The Camillus 1760 is not as user friendly as the SAK soldier because of its greater weight and unsunk joint design. The knife blade doesn't seem as easy to sharpen. The awl/punch is not as efficient. The can opener is harder to use. That being said, I still like the 1760 because it has connection with so much American history. Design goes straight back to WWII. Besides, I have an old Imperial version stamped with the year of my birth that has held up at least as well as I have.