pit bulls".

AverBitesCity_chart.jpg


Edit: And these are just reported bites. Just Bing "dog bite statistics per year by breed"
 
This is a knife thread, not a pit bull thread.

All attacking dogs are fair game to be stabbed, clubbed, tased, sprayed or shot.
 
Thanks for posting that story Stabman. I have a long list of documented incidents of people successfully using knives to defend themselves and their dogs from attacking dogs. I like to post those incidents whenever people like to say "You can't defend yourself against a dog with a knife". I will be adding this incident to my list.

Although I certainly recognize that neither a knife, nor any weapon, offers any guarantee of success when defending against a four-legged threat or a two-legged threat, obviously they can be very effective.
 
I always wonder about the 'they'll take the knife and use it against you' trope. I'm not an expert by any stretch, but I've been used as a punching bag/crash test dummy by a number of friends that train pretty seriously and they've all stressed how difficult it is to perform a disarm that leaves you in control of your opponents knife.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top