C.R.K.T - M21 vs. Benchmade 551 (Griptilian)

It would be sad if the "entry level" Benchmade didn't cost 25% more than the CRKT staple with an overall reduction in both fit and finish and material quality. Take a look at the little lines on the butt of your minigrip where they finished making the FRN scales.

And of course, if it were actually superior. The only thing it can be considered universally is comparable. For you, it might be an easy choice, but I own both, and I use both for different reasons.

Nonetheless, between the two, I'd probably choose the minigrip. But that's my preference. Actually, I just ordered another minigrip today.

That's how you'll know I'm unbiased.
 
I can't speak about the CRKT because I haven't used one, but I've used a 551 for my EDC for a little over a year now and I haven't had a single problem with it yet. This is the first knife that I've had with an axis lock and I think I'll be sticking with them when this knife needs to be replaced. The blade is just under the legal limit for Maryland (where I live/spend most of my time) and it tends to keep an edge fairly well. Overall it's a great knife and when the time comes to replace mine I'll probably end up buying another 551.
 
@ Artfully Martial

Where's your different in use between M21 and BM551 ??
(Spear-Point vs. Drop-Point -blade)

But that's two allround blade-shapes, i mean!
 
BM Grips is on sale at gpknives. Grips $47.50 and Mini 42.50.
http://www.gpknives.com/store/Benchmade-Knives.html?page=2
I never saw such a good price on ebay. I have BM551 and I like it a lot. Also I have a knife with AUS8 blade, made in Seki Japan. Both steels easy to sharpen with sharpmaker. I had BM520, it was very heavy knife to compare to 551 Grip, also it looks much bigger because blade is wider, blade length of Grip and BM 520 is the same-3.4".
R
 
But there's only the Griptilian with combo-edge. And i want one with plain blade!
Where is the 551 already with 154CM Steel in offeer??


And i asked them if they have the 551 as well!


But i can get the M21 for about 40 bucks!

If the 520 is too heavy for you i would take it likely ;-)
 
Those are good prices, however, if you do decide on the minigrip, I highly recommend the Cabela's D2 model which is about 70 dollars. It's worth the upgrade though.

I like both blade shapes, but I definitely prefer the M21--and to be fair, I prefer the M21's blade shape over my M16 too. I only have one recurved knife (41MC), but it has really grown on me. The slicing power of recurves is unparalleled. Both blade shapes are fine though and unless you really are going to do a ton of slicing, I would pick whatever I think looks the best. Don't forget that you can get the minigrip in tanto also, which is an excellent profile. My first minigrip is the regular style Cabela's, the one I ordered today is a tanto.

My use of the knives doesn't change for blade shape. But it does change for other things. First of all, the M16/11K has a slimmer profile, so for certain clothes, it just works better. Virtually no knife can be opened as fast as an M16/M21, but the axis lock knives with practice come pretty dang close--and better yet, they can be flicked closed. Therefor, when I might need to open and close my knife over and over again periodically, the minigrip gets carried over the M16. The black TiNi finish on my M16 is super tough, but the black finish on my d2 minigrip scratches reallllly easily, so for cutting through stuff, the M16 gets carried, but this probably won't affect you. Also, I think the M16 looks a lot more expensive so when it's more visible, I like to use it. And lastly, because my minigrip is D2, I'm a bit more cautious about what I do with it rust and stain wise, but again, may not be an issue for you.
 
Thanks, but you don't help me so much ;-)


And do omeone know how thick the 551 & M21 are?

I can't find this information anywhere in net, as well on the sites which you sayed me!
 
Is there the possibility of you finding them in a local shop.... maybe holding/opening them will tip you one side or the other.
 
bh49 said:
BM Grips is on sale at gpknives. Grips $47.50 and Mini 42.50.
http://www.gpknives.com/store/Benchmade-Knives.html?page=2
I never saw such a good price on ebay. I have BM551 and I like it a lot. Also I have a knife with AUS8 blade, made in Seki Japan. Both steels easy to sharpen with sharpmaker. I had BM520, it was very heavy knife to compare to 551 Grip, also it looks much bigger because blade is wider, blade length of Grip and BM 520 is the same-3.4".
R

Yes this was the site I was referring to in my earlier post, I didn't know if the moderators allowed web links to vendors.

I ordered the black coated Grip with thumb stud for 52.00.
 
And the width of the two blades? I don't no where do you have this informtaion, but i can't find it somewhere!
 
I've owned about 10 different CRKTS. Only liked one model, the Mirage. And it wore out fairly quickly. Their liner locks all wore quickly IMHO.

I've had a few Grips and love them. Last a long time too if you don't lose them.

Phil
 
Achso, aber das hilft mir ja nicht soo sehr weiter. Das heißt du favorisierst das Benchmade Griptilian?

Allright, but you don't help me soo much. than you favore the Benchmade Griptilian?
 
OK kennst du einen günstigen Anbieter der das 551 mit ebener Klinge(!) anbietet?
-Hab nicht sehr viel sinnvoles gefunden, bisher!


OK do you know some cheap vendor, which has the 551 with plain(!) blade?
-I don't find any meaningful so far!
 
Back
Top