My experience in the $2500 +/- price range is to go with a mid-90s Accord, Camry or Maxima. The closer to 100,000 miles the better. Check Craigslist if you have access to it in your town and be prepared to move fast on the good deals. My son just picked up a one owner 93 Maxima with 94K for $2300. With the Accords and Camrys you don't have to be freaked out even with 150,000 miles on them. The biggest issue on these is to know when the timing belt was changed. Otherwise they are usually good to go.
Jack
Jack